Journal, 2026-11-16 (third run)
Cycle 1: originality
What the cycle did. The selector, the tool that picks each cycle's kind of work, chose an originality check. This was not a judgment call: the project's rules force one every twentieth run, and this was run 820. An originality check takes a random sample of ten definitions or notes already published in the dictionary and asks whether any of them reads as if it had been copied from a published dictionary. The dictionary is meant to be written from scratch, so a match would mean rewriting that field.
Before starting, the opening checks found nothing waiting: no open pull requests left by an earlier run, no reports from readers about particular entries (these arrive as GitHub issues titled "Entry report"), and nothing in the owner's inbox folder. One old working branch, claude/zealous-mayer-8da3yb, still exists on GitHub, but it has no unmerged work and was already listed in the curator file for deletion, which the automated runs cannot do themselves.
The sample. The ten sampled fields were:
- sun (noun), the sense any star, especially one with planets moving around it;
- yourselves (pronoun), the phrase see for yourselves: directly, by your own experience, and not because other people tell you;
- pair (noun), two people who are together or who do something together;
- help (interjection), used to shout to people that you are in danger and need someone to come and save you;
- offer (noun), a price lower than usual, or something more that you get free when you buy something;
- some (determiner), the ironic sense (Some friend you are!);
- doubt (noun), the phrase in doubt: not certain, so that it may not happen or may not be true;
- bald (adjective), said or written plainly, without any extra detail or explanation;
- he (pronoun), the usage note on the old generic he and the modern neutral they;
- pull (noun), an act of drinking from a bottle or of taking in smoke from a cigarette or a pipe.
How each was checked. For each field I ran a web search for the exact wording in quotation marks. What counts is only whether a published dictionary or word list shows the same words; nothing found is stored in the repository except the verdict. Separately, one of the two reviewer models (reviewer B, from a different company than the model writing the entries) was asked once, for all ten together, whether each reads as copied or original, and told it may answer "copied" only if it can quote the matching published wording.
What was found. None of the ten searches found the same wording in any dictionary. The nearest results were different wordings for neighbouring words (a published definition of couple near the pair sense, a glossary definition of possibility near in doubt, published definitions of plain and plainly near the bald sense) and, for the rest, encyclopedia or advice pages on the topic. Reviewer B called all ten original and named no source. All ten verdicts are therefore "original"; there were no "generic overlap" verdicts (short plain definitions any dictionary would word the same way) and no rewrites. This is a cleaner result than the previous check on 2026-11-14, which found two definitions (sea and figure) close enough to published wording that they were rewritten. The record is in reviews/originality/2026-11-16.md.
Spend. One paid call to reviewer B, about US$0.004. The day's total is about US$1.63 of the US$15 daily budget.
What did not work. Nothing went wrong in this cycle.
What is next. The run continues with further cycles while the run clock allows, each picked by the selector; the build queue, the coverage review of the most important entries, and the "closure" work (writing entries for words the dictionary already uses in its own definitions) all remain open as described in NEXT.md. The next routine maintenance pass (lint) is due in three cycles, and the next weekly digest on 2026-11-21.
What needs the owner. Nothing new from this cycle. The standing items remain: the pronunciation disputes in reviews/needs_curator.txt, the ten-entry samples in the weekly digests, and the old branch that only a person can delete.
Cycle 2: build
What the cycle did. The selector chose a build cycle: writing new entries from the queue, the ordered list of words still to be written. It allowed up to twelve, and all twelve claimed words were written, all nouns: rescue, reservation, reserve, resident, restroom, résumé, revolution, reward, rival, romance, roommate, and row. Each went through the full pipeline (schema check, generated plurals, a pronunciation vote, two reviewers, my decisions on what they raised, a vocabulary check, and cross-reference checks) and is now published as reviewed.
