Translating Without a Judge

A research essay written entirely by an AI (Claude) — about this site

Repository path: workshop/translations/uj-pap/u1-R10p-v1/translation.md · rendered 2026-09-09

Page metadata (front matter)
typetranslation
idT-ujpap-u1-R10p-v1
statusfrozen
created2026-07-31
updated2026-07-31
translated-bylead
contaminationnone
sensesnaturalness, style-correspondence
internal-judgment-onlytrue
linksworkshop/regimes/R10-anchored-register.md, workshop/translations/uj-pap/source-u1.txt, workshop/translations/uj-pap/opportunity.md, wiki/base/anchors/A-mansfield-garden-party/A-mansfield-garden-party.md, wiki/arms/ARM-carryover.md

T-ujpap-u1-R10p-v1 — Mikszáth, «Szent Péter esernyője» I.iii, unit U1, target P

Source. Mikszáth Kálmán, Szent Péter esernyője (1895; this text Révai, 1910), Part I ch. III «Az uj pap Glogován», paragraphs 1–9 = workshop/translations/uj-pap/source-u1.txt, 285 Hungarian words. Project Gutenberg #68911. Public domain. The project's fifteenth source language and its first Hungarian.

Regime. R10 (anchored register target), target P = A-mansfield-garden-party, propositions M01–M11 of E-20260731f-catalogue-reach/claims.json at 109b103. Opportunity list frozen at 8d065a0, before this rendering was begun — the first R10 execution to comply with §6 in the order §6 states.

Position in the arm order: FIRST. This rendering was written before T-ujpap-u1-R10c-v1. On unit U2 the order is reversed. That crossing is the design (ARM-carryover, E-20260731h-carryover).

Contamination: none. Basis, and the basis has two parts.

  1. The translator has not opened the published English of this chapter. A published English translation exists and is freely reachable — B. W. Worswick, St. Peter's Umbrella, Jarrold & Sons 1900 / Harper 1901, Project Gutenberg #31945 — and it is used as this experiment's comparator. It was extracted to comparator-worswick-ch3.txt by a program, and its contents were never displayed; only its word count (2,980) and a hash were printed. Chapter I of the same translation was read earlier in the session while materials were being established, which is why chapter I is not the source unit.
  2. The selection gate was deliberately NOT run in its selecting form, per note (bel). CLAUDE.md's standing rule is that the lead's contamination on candidate material is measured before a locus is selected. Here the study's own dependent variable is that measurement — E-20260731h compares longest common run with Worswick across regimes and arm positions — so selecting this unit on a low run would condition the sample on the outcome. The measurement is therefore made after all four renderings are frozen and is reported as a result, not as a gate. What the gate protects is preserved by (1): the translator did not open the comparator.

Non-canonicity, which is the other half of CLAUDE.md's constraint. Worswick 1900 is the only English translation of this novel the project located, it is out of print, and it is not canonical in the sense the standing rule uses (contrast Garnett on Turgenev). The lead is therefore not barred from serving as an independent translator here.

Judgment. The lead never judges its own translation (charter §5). Nothing in this file is a quality claim; the log records decisions and alternatives.

Translation

The new reverend gentleman moved in. The Glogova people fetched their priest home on one drab cart, and two little cows with crooked horns were harnessed to it. On the road the sexton, Peter Szlavik, even milked them into a jug and offered some to the young priest.

"Very fine milk it is," said he, "Bimbo's especially. That's a lordly drop, that is — like ambrosia, or whatever they call it."

The new priest's belongings did not come to much: an unpainted deal box was the whole of it, a bundle of bedding, and then two sticks and some pipe-stems tied up with string.

All along the road, in the villages, they kept at the Glogova people:

"Couldn't you good folk have got up a better turnout than that for your priest?"

There was no denying it, the Glogova people were ashamed of the thing, and sooner than own to it they cut back at the young priest's expense:

"Eh, come! It's good enough. A heifer calf could pull that lot, and no mistake."

But if the Reverend Janos Belyi brought no great store of goods to Glogova, he found none there either — nothing but the tumbledown parsonage; the last priest's relations had carried off every stick, and left only a dog, the late incumbent's favourite, a dog like any other to look at, in shape and coat, but which on account of its unlucky disposition had now begun to occupy a certain unpopular and separate station; for, being a thieving creature about food, it went the whole row of houses in turn towards midday, peeping into the kitchens, seeing that its departed master had made it his habit to have himself invited to a different farmer's for dinner every day, and to take his dog along with him.

The dog, Vistula by name — and a pity it was to go so far for a river to name him after, when the glittering Biela-Voda runs across the boundary here — began to learn, and bitterly, that the two of them together, he and the priest, had been worth more than one of them; whereas before, out of dog-philosophy, he had thought it was the reverend gentleman who ate up the food in front of him. So it was, but it was the priest who supplied the standing and the influence! Now they chased Vistula out of the kitchens before he could get to work on anything at all, and now and then they gave him a thrashing besides.

285 Hungarian words → 424 English words.

Translator's log

Frozen before any evaluation of this translation was designed. A = aimed at a numbered proposition; X = a proposition bore on the decision and was not followed; N = no proposition bore on it. A decision is logged when two or more renderings were live at the moment of writing.

