Run report, 2026-11-14 (second run of the day, e2gonv)
Cycle 1: build
What the cycle did. The selector (the script that picks each cycle's job from what the dictionary most needs) chose build: new entries from the queue, the ordered list of words still to be written. Its limit was twelve entries and US$3 of paid model calls. I claimed the next twelve band-2 words in queue order (band 2 is the second most important of five frequency bands) and wrote all of them. Every one went through the full pipeline and is now reviewed, meaning it is published on the site.
The twelve nouns are photo, physics, piano, pie, pile, pit, pitch, playground, plenty, plot, poem, and poet. The bigger ones:
- pitch has five senses: how high a sound is, a talk meant to sell something (a sales pitch), a sports field (British) with a subsense for a camping or market place, a throw in baseball (American), and the level of a feeling.
- pit has five senses: a hole in the ground (with the orchestra pit as a subsense), the hard seed of a fruit (American; British says stone), a coal mine (British), the stopping area beside a race track, and a small hollow mark on a surface. It also has three idioms: the pits, the pit of your stomach, and a bottomless pit.
- pie covers the food and the idea of a share (a bigger slice of the pie), plus pie in the sky, as easy as pie, and eat humble pie.
- plot covers the story, a secret plan, and a piece of land, plus the plot thickens and lose the plot.
- plenty as a noun is the literary use (a land of plenty). The everyday use (plenty of time) is the existing pronoun entry, and each entry points to the other.
All 24 pronunciations (American and British for each word) were confirmed by the pronunciation panel and the open CMU pronouncing dictionary. Plural forms came from the rules. Physics and plenty correctly have none.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. The two reviewer models (one from Anthropic, one from Google) raised 76 issues. Eight were blocking, meaning the entry cannot be published until they are settled. I applied all eight:
- In pile, I had added the soft surface of a carpet as a third sense. Both reviewers were right that this is a different word with a separate history, so it must be its own entry (a homograph). I removed it, together with the summary sentence and the translator's note that tried to tie the two meanings together.
- In pitch, the opening summary sentence forced unrelated meanings into one idea. I rewrote it to say plainly that the word has several separate uses. I also moved the British sports-field sense below the senses an American-based dictionary should list first.
- In a bottomless pit, one example (a teenager who eats all day) did not fit a definition that only mentioned money and effort. I widened the definition, because the hungry-person use is common.
Of the minor issues I applied most. Mostly I cut notes that stated the same fact twice, which the house rule "one fact, one field" forbids: in photo, physics, poem, pitch, and plenty. I also dropped weak collocations (a fresh pie, a hard pitch) and moved noun-before-noun compounds (apple pie, sales pitch) to the right collocation type. I added coverage the reviewers found missing: the physics of something, eat humble pie, the small-mark sense of pit, and the camping pitch. I rejected five:
- a request for a second example on a subsense (the style guide allows one);
- two requests to hand-mark lost the plot (the site already marks the headword);
- a request for a "figurative" label, which is not in the closed label lists;
- a complaint about using an explanation to mention the short form easy as pie.
All 76 decisions are logged in reviews/decisions.jsonl.
The cross-reference tool adds a link back from each entry the new words point to, but it could not pick the right sense for 15 of them. I placed those by hand: for example, physics in the science senses of chemistry and biology, and plot in the "area of ground" sense of land.
Spend. US$0.34 for this cycle (the reviewer model from Google and the pronunciation panel; the Anthropic reviewer costs nothing in the ledger). The day's total is US$1.53 of the US$15 daily cap.
What did not work. Nothing failed. A small slip in the decision logging: I first tried to tell apart two issues on the same field by quoting the reviewer's comment, but the tool matches the quoted entry text. I used the position number instead. No tool change is needed.
What is next. The queue continues with pace and the following band-2 words. I left three items for later, recorded in NEXT.md: a separate pile-n-2 entry for the carpet surface, a pitch-n-2 entry for the black tar (which carries pitch-black), and the idiom have a finger in every pie, which belongs under finger by the rule that an idiom goes under its first noun.
What needs the owner. Nothing new from this cycle. The pronunciation disputes and the ten-entry samples in the weekly digests are still waiting for a session with you.
Cycle 2: review
What the cycle did. The selector chose review: rereading entries that are already published. No entries were waiting as drafts and no reader reports were open, so the cycle continued the coverage pass. This is the owner's 2026-10-24 instruction to reread the 500 most important entries for missing senses and idioms, taking the words with the most senses first. I read the next five, each with five senses: together (adverb), top (noun), train (verb), use (noun), and value (noun). The pass now stands at 329 entries.
Before sending them to the reviewers, I added what was missing:
- together: a subsense for being in one place or group (stay together so nobody gets lost, close together).
- top: a subsense for the leaves of plants such as carrots (carrot tops) and the idiom from the top (start again from the beginning).
- use: the idiom have no use for something and collocations such as drug use and land use.
- value: collocations such as shock value.
I also cut notes in use, value, and train that repeated a fact stated in another field.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. The two reviewer models raised 50 issues. One was blocking: the use entry listed make the most use of as a pattern of make use of. That is not natural English (the phrase is make the most of), so I removed it. I applied 39 issues in all:
- use: two learner errors were invented or too strict, so I removed them, and the fact that it's no use takes -ing now lives only in that phrase.
- value: the "good value for money" sense now comes after the more common importance and beliefs senses, and its article note moved into the usage note.
- together: the couple sense is now defined as an adverb phrase.
- top and train: generic translator notes were removed or narrowed.
- Removing exercise as a synonym of train also meant removing the matching link back from exercise.
I rejected 11:
- The reviewers called the definitions of use circular because they contain the verb use. That verb is in the defining vocabulary (the word list definitions are written from), and any paraphrase would be harder for an intermediate reader.