Some choices worth knowing about. Résumé is written with its accents as the headword, with resume and resumé listed as spellings; the entry warns that it is said REZ-uh-may and is a different word from the verb resume, and that in several languages a similar word means only "summary". Row covers only the line of things (seats, a line in a table, and the phrase in a row, "one after another"). The British word row meaning a noisy argument, which rhymes with cow, is a different word with its own history, so it needs a separate entry; one older entry, argument, already lists row as a synonym and should point to that second entry once it exists. This is noted in NEXT.md. Romance carries a warning for translators that in several languages a similar word means any novel.
Pronunciation. Each entry gives American and British forms, checked by a vote among other models and, for American English, the open CMU pronouncing dictionary. All 24 transcriptions were verified on the first pass.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. The two reviewer models raised 35 issues, none of them blocking (an issue that must be settled before publishing). I applied 29 and rejected 6, each with a logged reason. The main changes:
- reserve: the military sense was defined as soldiers, but its examples used the army reserve as an organization. It is now defined as the force, and a confusing grammar note was removed. The opening summary of the entry's senses (the "core idea") now covers protected land too.
- rescue: a reviewer pointed out that a rescue is also a group or place that takes in animals and finds them homes (she volunteers at a dog rescue). That is now a sub-sense.
- romance: the "love story" sense can be uncountable when it names the kind of book (she mostly reads romance); the grammar and examples now show this.
- Several collocations were corrected or replaced, and the culture note on reservation was cut down so that it only says what a translator would get wrong.
The rejections: I kept a valid grammar code ("often before another noun") on rescue; I did not label the sports sense of reserve British, because reserves for the players on the bench is common in American sports reporting; I kept pay a reward; and I did not add death row to row, because the project's rule files an idiom under its first noun, here death.
Three definitions used words outside the defining vocabulary, the list of about 2,400 simple words that definitions must use: native, Canada, and stadium. They were rewritten (for example, the land sense of reservation is now "kept for one of the first peoples of North America"). Three older entries, bathroom, toilet, and punishment, received back-links to the new entries, placed by hand on the right sense.
Spend. About US$0.35 for the reviewers and pronunciation checks. The day's total is about US$1.98 of the US$15 daily budget.
What did not work. Nothing failed. The first drafts had more noun-modifier collocations and a few loose ones (look at a résumé, share a room with a roommate) than they needed; the reviewers caught them.
What is next. Another cycle if the clock allows. The second row entry is queued for hand-claiming.
What needs the owner. Nothing new from this cycle.
Cycle 3: review
What the cycle did. The selector chose a review cycle: rereading entries that are already published to make them more complete and correct. With no unreviewed drafts and no reader reports waiting, the next job in the owner's order of 2026-10-24 was the "coverage pass": rereading the most important everyday words, those with the most senses first, and asking whether anything a learner needs is missing. This cycle took four of them, beat (verb), bed, boy, and breathe, and one small fix left from an earlier run: relationship listed relations as a synonym, an entry that will never exist, so it now points to relation with a note that the plural is meant.
What was added.
- beat: two new sub-senses, beat an illness or a fear (she beat cancer) and the informal be better than (walking beats sitting in traffic); an example of beating a person, which the hitting sense lacked; collocations for senses that had none; and the saying if you can't beat them, join them.
- bed: a hospital or shelter bed (the hospital has three hundred beds), a layer of rock or clay in the ground, and the open back of a truck (American).
- boy: the phrases golden boy and the old boy network (marked British). The phrase jobs for the boys was moved to job, because the project files an idiom under its first noun.
- breathe: the sub-sense breathe on something (don't breathe on the baby) and the literary phrase breathe your last, meaning "die".
Several entries also said one fact in two or three places, which the house style forbids. bed stated that go to bed takes no article in an explanation, a learner-error note, and a translator's note; it now says it once. beat explained its past participle in both a usage note and the inflection note, and boy repeated its warning about calling a grown man boy; those were cut down.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. The two reviewer models raised 55 issues on the six changed entries, 3 of them blocking (an issue that must be settled before publishing). All three blocking issues were on breathe's cross-references. Both reviewers were right that draw is not a synonym of breathe (only draw breath is), so that link was removed, together with its mirror on draw: the project keeps cross-references two-way, and removing one side means removing the other. I rejected the third: the link from breathe to word leads to the idiom not breathe a word, which is filed under word; it now carries a note saying so, and a similar link to neck (breathe down someone's neck) was added.
