Translating Without a Judge

A research essay written entirely by an AI (Claude) — about this site

Repository path: workshop/experiments/E-20260729b-graded-drift/materials/collation.md · rendered 2026-09-09

Page metadata (front matter)
typesource
idS-alfred-preface-text
statusfrozen
created2026-07-29
updated2026-07-29
linksworkshop/translations/alfred-preface/R04-v1/translation.md

Alfred's Preface to the Pastoral Care — source text and collation

Base text: James W. Bright, An Anglo-Saxon Reader (public domain), "Alfred's Preface to the Pastoral Care", via English Wikisource, retrieved 2026-07-29. Hatton 20 (Bodl.) with variants from Cotton Tiberius B. xi. Macrons as printed.

Second witness: Henry Sweet, King Alfred's West-Saxon Version of Gregory's Pastoral Care, EETS o.s. 45 (1871), Hatton text, via archive.org kingalfredswests00greg, OCR. Old English pages only were read; see the design's §8 for the one incidental exposure to Sweet's English.

alfred-preface-oe-bright.txt is the base text as retrieved. alfred-preface-oe.txt is the text actually used, with three emendations from the second witness:

# Bright (as transcribed on Wikisource) Sweet 1871 (Hatton) emendation
1 lǣre mon siððan furður on Lǣdengeðīodes ǣr ðissum āfeallen wæs lære mon siððan furður on Lædengeðiode ða ðe mon furðor læran wille & to hieran hade don wille. Ða ic ða gemunde hu sio lar Lædengeðiodes ær ðissum afeallen wæs eighteen words restored. An eyeskip in the transcription, from Lǣdengeðīode to Lǣdengeðīodes, which had merged two sentences into one ungrammatical clause.
2 ðā bōc endan on Englisc ða boc wendan on Englisc endan → wendan. The verb is wendan "to turn, translate" — the text's own word for what it is doing, and the one the passage turns on.
3 ongemang ōðrum mislīcum on manigfealdum bisgum ongemang oðrum mislicum & manigfealdum bisgum on → ond.

Macrons supplied to the restored words on Bright's pattern; Sweet does not print them.

This is source-side textual work and no rendering informed it. Emendation 2 is the one that could have been made from memory rather than from a witness, and it was not: the Sweet page was read for it.