Run report, 2026-11-11, third run (run 20261111T164342Z-wibk39)
Cycle 1: build
What this cycle did. The selector (the tool that picks each cycle's job from what is most overdue) chose build: new entries taken from the queue, the ordered list of words still waiting for an entry. Its reason was that build had the highest "scheduler debt", meaning it had gone longest without its fair share of runs. It allowed up to twelve entries and US$3 of paid model calls. Twelve words were claimed in queue order and all twelve were written, checked, and published: logic, login, loser, loyalty, luggage, magic, maintenance, make (the noun, as in What make is your car?), making, male (the noun), mall, and management. All are nouns in band 2 (band 2 is the second most common group of words).
Before the work. No open pull requests were left by an earlier run, inbox/ (the folder where you leave instructions) was empty, and there were no "Entry report" issues from readers. The one old work branch, claude/friendly-mayer-mdy32d, still holds nothing that is not already in main. It already has its line in reviews/needs_curator.txt asking you to delete it, because these runs cannot delete branches.
What the entries contain. A few points worth knowing:
- login has two senses: the process of getting into a system (after three failed logins), and the name and password you use. Its learner error is the very common I can't login: the verb is two words, log in.
- loser separates the plain competition sense from the insult (a total loser), which is labeled informal and disapproving. It also has a subsense for a good loser and a sore loser.
- luggage carries two real learner errors, three luggages and a new luggage. Both come from the noun being uncountable.
- maintenance has three senses: repair work (with a subsense for the staff who do it, call maintenance), keeping something at a level (formal), and the British sense of money paid after a divorce. A pronunciation-and-spelling note warns that it is spelled -ten-, not -tain- as in maintain, and that the stress moves to the first part.
- making holds the makings of (the makings of a fine player) and three idioms: in the making, be the making of someone, and of your own making.
- male (the noun) mirrors the existing female entry, with the same usage note: as a word for people it belongs to science, police reports, and forms, and in conversation it can sound cold.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. Each entry goes to two reviewer models from different companies, which check every field and mark each problem as blocking (must be settled before publishing) or minor. They raised 37 issues, 7 of them blocking. I accepted 30 and rejected 7, and every decision is logged with a reason.
- Both reviewers rightly objected that password was listed as a synonym of login. It is only part of a login, so it is now a "compare" word with a short note.
- Both also saw that right after login uses the noun without a or the, while the grammar said it was countable only. That sense is now marked "countable or uncountable".
- They were also right on several smaller points. Hand luggage is a noun + noun pairing, not adjective + noun. Trick and repair are related words, not synonyms. Under new management belongs to the "people in charge" sense. An example about soup "working its magic" did not fit the definition. The definition of make used the word made, which is circular, so it now says produced.
- I rejected three blocking flags on making. They said the entry claims "no plural" while one sense is used only as makings. The reviewers are right that this looks inconsistent, but the inflections field is written by a script (
tools/inflect.py), never by hand. The script cannot record a plural for a noun whose other sense is uncountable. This is a known gap, already recorded inwiki/notes/inflect-uncountable-plural-gap.mdfrom money, finance, energy, and rain, and making is now added to that list. The examples mark makings by hand, as the house rules require. - I also rejected a request to add a register label to male for people. The usage note already says where the word is used, and the existing female entry does the same.
Other fixes. Two definitions used words that have no entry yet (philosophy in logic, brand in loyalty), so I reworded both. The cross-reference tool (it adds the matching link in the other entry) could not decide which sense to link in four cases, so I placed those links by hand: in password, model, man, and leadership. Logic now points to reason as a "compare" word, matching what the reason entry already said.
Spend. US$0.36 for this cycle (pronunciation panel and reviewer B; reviewer A runs on your subscription at no charge). The day's total is US$1.75 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work. Nothing failed. The making inflection gap has now come up six times. When a run has room for it, the tool fix described in the notes page is worth doing.
What is next. The queue continues after management. The next lint pass (the periodic housekeeping check) is due within a run or two, since nine of its ten runs have passed.
What needs you. Nothing new. The pronunciation disputes and the digest samples still wait for a session with you, and the old branch above can be deleted whenever convenient.
Cycle 2: lint
What this cycle did. After the first cycle merged, the selector chose lint. Lint is the periodic housekeeping pass, forced every ten runs (each cycle counts as a run), and ten had passed. It changes no definitions; it checks that the dictionary, the queue, and the wiki agree with one another and with the rules.
The mechanical checks.
- Caps and links. The word caps on the rule files and the wiki are all respected, and every relative link in the wiki resolves.
- Cross-references. The cross-reference tool keeps every link two-way. If entry A lists entry B as a synonym, B should list A. Run over the whole dictionary, it added three missing return links: lawn now lists grass, lifetime lists time in its word family, and luggage lists bag. In two cases it could not tell which sense of the target the link belonged to, so I placed them by hand: location (the "place" sense) now lists situation as a synonym, and mall (the shopping sense) lists department store as a compare word. Both came from entries written earlier today.
