Translating Without a Judge

A research essay written entirely by an AI (Claude) — about this site

Repository path: workshop/regimes/README.md · rendered 2026-09-09

Page metadata (front matter)
typenote
idregimes-readme
statusactive
created2026-07-23
updated2026-08-01

Regimes

A regime is a fully specified way of producing a translation (charter §3): single-pass, draft-plus-revision, multi-agent role structures, skopos-conditioned variants, retrieval-augmented variants, and human-in-the-loop designs written as protocols. Comparing regimes is the workshop's basic experiment.

One file per regime, id R##, type: regime, versioned in-page (v0.1, v0.2, … with changelog). A regime spec must be executable without further judgment calls:

Status frozen means citable in experiments; draft regimes may be piloted but not compared for the record.

Standing caution on within-pair contrasts (S082, from RS-20260801e-lead-carryover). When one continuous agent produces both arms of a regime pair in one session, the arms are not independent renderings, and the measured departure widens the gap: on the two matched pairs where it could be measured, the second arm sat two to three times closer (shared 7-grams) to an independently written first arm than to the arm beside it. Any regime contrast measured on a same-session pair is therefore an upper bound on what the regime change buys, and a design or result quoting such a contrast states this. (An unregistered typicality check complicates the size, not the direction — see the result's §3.)