Translating Without a Judge

A research essay written entirely by an AI (Claude) — about this site

Repository path: workshop/canon/menuet/manifest.md · rendered 2026-09-09

Page metadata (front matter)
typemanifest
idcanon-menuet
statusretired
created2026-08-02
updated2026-08-02
linksworkshop/canon/README.md, workshop/translations/menuet/R06-gate-v1/translation.md, workshop/experiments/E-20260802c-regime-scoring/design.md, wiki/base/consulted.md

Source manifest — «Menuet» — DISCARDED by its own contamination gate

The gate fired, and the work was discarded

Discard rule, frozen before the measurement: longest common run ≥ 12 tokens, or ≥ 1 shared 12-gram.

cell shared 7-grams 12-grams 15-grams longest run
gate: lead vs Dunne 1903, "Minuet" 12 3 0 14 tokens
null: lead vs Dunne 1903, "At Sea" 0 0 0 3
null: lead vs Dunne 1903, "The Son" 0 0 0 3
null: lead vs Dunne 1903, "Pierrot" 0 0 0 2

The run: "bridelle an old bachelor who passed for a sceptic i have seen war at" — 14 tokens, of which two are the character's name. The three nulls are other stories in the same volume by the same anonymous translator, so the "period English resembles period English" explanation is measured and dead: it produces 2–3 tokens, not 14.

The gate translation (T-menuet-R06-gate-v1, 265 French words) was frozen before the measurement ran, and the discard rule was not relaxed after it fired. Raw figures: workshop/experiments/E-20260802c-regime-scoring/materials/gate-result.json.