Of the 55 issues I applied 44 and rejected 11. Among the applied: cream and club were removed as synonyms of beat (with their mirrors), and whisk added for the cooking sense; football in two boy examples became soccer, which is clear in American English; the "son" sense of boy is now marked informal. Among the rejected: one reviewer wanted beat's "defeat" sense moved first, but the hitting sense is the base that the others build on; idioms like breathe a sigh of relief stay under their first noun.
Spend. About US$0.30. The day's total is about US$2.29 of the US$15 budget.
What did not work. Nothing failed. My first draft of the new breathe on sub-sense used don't breathe smoke in my face, which reads as breathing in; the reviewer caught it and it was replaced.
What is next. The coverage pass continues with the next four-sense words after breathe. Three new words were queued from this cycle's cross-references: beat up (phrasal verb), bed and breakfast, and boy as an exclamation (oh boy).
What needs the owner. Nothing new.
Cycle 4: build
What the cycle did. The selector chose another build cycle, allowing up to twelve new entries. I took six, because this was the run's last cycle and the checks, the reviewers' findings, and the merge at the end need room too; the rules say fewer, fuller entries beat more thin ones. The six nouns were rubbish, rumor, rush, sack, sadness, and sailing, and all six are now published as reviewed.
Some choices worth knowing about. Rubbish is marked as mainly British, with garbage and trash named as the usual American words. Its informal use after be meaning "very bad" (the film was rubbish) behaves like an adjective, so the entry points to a separate adjective entry, now queued, instead of mixing the two parts of speech. Sack covers the large bag, the American paper bag (a sack lunch), and three informal phrases: get the sack and give someone the sack (British, "lose your job" and "dismiss someone") and hit the sack ("go to bed"). Sailing has the phrase smooth sailing, with the British plain sailing mentioned.
Pronunciation. All 12 American and British transcriptions were verified on the first pass.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. The reviewers raised 22 issues, 4 of them blocking. Three blocking issues were the same point, made by both reviewers: one example under rush, a rush on umbrellas, shows a sudden demand to buy something, not the "sudden movement toward a place" that its sense defined. They were right. That use is now its own sub-sense (there was a rush on umbrellas when the rain started). In the same entry, the thrill use (riding a fast motorcycle gives me a real rush) became an informal sub-sense, with the American motorcycle in place of the British motorbike.
The fourth blocking issue was the plural sadnesses, which the project's inflection tool had produced because I had marked sadness as both countable and uncountable. The reviewer was right that learners should not be shown that plural. I marked the sense uncountable and reran the tool, which now shows no plural.
Of the 22 issues, I applied 18 and rejected 4. The rejections: the American-football use of sack (knocking down a player) is a specialist use that would need several sports words to define; sack lunch does show the paper-bag sense; "often before another noun" is a valid grammar code; and the note naming plain sailing stays, because phrases have no separate field for variant forms.
Two small consistency fixes followed from the cross-reference check. The existing entry hurry listed rush as a word to compare, while the new rush listed hurry as a synonym; rush now uses "compare" too, so the two agree. Nonsense received a back-link to rubbish, placed by hand on the right sense.
Spend. About US$0.17 for this cycle. The day's total is about US$2.45 of the US$15 daily budget.
What did not work. Nothing failed. The two problems the reviewers caught (an example under the wrong sense, and a countability choice that produced a wrong plural) are the kind a first draft can miss, and the pipeline caught them before publishing.
What is next. The next scheduled maintenance pass (lint) is due next cycle. The build queue continues from sailing; a second row entry (the British word for an argument) is waiting to be hand-claimed. The coverage review continues after breathe.
What needs the owner. Nothing new from this run. The standing items are unchanged: pronunciation disputes in reviews/needs_curator.txt, the ten-entry samples in the weekly digests, and the old branch claude/zealous-mayer-8da3yb, which only a person can delete.