Journal, 2026-11-18
Cycle 1: review
What this cycle did. The mode selector (tools/next_mode.py, which picks each cycle's job from how long each kind of work has waited) chose a review. There were no drafts and no reader reports, so the cycle continued the coverage pass: a re-reading of the most important band-1 entries (band 1 is the most common words), most senses first, asking of each one whether a real, current meaning or a common fixed phrase is missing. Four entries were read: common (adjective), condition (noun), control (verb), and copy (verb). Before the start, the pre-flight checks found no open pull requests, nothing in the owner's inbox, no reader reports, and two old branches already merged and already listed for pruning.
What was added before review.
- common: a subsense for common courtesy and common decency (basic good behavior that everyone should show), and the collocations common ground, the common good, and common knowledge.
- condition: the phrase the human condition, and in mint condition and under difficult conditions.
- control: a research sense, control for something (make sure one factor does not change a study's results); the "make work" sense now covers animals and balls (control a horse, control the ball); the "limit" sense now covers limits set by rules (strictly controlled drugs). take over was removed as a synonym, because it means gaining control, not having it.
- copy: the radio sense (Do you copy?, Copy that), and a missing grammar pattern for copy down the questions.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. The two automated reviewers (reviewer A and reviewer B, models from different labs) raised 38 issues, 3 of them blocking. I applied 34 and rejected 4.
- Blocking: an example said the common cold is caused by a virus, a checkable science claim, which our examples must not contain (both reviewers); it now reads It's only the common cold, nothing serious. Reviewer B also said control for takes no direct object, so it is intransitive; I agreed, matching how depend on and rely on are coded.
- Three facts were stated twice, against the rule that one fact lives in one field: common's usage note repeated the comparative forms already in the inflections note; condition's translators' note repeated that the situation sense is plural; control's false-friend note repeated the learner error about check. Each copy was removed.
- Smaller fixes: common knowledge moved to the "shared" sense, where it belongs; the old-fashioned British "low class" sense of common now covers things as well as people; condition's "rule" signpost became "requirement", and the medical sense lost a "medicine" field label, since a heart condition is an everyday phrase; control's core idea and its feelings sense (which must cover control yourself) were rewritten, and two examples that did not fit their definitions were replaced; copy lost two weak cross-references (rip, borrow) and a needless explanation.
- Rejected: a request to mark mutual friend with single asterisks (it is named as a phrase, so double is right); a claim that with the condition that is not a learner error (it is a common translation from other languages); a request for a "radio" field label (no such label exists in our closed list, and copy that is used widely in casual speech); and a claim that copying an idea is making a copy rather than imitating someone.
One back-link the cross-reference tool could not place (receive as a synonym of radio copy) was resolved by dropping the synonym, since receive's radio sense is about machines picking up signals.
Spend. US$0.18 this cycle, all on reviewer B and the pronunciation check; reviewer A runs on the owner's subscription at no ledger cost. The day's budget is US$15.
What did not work. Nothing failed. The budget ledger reset itself at the UTC day change, as designed.
What is next. The coverage pass stands at 369 entries; next are cup, dance, dark, and date.
For the owner. Nothing new.
Cycle 2: build
What this cycle did. The mode selector chose a build: new entries drawn from the queue (the ordered list of words waiting to be written). I claimed eight and wrote all eight, each a noun in band 2 (the second most common of the five frequency bands): seminar, senior citizen, sequence, shake, shed, shift, shopping center, and shortage. The selector allowed up to twelve; eight full entries were a better use of the cycle than twelve thin ones.
A few points about the entries themselves:
- seminar has two senses: the small university class, and a training meeting (a sales seminar), with a note on how it differs from a lecture.
- senior citizen carries a usage note that many people now say seniors or older people, and that some find the phrase a little old-fashioned.
- sequence has four senses: a series of events, the order things come in (out of sequence), a part of a film (the opening sequence), and a number pattern.
- shake covers the movement (give the bottle a shake), the drink, and the shakes, with three informal phrases: a fair shake, in two shakes, and no great shakes.