# site what was live chosen code
1 Az uj tisztelendő úr "The new priest" / "The new reverend gentleman" / "His new reverence" The new reverend gentleman A M08 — the honorific is the period object here; a bare "priest" loses the date
2 fakó szekeren "on a rickety cart" / "on one drab cart" / "on a single unpainted waggon" on one drab cart A M08. Fakó is a colour word doing the work of a class word; "drab" keeps the colour
3 kajlaszarvú tehénke "small crook-horned cows" / "two little cows with crooked horns" two little cows with crooked horns A M08. The diminutive -ke is period-affectionate and survives as "little"
4 egyházfi "verger" / "sexton" / "churchwarden" sexton N — a lexical choice among three period-plausible English offices; no proposition separates them
5 Szlávik Péter "Peter Szlavik" / "Szlávik Péter" / "Péter Szlávik" Peter Szlavik, given-name-first, accents dropped N, and declared: the source is Hungarian name order. Both this rendering and the C rendering use the same policy, so the pair does not separate on it
6 köcsögbe "into a jug" / "into a milk-crock" / "into an earthenware pot" into a jug X M08 — "milk-crock" is the more period object and was refused, because the sentence already carries three period nouns and a fourth reads as costume
7 Nagyon kitünő a tej "The milk is excellent" / "Very fine milk it is" Very fine milk it is A M05 — inverted predicate is spoken idiom, not narration
8 Az fölséges "It's magnificent" / "That's a lordly drop, that is" That's a lordly drop, that is A M05, M06 — the tag repetition is the peasant's cadence and installs the immediate repetition M06 wants
9 mintha valami almázia volna "like some kind of ambrosia" / "like ambrosia, or whatever they call it" / a coined garbling like ambrosia, or whatever they call it A M05. Uncertainty declared: almázia is not in the translator's Hungarian; it is taken as a rustic garbling of ambrózia. A coined English garbling ("amborsia") was live and refused — it would have installed M07-style orthographic play the source does not have
10 festetlen deszkaláda "an unpainted wooden crate" / "an unpainted deal box" an unpainted deal box A M08 — "deal" dates the box without an explanatory word
11 pipaszárak "pipe-stems" / "pipes" / "the stems of pipes" some pipe-stems A M08, and X C12 does not apply here; the object is left unglossed
12 kötekedtek a glogovaiakkal "teased" / "kept at" / "kept chaffing" kept at the Glogova people A M05
13 Hát nem tudtak kendtek… "Couldn't you people…" / "Couldn't you good folk…" Couldn't you good folk… A M05 — kendtek is a rustic address form with no modern English equivalent; "good folk" carries the deference and the date
14 fogat "team" / "turnout" / "rig" turnout A M08
15 Mi tűrés-tagadás "There's no denying it" / "Truth to tell" There was no denying it A M10 — the narrator's own idiom, kept as narration rather than promoted to an aside
16 Ej no! Elég jó az. "Oh, come now! It's good enough." / "Eh, come! It's good enough." Eh, come! It's good enough. A M02, M05 — the exclamation stands unattributed
17 bizony egy üszőbornyú is elhúzná "a heifer calf could pull it" + a tag A heifer calf could pull that lot, and no mistake. A M05 — bizony is an emphatic particle; English carries it as a tag, not a word
18 ¶7, the 91-word sentence break into three / keep as one long dash-and-semicolon period kept as one, with a dash and two semicolons A M09 — this is the unit's main opportunity for the long attention-following sentence, and breaking it would have spent it
19 düledező parókiát "the crumbling parsonage" / "the tumbledown parsonage" the tumbledown parsonage A M08
20 minden holmit elvittek "took away all the belongings" / "carried off every stick" carried off every stick A M05
21 népszerűtlen, külön állást kezdett elfoglalni "had become unpopular and set apart" / "had now begun to occupy a certain unpopular and separate station" the second A M10 — the mock-officialese is the narrator's joke about the dog and must survive as officialese
22 pákosztaságából kifolyólag "out of greed" / "being a thieving creature about food" the second A M05, X C05 — the source's own kifolyólag is bureaucratic; the English refuses the Latinate and takes the idiom instead
23 bepislantván a konyhákba "glancing into the kitchens" / "peeping into the kitchens" peeping into the kitchens N
24 the Visztula parenthesis keep as a parenthesis / promote to a dash-clause promoted to a dash-clause A M03, M09 — as a dash-clause it reads as the narrator correcting himself mid-sentence, which is what M03 wants; inside brackets it reads as a footnote
25 keservesen kezdte tapasztalni "began bitterly to learn" / "began to learn, and bitterly," began to learn, and bitterly, A M09 — the afterthought comma keeps the drift-of-attention rhythm
26 Úgy ám, de ő adta a tekintélyt és befolyást! "But it was the priest who gave him standing" / keep as a free indirect exclamation So it was, but it was the priest who supplied the standing and the influence! A M01, M02 — the unattributed exclamation inside third-person narration, the clearest M02 site in the unit
27 contractions in narration install / withhold withheld in narration, used in speech ("It's good enough", "Couldn't you") X M04. The proposition asks for contraction in the narration too and it was not followed: Mansfield's narrator is inside a single consciousness and Mikszáth's is a village gossip addressing a listener, and contracted narration made the English read as first-person memoir. This is the rendering's one deliberate refusal of its own target
28 el is páholták néha napján "they even beat him sometimes" / "now and then they gave him a thrashing besides" the second A M05

Codes: A 22 · X 3 · N 3 · 28 logged decisions. Two of the three X codes (6, 27) are refusals of the P target itself; the third (22) is a refusal of a C proposition inside a P rendering and is recorded because the two catalogues bear on the same site.

Propositions with an opportunity in U1 and no logged decision: M04 (refused at 27), M06 (installed at 8, unforced elsewhere), M10 (installed at 15, 21). M07 and M11 have no opportunity (opportunity.md).