- at face value belongs under face, the first noun, where it already is.
- Two requests to hand-mark tops: the site already marks that plural.
- A request for a "gardening" label, which is not in the closed label list.
Both reviewers asked for off the top of your head under top. The style guide files that idiom under head, so I rejected the request here. But I checked, and the idiom is in fact missing from head. It is now on the to-do list in NEXT.md.
Spend. US$0.28 for this cycle. The day's total is US$1.81 of US$15.
What did not work. Nothing failed. The style guide's own model-entry section says head holds off the top of your head, and it does not. The next review of head should add it.
What is next. The coverage pass continues with voice, walk, and want. The lint pass (the periodic whole-dictionary check) is due in two more cycles.
What needs the owner. Nothing new.
Cycle 3: originality
What the cycle did. The selector forced an originality check, which comes round every twentieth run. Its job is to make sure our definitions were not copied from a published dictionary. The tool picked ten definitions at random from across the dictionary. I searched the web for each one as an exact phrase. I also asked one reviewer model (reviewer B, from Google) whether each one read as copied, with the rule that it may answer "copied" only if it can quote the published wording.
Results.
- Six definitions are original. Nothing published matched them (frozen "not able to move because you are very afraid or surprised", count, view, big, continue, and save).
- Two are generic overlap: definitions so short and plain that any dictionary would write them the same way. These are unless ("except if; if not") and the idiom put a sock in it ("stop talking or making noise"). They stay.
- Two needed rewriting:
- sea, sense 3 (a sea of faces), read "a very large number or amount of something". The search found that exact wording in a published learner's dictionary, and the reviewer named two learner's dictionaries with the same words. It now reads "a crowd of people or a mass of things so large that it seems to cover a whole area", which also describes the way a sea of is actually used.
- figure, sense 4 (a public figure), read "a person who is important or well known in some way". The search found the same wording on a site that reproduces a learner's dictionary. It now reads "someone seen as having a particular place or role, especially someone important or famous", which also covers a father figure.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. A rewritten definition is a change to the entry, so both entries went back through the two reviewers. They raised 30 issues, one of them blocking. The geometry sense of figure said "a flat or solid shape with fixed edges, such as a circle", and a circle has no edges. It now reads "a shape, such as a circle or a square, especially one drawn or studied in mathematics". I applied 25 issues in all. In sea that meant:
- removing three unneeded explanation fields;
- removing the "geography" subject label from the everyday sense (swim in the sea);
- cutting copies of the article rule and the "sounds like see" note, which were each repeated in several places;
- replacing a vague example (the northern seas).
I also widened the "model" sense of figure to cover statues of any size. I rejected 5. Two examples:
- I did not mark all at sea as British, because it is used in American English too.
- I kept the order of the figure senses, because the technical geometry sense rightly comes last.
The completed checklist is in reviews/originality/2026-11-14.md.
Spend. US$0.14 for this cycle (one reviewer question, then the review panel for two entries). The day's total is US$1.95 of US$15.
What did not work. Nothing failed. Two of ten sampled definitions needed rewriting. That is higher than recent checks, and both were short "a person who..." or "a very large number..." definitions of the kind learner's dictionaries share. Such definitions are worth an extra look when they are drafted.
What is next. The next scheduled job should be a lint pass, the periodic whole-dictionary consistency check, due after one more cycle. The coverage pass continues with voice, walk, and want.
What needs the owner. Nothing new.
Cycle 4: build
What the cycle did. The selector chose build again, with room for twelve new entries. This was the fourth cycle of a long run, so I took six. The rules prefer fewer, fuller entries, and entries drafted late in a long session can come out thinner. All six are band-2 nouns, now reviewed and published:
- poetry: poems in general, plus a second sense of a beautiful quality (there is real poetry in the way she dances), and the idiom poetry in motion.
- politician: the government sense, plus a disapproving sense for someone who plays politics inside a company.
- pond: with the informal idiom across the pond, meaning on the other side of the ocean between North America and Europe.
- pork: the meat, plus the informal American sense of government money spent locally to win votes.
- portion: a part of something, and an amount of food for one person.
- portrait: a picture of a person, a description in words or on film, and the tall page or screen shape (print it in portrait). The existing landscape entry already pointed to that last sense as its opposite.
All twelve pronunciations were confirmed. For portrait in British English, two of the three panel models agreed, which meets the house rule.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. The two reviewer models raised 22 issues, one of them blocking. The opening summary sentence of portrait claimed that the page-shape sense comes from the usual shape of a portrait. A claim about where a word or sense comes from may appear only in the etymology field, and only once it has been checked, and the reviewer also doubted the claim. I removed it.
I applied 21 issues in all. Most moved collocations to the right type, for example love poetry and a family portrait are noun-before-noun compounds. I also fixed:
- the politician definition: people are elected to an office, not "to a government";
- a British phrasal verb in an example (get on in a company), changed to the American get ahead;
- a vague phrase in the pork definition.
I rejected one issue: humorous is a register label in the closed list, not an attitude label. Five links back from other entries needed a sense chosen by hand: pool, part, share, picture, and painting. I placed them.
Spend. US$0.17 for this cycle. The day's total is US$2.11 of US$15.
What did not work. Nothing failed.
What is next. The lint pass, the periodic whole-dictionary consistency check, is now due, so the next run's selector should choose it. After that, the queue continues in order, and the coverage pass continues with voice, walk, and want. The items left for later are listed in NEXT.md:
- separate entries for the carpet sense of pile and the tar sense of pitch;
- have a finger in every pie for finger;
- off the top of your head for head.
What needs the owner. Nothing new. The pronunciation disputes and the ten-entry samples in the weekly digests still wait for a session with you.