- shift covers a period of work (with a subsense for the group of workers), a change (a shift in opinion), the keyboard key, and a simple dress.
- shortage has a short note on choosing between it and lack: a water shortage, but a lack of confidence.
Pronunciation. Our check sends each transcription to a panel of three models and, for American English, the open CMU pronouncing dictionary; a transcription is "verified" when at least two votes agree with it. All sixteen transcriptions were verified. The British form of senior citizen got only one agreeing vote at first, with the other votes split; a second panel run gave two of three, which meets the rule.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. The two reviewers raised 25 issues, none blocking. I applied 21 and rejected 4.
- Two core ideas (the one-sentence summary that opens an entry with three or more senses) did not cover every sense, on shake and shift; both were rewritten.
- Reviewer A pointed out two real gaps. A shake can be made with a powder and no ice cream (a protein shake), so the drink definition was widened. American English uses shift for the stick that changes a car's gears (a stick shift), which is now its own sense, marked American. The graveyard shift (night work) was added as a collocation.
- We built a shed at the bottom of the garden is British in flavor, and our main variety is American, so it now reads in the backyard (both reviewers).
- An invented learner error on sequence and a culture note on senior citizen that only repeated the usage note were removed. Weak synonyms (conference for seminar, move and dress for shift) were dropped, and scene was moved from synonym to "compare" on sequence.
- Rejected: removing the note that the shakes always takes the and a plural verb (the grammar value alone does not say this); calling the keyboard key uncountable because one says press shift (key names go without an article, as in press enter); dropping at and in the shopping center (which preposition to use is a real question for learners); and dropping the link to gear, which now fits the new sense.
The cross-reference tool adds back-links between entries automatically, but it will not guess which sense of the other entry to use. Four were placed by hand: seminar on lecture, sequence on scene, shed on garage, and shift on change.
Spend. US$0.22 this cycle; US$0.41 of the US$15 daily cap so far today.
What did not work. Two schema mistakes in my first draft (a wrong countability value and the wrong shape for a word-choice note) were caught by the validator before any review and fixed.
What is next. The build queue continues after shortage. The coverage pass continues with cup, dance, dark, and date.
For the owner. Nothing new.
Cycle 3: lint
What this cycle did. Ten cycles had passed since the last lint, so the mode selector required one. A lint is a maintenance pass over the whole dictionary and its knowledge base (the wiki/, the project's notes and rules). Some checks are done by scripts and some by reading. No entries were written and no senses were changed.
The script checks.
- Size caps on the rule files and the wiki: all within limits. Links inside the knowledge base: all 782 pages resolve.
- Cross-references. When one entry names another as a synonym, antonym, or "compare" word, the other entry should point back. The tool added three missing back-links (salesperson to person, seafood to fish, seat belt to belt). It flagged five pairs where it could not tell which sense should carry the link, and I settled them by hand. Three of these came from this morning's first cycle: there I removed copy's links to borrow and rip and control's link to take over, but the other side of each link was still in place. The house rule is that removing a link removes its mirror too, so I removed those three. The other two were placed: scenery now compares with scene, and screw with nut.
- Six old claim files (records of which run reserved which words) were cleared.
- Thirty-six words added to the queue since the last lint had no frequency band yet. Bands come only from a vote of three models on one written scale, never from a person or the drafter. The vote cost under one cent. No word split the voters by more than one band, so nothing needed settling by hand, and all 36 are now ready to be built in their turn.
- Three standing reports came out as before. 1,043 pairs where an entry is named as a synonym but may lack a matching sense, left for the review cycles to check. 317 definitions that use their own headword, nearly all harmless (a walk defined through walk); a review judges each one. And the same six notes that point to entries not yet planned.
Reviewer precision. For each reviewer and each kind of issue, "precision" is the share of its issues that I applied rather than rejected. A pair that falls under 30 percent over twenty or more decisions is switched off. Reviewer A stands at 0.85 overall and reviewer B at 0.83. No new pair fell under the line. Reviewer B's spelling-and-format checks are at 0.39 and stay on by the owner's ruling. I added this pass to wiki/notes/reviewer-precision.md, along with a line noting that the previous pass's numbers were only in the log.
