Journal, 2026-11-12, run ruj1dp
Cycle 1: review
What the cycle did. The mode selector (tools/next_mode.py, which picks the kind of work with the most "debt" since it was last done) chose a review. There were no unreviewed drafts and no open entry reports from readers, so the cycle continued the coverage pass: a second careful reading of the most important everyday words (frequency band 1, the commonest words), taken in order of how many senses they have, to add any common meaning or idiom that the first draft missed. Four entries were read this time: right (adverb), roll (verb), root (noun), and rule (noun). The pass now stands at 299 entries; the next unread ones are sale and scene.
Before the reviewers saw the entries, I added what was missing:
- right (adverb): go right home, come right in (a new subsense meaning "directly"); if I remember right under the "correctly" sense; and the American informal phrase right off ("at once").
- roll (verb) was the thinnest entry of the four and grew from five senses to ten: throwing dice, turning over in bed, rolling a sleeve, waves and fog rolling in, a ship rolling from side to side, thunder and drums, rolling your r's, and cameras rolling. It also gained the idioms be rolling in it (be very rich) and rolled into one, and a note that roll sounds the same as role.
- root (noun): a math sense (the square root of 16), the saying money is the root of all evil, and the British phrase root and branch.
- rule (noun): ground rules, house rules, the rules of the road, and the saying rules are made to be broken.
What the reviewers found. Each entry goes to two reviewer models from different companies, who check every field and return closed verdicts. They raised 57 issues, 4 of them "blocking" (must be settled before the entry can stand). I read every one and decided: 53 applied, 4 rejected, none escalated. The real catches:
- I'll be right there had been filed under "exactly in a place", but it means "immediately"; both reviewers caught it, and it moved.
- The right usage note said rightly does not mean "correctly". That is false: as you rightly said, she rightly guessed. The note was rewritten.
- The band's music has its roots in old folk songs sat under a sense defined as where a person comes from. It now has its own subsense for the beginnings of a custom, an idea, or a kind of music.
- The roll "cameras rolling" sense had pulled in let's roll ("let's go"), which does not fit. Let's roll is keyed on let under the house rule for idioms, so it is noted for the next review of let instead.
- A reviewer pointed out that time passing (the years rolled by) was missing; it was added.
- Smaller fixes: four signposts (the short labels that help a reader pick a sense) were over three words; a tooth's root is not "under the skin"; ruler inside the definition of rule was circular; a note on rule only pointed to another entry and was removed; a doubtful learner error on each of right and rule was removed as probably invented.
What I rejected: a request to drop government as a synonym for the "control of a country" sense of rule (the government entry has a matching sense, "the system of ruling"); a request to add the exception that proves the rule (its keyword is exception, so it goes there, and is noted); a claim that the adaptation note on rule was generic (it names one specific pair of senses); and a request to add up to rolled his sleeves to the elbow, which is natural as it stands.
Checks. All four entries pass the schema validator, the inflection and pronunciation checks (all verified), the defining-vocabulary lint, and the cross-reference check. The full gate over 4,216 entries, the size caps, the link check, and the unit tests all pass.
Spend. US$0.22 for this cycle (reviewer B and the pronunciation panel; reviewer A runs on the owner's subscription at no ledger cost). The day stands at US$0.89 of the US$15 daily cap.
What did not work. Nothing broke. One note for later cycles: the coverage list I computed contains four phrasal verbs (come in, get back, get on, put on) that earlier cycles passed over; they are recorded in NEXT.md so a later cycle can decide whether the coverage pass should include them.
What is next. The coverage pass continues with sale and scene. Lint is due in about four runs.
For the owner. Nothing new. The pronunciation disputes and the digest samples still wait for a session with you.
Cycle 2: closure
What the cycle did. The selector chose closure: building entries for words the dictionary already uses or points to but does not yet define. The first source, closure (words used inside definitions), is empty. So the cycle took the next rows from the family source, which holds related forms that existing entries list in their word families. I built five new entries in queue order. That is fewer than the cap of twelve, so that each entry is complete and the run has room for later cycles.
