Journal, 2026-11-18, second run (run 20261118T164420Z-28iaq2)
Cycle 1: review
What the cycle did. The scheduler chose review: rereading entries that have already been published, to fix and complete them. There were no draft (unreviewed) entries and no open "Entry report" issues from readers, so the cycle continued the coverage pass. That pass is one of your rulings of 2026-10-24: the most important words (band 1, the most frequent of the five frequency bands) are read again one by one to check that every current meaning, common phrase, and grammar pattern is there. Before this cycle 369 entries had been through it. This cycle took the next four: cup (noun), dance (verb), dark (adjective), and date (noun). The pass now stands at 373.
What was added before the reviewers saw the entries.
- cup: the cup of a bra and the hole in golf (the first draft of this addition put them in one sense; see below), and a learner error that really happens: two coffee cups when two cups of coffee is meant.
- dance: leading a partner (He danced her across the floor) and dancing a role in a ballet (She danced the lead role).
- dark: a theater with no show or a website that has stopped working (The theater is dark on Mondays, go dark); dark chocolate, dark meat, and dark beer; a dark look, meaning an angry one.
- date: the dates of a band's tour; the phrase save the date; the collocations date night, double date, play date.
What the reviewers found, and what I decided. Each entry went to the two-reviewer panel. The reviewers are two AI models from different companies: reviewer A is a Claude model at no cost, and reviewer B is a Google model paid per call. Each reads every field and marks it fine or raises an issue. I then read every issue and decided whether to apply it (fix the entry in my own words) or reject it (with a logged reason). They raised 54 issues, 6 of them marked blocking (must be settled before the entry can stay published). I applied 49 and rejected 5.
The useful catches:
- My new cup sense was too vague. It lumped together a bra cup, the cup shape of a flower, and the golf hole under "a part of something that is round and hollow like a cup". That wording was also circular, since it uses the headword to define itself. It is now two senses with exact definitions (bra; golf), and the flower use was dropped. The prize sense ("a large cup...") was circular as well and now describes the object itself.
- dark defined the "dark-haired person" use with the word dark. It now reads "having black or brown hair, and often brown eyes or brown skin". Dark humor was filed under "sad, and without hope" and is now under the "cruel or frightening" sense, where it belongs.
- In date, the sense "an arrangement to meet" overlapped the romantic sense and also took in doctor's appointments, which the entry's own learner-error note says are not dates. It is now limited to social plans with friends. It's a date! and bring someone up to date became phrases of their own. Before, one was squeezed into an explanation and the other was an example that did not fit its phrase's definition.
- Five adaptation notes (notes for future translators) only repeated another field in the same entry, which breaks the "one fact, one field" rule. All five were removed.
What I rejected: a British-only label on cup competitions (they are followed everywhere); reviewer B's claim that phrases named as phrases take single asterisks (the style guide says double); removing literary from "leaves danced in the wind"; removing the note that the "avoid a subject" sense is used with around (the style guide asks for that kind of restriction to be stated there); and the claim that a dark mood is not sad.
Checks. The defining-vocabulary check (definitions should use only words on the dictionary's basic list) caught golf, waltz, tango, and valid in new definitions. All four were reworded. All gates pass.
Spend. US$0.19 for this cycle; US$0.78 of the US$15 daily cap so far today.
What did not work. Nothing broke. One thing I learned: three of the six blocking issues were in text I had just added, so a first draft written during a coverage pass needs the same circularity check as a new entry.
Next. The coverage pass continues with dance (noun), deal (verb), degree, and design. I noted dance to someone's tune for the tune entry, since idioms are filed under their first noun.
For the owner. Nothing new. The pronunciation disputes and the ten-entry samples in the weekly digests are still waiting for a session with you.
Cycle 2: build
What the cycle did. The scheduler chose build: writing new entries from the queue, the list of words waiting to be written in a fixed order. It allowed up to 12. I claimed eight, because fewer, fuller entries are better than many thin ones. All eight are band-2 nouns (band 2 is the second most frequent of the five frequency bands): scholar, shorts, sibling, sightseeing, signature, sin, site, and sixth. Each was drafted from my own knowledge and the house style guide; no published dictionary was used. Each then went through the full pipeline: the format and schema check; the inflection tool, which builds plurals from rules; the pronunciation check; the two-reviewer panel; my decisions on what they raised; and the checks again. All eight are now published as reviewed.
Some points of content: shorts is plural-only, like pants, with a learner error for a new short. Its underwear sense is marked American. sibling has a usage note: everyday speech prefers brothers and sisters. sightseeing has the common learner error go to sightseeing. signature has three senses: your written name, the thing that marks a person's style (a signature dish), and the block at the end of an email. site notes that it sounds like sight and cite, and it has the phrase on site. sixth follows the model of seventh (one of six equal parts) and has a plain note on its hard ending, ks plus the th of thin.
Pronunciation. All sixteen transcriptions (American and British for each word) passed the check, which compares several models' transcriptions with each other and with an open pronouncing dictionary (CMU). One check was close. For the American sightseeing, three of four models agreed, and the CMU dictionary differed only on where the secondary stress falls. Under the two-vote agreement rule that counts as verified.