The reading checks. Every wiki page is listed in the index. The open-questions page has nothing open. The curator file (questions left for the owner) has no duplicate lines. The log has an entry for every cycle. I found no contradictions between pages. This morning's branch was deleted automatically when its pull request merged, so it needs no prune line.
Spend. US$0.006 this cycle, for the band vote. US$0.42 so far today of the US$15 cap.
What did not work. The band-vote settle and apply steps look for a file named votes.tsv unless they are given the unbanded vote file with --votes. This is the known usage (wiki/notes/band-vote-unbanded-overwrite.md), so I recorded no new problem.
What is next. The next lint is due after ten more cycles. Building and the coverage pass continue as before.
For the owner. Nothing new.
Cycle 4: build
What this cycle did. The fourth and last cycle the run allows. The mode selector chose a build again, and I claimed six words from the queue rather than the twelve allowed, so that each entry would be as full as the earlier ones. The six were all added to the queue because existing entries pointed to them. Dominate came from this morning's review of control. Screw (the verb) came from screw (the noun). Grant came from scholarship, hot dog from sausage, maid from servant, and saving from savings.
The entries:
- dominate has three senses: to control (a few big companies dominate the market), to be the most important part of something (the story dominated the news), and to stand high above a place (a castle dominates the town).
- screw has four senses: to fix something with screws, to turn something into place (screw the lid on), to cheat someone (slang), and to have sex (vulgar). The style guide says vulgar words are included and labeled, not left out.
- grant covers money given for study or research, with notes on how it differs from a scholarship and a loan, and a formal sense for an official gift of land or a right.
- hot dog, maid (with maid of honor), and saving (an amount saved, and the act of saving).
All twelve transcriptions were verified by the pronunciation panel on the first try.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. 33 issues, 2 blocking. I applied 27 and rejected 6.
- Blocking: the first sense of screw was defined as "fix something with screws", which uses the headword's own form in its definition. It now reads "fix something to something else by turning small pointed pieces of metal into it". On grant, the note "a loan must be paid back; a grant does not" is ungrammatical; it now ends "a grant need not be".
- Both reviewers noted that screw it (I give up on this) and screw you (a rude insult) were missing. Both were added as phrases with the right labels. Reviewer A also found that the entry described the cheating sense three ways: "informal" in the summary line, "slang" in its label, and "rude" in the note. All three now agree. The summary line also used two words outside our defining vocabulary, which the vocabulary check caught, and it was reworded.
- grant sense 2 now covers the thing given as well as the act of giving (a grant of land). Sausage was dropped as a synonym of hot dog, since it is the wider word; it now sits under "see also". The translators' note on hot dog now simply says it contains no dog meat. On maid, the note on cleaner now says that word is mainly British. On saving, the second sense was widened to cover time and energy (energy saving), and a note that repeated the learner-error note was removed.
- Rejected: a request to split a pattern that is already one value on our closed list; a request to add a pattern for an intransitive use, which takes none; a request to merge two screw senses that many languages translate differently; adding screw around to this entry (a phrasal verb gets its own entry, so I linked to it instead, which also queues it); a request for a second example in a subsense, where one is allowed; and a claim that savings cannot be the plural of saving, when it is the plural of the first sense.
Five back-links were placed by hand, on cheat, loan, servant, cleaner, and savings.
Spend. US$0.18 this cycle; US$0.59 for the whole run, of the US$15 daily cap.
What did not work. My first draft gave the vulgar sense of screw only one example, and the validator requires two. A second example was added before review.
What is next. The build queue continues in its order. The coverage pass continues with cup, dance, dark, and date. The next lint is due after ten more cycles, and the next weekly digest on 2026-11-21.
For the owner. Nothing new. The entries for screw include a vulgar sense and a rude phrase, labeled as such under the style guide's rule on taboo words, in case you want to look at how they read.