- mention (noun): a short remark, with no detail. It has a subsense for public praise without a prize (an honorable mention), and a usage note that make mention of something is formal and takes no article.
- messenger (noun): two senses, the person whose job is carrying letters and packages (a bike messenger, by messenger) and someone who brings news. It also has the idiom don't shoot the messenger.
- military (noun): the military, meaning a country's armed forces as a group. It takes a singular or plural verb. It has a learner error, my father is a military, because in several languages the matching word can mean one soldier.
- milkshake (noun): a usage note says an American milkshake almost always contains ice cream, while in Britain the word can also mean flavored cold milk.
- millionaire (noun): a pronunciation note gives the stress on the last part (mil-yuh-NAIR).
All five transcriptions and all inflections were verified on the first pass. (Transcriptions are checked by a panel of models plus the open CMU pronouncing dictionary; inflections are generated by rule.)
What the reviewers found. There were 11 issues, 3 of them blocking, and all 11 were applied. The three blocking issues all concerned a third sense of messenger that I had drafted: a phone app for sending messages. Reviewer A pointed out that native speakers say a messaging app or use a brand name, and that a messenger service is a courier company, not an app. I agreed and removed the sense; it was led by brand names more than by ordinary English. The other fixes:
- milkshake is now countable only. Its definition says ice cream is "usual", not required, so it agrees with the usage note.
- millionaire is now defined by the threshold itself: a person who owns at least a million dollars or pounds. I first wrote property, which the defining-vocabulary check refused because property has no entry yet, so I reworded it.
- A needless explanation came out of military.
Before the panel I also took out two cross-references of my own. billionaire is not a synonym of millionaire. army is only part of the military, so it moved from synonyms to "see also".
Checks. The gate over all 4,221 entries, the link check, the unit tests, and the vocabulary and cross-reference gates pass. The cross-reference tool added a mirror link from billionaire back to millionaire.
Spend. US$0.12 for this cycle. The day stands at about US$1.01 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work. Nothing failed. The vocabulary lint had added a note to the queue row for property while millionaire still used the word. I removed that note by hand once the definition changed, so the row does not point to a use that no longer exists.
What is next. More family rows, then crossref rows. Band 3 and above stay paused until band 2 is finished, under the owner's ruling A3.
For the owner. Nothing new.
Cycle 3: build
What the cycle did. The selector chose build: new entries taken in the queue's order, which follows the owner's build-order ruling (band by band, the commonest words first). I claimed five rows. That is well under the cap of twelve, so each entry is complete and the run keeps room to finish cleanly. All five are band 2.
- meter (noun) has three senses: the unit of length; a machine that measures and shows an amount, from a gas meter to a taxi's fare, with a subsense for the parking meter; and the rhythm of beats in a line of writing. The British spelling metre is recorded for the unit and the rhythm only, because a measuring machine is a meter in Britain too.
- microwave (noun) has two senses: the oven, and the energy wave, which is labelled technical.
- midday (noun): one sense, at midday, the midday sun.
- mineral (noun) has two senses: a substance in the ground, and a substance the body needs (vitamins and minerals).
- ministry (noun) has two senses: a government department, and church work. A usage note says that in the United States a government department is normally called a department.
Pronunciation. The American transcription I first wrote for microwave was disputed. The panel and the open CMU pronouncing dictionary (an open American dictionary of pronunciations, consulted at run time and not stored) agreed on a lighter middle vowel and a second, weaker stress on wave. I corrected it to that form, and it then passed (3 of 4 votes plus CMU). Everything else passed on the first check.
A vocabulary limit. Definitions must use the defining vocabulary, the list of about 2,400 plain words that all definitions are written in. poem and poetry are not on that list and have no entries yet. So the rhythm sense of meter is defined through "lines of writing, such as the words of a song". A reviewer asked for "poetry" in the definition; I rejected that for this reason and logged it.