What the reviewers found, and what I decided. The two reviewers raised 26 issues, one of them blocking. That issue was right: The song has all the signatures of the band's early work is not natural English, so I replaced it. I applied 17 issues in all. The main ones:
- the underwear example for shorts could have meant ordinary shorts, so it now says they are worn under pants;
- two patterns I had put in explanation fields (it's a sin to..., not much of a scholar) now sit in the collocations, where both reviewers wanted them;
- the idiom for my sins (British, humorous) was missing and is now added;
- the website sense of site is no longer defined with the word website, and its computing label is gone;
- the core-idea lines of three entries now cover all of their senses.
I rejected 9, each with a logged reason. Reviewer B three times asked for single asterisks around phrases named as phrases, which goes against the style guide. Signature dish is a noun used before another noun, not an adjective. "Often before another noun" is a code on the closed list. The date use of sixth (on the sixth) belongs to the number entry sixth by an existing rule.
Cross-references. The cross-reference tool adds a matching link back from each word an entry points to. It added two by itself. It could not choose the right sense in two other cases, so I placed those by hand: scholarship now points back to scholar, and crime back to sin with a one-line note on the difference.
Spend. US$0.20 for this cycle; US$0.98 of the US$15 daily cap so far today.
What did not work. My first draft used "unchecked" as a status value, but the closed list says "unverified". I also left out the empty form key in the word-family lists. The validator caught both before anything else ran.
Next. The queue continues after sixth. tenth can follow the sixth model.
For the owner. Nothing new.
Cycle 3: site
What the cycle did. The scheduler chose site: rebuild the public website from the entries and check it in a real browser. The build tool turned all 4,547 entries into 3,793 headword pages. Words with the same spelling share a page, which is why there are fewer pages than entries. No unreviewed drafts were held back, and there were no renamed entries to redirect. The built files are not committed: the site is built again by GitHub Actions when changes reach main.
The check tool opens the site in an automated browser at phone width and at desktop width and runs 79 checks. All 79 passed. Among them:
- no page scrolls sideways on a 360-pixel phone screen (all 3,799 pages were checked);
- the search box finds headwords and also phrases from their main words;
- a misspelling such as abadnon gets "Did you mean abandon?";
- a mistyped address leads to a search page;
- the sense menu jumps to the right sense;
- cross-references to words with no entry yet show in plain grey text;
- dark mode works.
I also checked by hand that this run's new material appears on the site: the golf sense of cup, save the date under date, and for my sins under sin are all there.
What the reviewers found. Nothing: this cycle uses no reviewers and costs nothing.
Spend. US$0 for this cycle; the day's total is still US$0.98 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work. Nothing; there was nothing to fix.
Next. The scheduler will choose again. Review (the coverage pass at dance as a noun) and build (the queue after sixth) are the likely next units.
For the owner. Nothing new.
Cycle 4: originality
What the cycle did. The scheduler forced an originality check, which runs every twentieth cycle. The check makes sure our wording has not drifted into the wording of a published dictionary. A tool picked ten definitions and notes at random from across the dictionary:
- part (the hair sense)
- the usage note on keep on doing
- state (verb)
- open (ready for customers)
- combine
- the phrase not give a shit under shit
- clean up (wash yourself)
- house (part of a parliament)
- a phrase under time meaning "at some time long ago"
- credit (verb)
For each one I ran an exact-phrase web search to see whether a published dictionary uses the same words. I also asked reviewer B once whether any of them read as copied.
What was found. No search found any of the ten wordings in a published dictionary. Reviewer B called all ten original. Two cases still made me cautious:
- state: we defined it as "say or write something clearly and definitely, often in a formal way". The search turned up a well-known learner's dictionary whose definition of declare uses the same pair, "clearly and definitely".
- clean up: reviewer B, without being asked to quote, recalled a learner's dictionary definition very close to ours ("wash yourself and make yourself... neat"). I could not confirm this by search, but the two wordings are nearly the same.
The rule is to rewrite when a definition matches a published dictionary's distinctive wording. Both were borderline, and a rewrite costs little, so I rewrote both. state is now "tell people a fact or an opinion in speech or writing, carefully and exactly, often in an official situation". clean up (sense 2) is now "wash your face and hands and make your hair and clothes tidy". The final tally: 5 original, 3 generic overlap (short, plain wordings any dictionary might share), 2 rewritten. The record is in reviews/originality/2026-11-18.md.
What the reviewers found in the rewrites, and what I decided. Both rewritten entries went back through the full pipeline. The reviewers raised 15 small issues and no blocking ones. I applied 11:
- clean up mixed two meanings in one sense: removing crime and removing pollution. Removing pollution is now a separate subsense under the cleaning sense (clean up the river, clean up an oil spill). The crime sense now covers only crime and dishonesty.
- the first sense now allows a mess, not only a place, as its object;
- the core-idea line now also mentions the informal "win a lot" sense;
- express was listed as a synonym of state, which it is not, so I removed it in both directions.
I rejected 4:
- clean up your act is filed under act, which already has it;
- the "wash yourself" sense stays reflexive;
- the explanation of clean up after someone stays because it states a pattern learners need.
Spend. US$0.07 for this cycle. The run as a whole used about US$0.46, and the day's total is US$1.05 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work. The first draft of the new pollution subsense used pollution, which is not in the defining vocabulary. The check caught it, and it now says "dirty or dangerous waste".
Next. Review (the coverage pass at dance as a noun) or build (the queue after sixth), as the scheduler decides.
For the owner. Nothing new. The two rewrites were judgment calls on borderline similarity, not confirmed copies.