What the reviewers found. There were 17 issues, 3 of them blocking, and I applied 16. All three blocking issues were the same kind of mistake: an example sentence that states a checkable science fact, which the house style forbids. This kind of glass blocks microwaves was doubtful as well. Fruit and vegetables are full of vitamins and minerals is a nutrition claim. Both examples were replaced. Both reviewers also noticed that a taxi meter does not measure "how much has been used", so that definition was widened. Reviewer A noted that American English uses ministry for a church program (a youth ministry); that use was added and the sense made countable as well. A few weak collocations were replaced. Dig for minerals became mine for minerals, and natural minerals became rare minerals.
Cross-references. The cross-reference tool could not place two mirror links automatically, so I placed them by hand. department (its government sense) now lists ministry as a synonym, and midnight lists midday as its opposite.
Checks. The gate over 4,226 entries, the caps, the links, the unit tests, and the vocabulary and cross-reference gates all pass.
Spend. US$0.15 for this cycle. The day stands at about US$1.17 of US$15.
What did not work. Nothing failed. The only rework was the microwave transcription described above.
What is next. Building continues in queue order after ministry. A lint pass (the periodic mechanical and judgmental clean-up) comes due within a few runs.
For the owner. Nothing new.
Cycle 4: review
What the cycle did. The selector chose review again. This cycle continued the coverage pass, the second reading of the commonest everyday words that adds what the first draft missed. It read the next four entries: sale, scene, seat, and section (all nouns). The pass now stands at 303 entries; security and send come next.
These four entries were already fairly full. Before the reviewers saw them, the main work was tightening:
- sale gains the British business phrase on sale or return.
- seat gains a subsense for the seat of a pair of pants and the American county seat.
- section gains the American use for one group of students in a large course (the morning section).
- scene had a generic translation note ("many languages use a different word for each"). The house rules ask for a note that names a specific trap, so it now explains that make a scene means a public show of anger, not part of a play. I also noted that Americans usually say a change of scenery, not a change of scene.
- Three entries (sale, scene, seat) repeated the same pronunciation point in two fields. Under the "one fact, one field" rule, each repeat was removed.
- Two examples stated real-world facts, which the style guide forbids, and were replaced. One was about sales of electric cars; the other said that smartphones "changed everything".
What the reviewers found. The reviewers raised 41 issues, 6 of them blocking. I applied 35 and rejected 6. The real catches:
- I bought this coat in a sale is British; American English says at a sale or on sale. Fixed.
- Take a back seat was defined as "choose to have a less important part". Yet the entry's own example (his studies had to take a back seat) involves no choice. Both reviewers caught it, and the definition now reads "become, or choose to become, less important".
- The newspaper sense of section carried the grammar code "often before another noun". It is the other way round: in the sports section, another noun comes before section. Both reviewers caught this too.
- Several facts were stated two or three times. The difference between for sale and on sale appeared in a usage note, a phrase explanation, and a learner error. The seat/sit confusion appeared three times. Each fact now lives in one place. The seat/chair/bench comparison moved into the field made for choosing between near-synonyms.
- Three weak cross-references were removed, together with their mirror links in the other entries: site as a synonym of scene, place of seat, and paragraph of section.
- Reviewer A noticed that the common a cross section of the public was missing. It is now a subsense of section.
What I rejected: in the driver's seat (its keyword is driver); C-section (a compound with its own headword, now queued as c-section-n); the claim that they sale fresh bread is an invented error (mixing up sale and sell is a real one); a request to remove the explanation that sense 4 of sale is always plural (she works in sales), which the style guide asks for; and a request to drop the note that by the seat of your pants usually goes with fly.
Checks. The gate over all 4,226 entries, the caps, the links, the unit tests, and the vocabulary and cross-reference gates pass. The cross-reference tool added one mirror link, in marketing.
Spend. US$0.21 for this cycle. The run's four cycles together spent about US$0.71. The day stands at US$1.38 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work. Nothing failed. One open point: the coverage list I computed puts four phrasal verbs at the top (come in, get back, get on, put on). Earlier cycles passed over them without saying why. NEXT.md records this so that a later cycle can decide.
What is next. The coverage pass continues with security and send. This run made four cycles, and each one counts toward the lint schedule, so the lint pass is now closer to due.
For the owner. Nothing new from this run. The pronunciation disputes and the digest samples still wait for a session with you.