- Claims. Six old claim files, the records by which a run reserves words before writing them, belonged to runs that had already merged and were removed.
- Band vote. 38 queued words were still unbanded, meaning they had no frequency band yet. These are words a tool added to the queue because an entry mentions them. Three models voted a band for each, at a cost of under one cent. For two words the votes were more than one band apart, so I settled them myself, both at band 3. Dead as a noun (the dead, in the dead of night) is met in reading but is not a first-need word. Only as a conjunction (I'd come, only I'm busy) is mainly spoken and informal. All 38 rows are now ready to be built in their turn.
The reports. Three standing reports list things for later review runs to judge, not errors to fix now:
- 1,004 places where a cross-reference may name the wrong sense, up 7 from the last pass, mostly from new entries.
- 321 definitions that use their own headword. Most are harmless, such as walk (the noun) defined with the verb walk.
- 6 notes that promise an entry that does not exist yet. These are the same six as last time; all are unrelated homographs or phrasal verbs already noted in
NEXT.md.
Reviewer precision. Precision is the share of a reviewer's flags that I accepted. Reviewer A, the Claude model, is at 0.85 and reviewer B, the Google model, at 0.82. The rule switches off any issue type a reviewer gets right less than 30 percent of the time, once it has twenty or more decisions. One type is near that line: reviewer B on inflections (word forms such as plurals), at 0.32 over 25 decisions. Its recent misses come from a gap in our own tool, not from the reviewer: the tool cannot record a plural like makings when another sense of the noun is uncountable. So no type was switched off, and fixing the tool would remove the cause. This is written up in wiki/notes/reviewer-precision.md.
The judgment pass. I read the wiki index against the pages: every page is listed. The open-questions page has nothing stale, and reviews/needs_curator.txt (the list of things waiting for you) has no duplicate lines. The log has no gaps.
Spend. Under one cent this cycle. The day's total is US$1.75 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work. The settle step of the band-vote tool looked for a votes file under its default name and failed. It worked once I gave it the file name the run step had written (--votes votes-unbanded.tsv). This is a small inconvenience, not a fault in the data.
What is next. The next lint is due after ten more runs. The build queue continues after management.
What needs you. Nothing new.
Cycle 3: review
What this cycle did. The selector chose review: a second reading of published entries, to find what a learner would expect and cannot find. No draft entries were waiting and no reader reports were open. So the cycle continued the coverage pass, the owner's ruling B1 of 2026-10-24. That pass reads the most important band-1 words one by one, the ones with the most senses first (band 1 is the commonest group of words). The next four unread entries, all with five senses, were program (noun), push (verb), quiet, and ready (adjectives). Two earlier entries in the list, practice and reading, had already been read since 2026-10-24 and were skipped. The pass now stands at 291 entries.
What I added before the reviewers saw the entries.
- program: a subsense for the items performed at a concert, in order (What's on the program tonight?). The entry had a culture note saying that British English spells it programme. That only repeated the spelling variant already recorded in the entry, so I removed it (one fact, one field).
- push: a sense for making a level rise or fall (bad weather pushed the price of fruit higher). Also an informal sense for being nearly an age (my dad is pushing seventy).
- quiet: a sense for feelings that are strong but not shown openly (quiet confidence, quiet determination).
- ready: a subsense for needing something after effort (I'm ready for a cold drink). The rule "ready for before a noun, ready to before a verb" was stated three times, in the usage note, an adaptation note, and the learner error. It now lives only in the learner error.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. The two reviewer models raised 57 issues, 10 of them blocking. I accepted 52 and rejected 5. The useful finds:
- Program: an example about a schedule "on the website" sat under the sense defined as a small printed booklet. Both reviewers blocked it, and it is replaced. My own new example said music "by three young writers"; the natural word is composers. A synonym, scheme, often suggests a dishonest plan in American English and was removed. A remark that Americans usually say show sat in the explanation field, which is meant for function words, so it moved to the usage note.
- Push: my new example pushed many small shops close to closing was unnatural and did not show a level changing; it is replaced. The "persuade" sense mixed two uses, pressing a person and campaigning for something. Push for something (the workers are pushing for higher pay) is now its own subsense, and push someone into something was added.
- Quiet: small is not a real synonym and was removed (from small's entry too). Have a quiet word is mainly British, so that example was replaced. A pronunciation note comparing quiet and quite repeated what the pronunciation field already says, and it was removed.
- Ready: both reviewers pointed out that ready compares as readier, readiest (readier to help). The entry had wrongly said it compares with more. I removed that grammar code, and the inflection tool now produces readier and readiest by its ordinary rules. The "available" sense joined two ideas: things kept for use (ready cash) and things that come easily (a ready smile). These are now a sense and a subsense. The idiom at the ready and the phrase ready, willing, and able were added. The learner error is now the more typical ready for going.
What I rejected: push your luck is already in the entry for luck, under the house rule that an idiom lives under its first noun. Make ready is formal and rare today. I also rejected two objections to the new pushing fifty sense. One said the grammar label "not used in the passive" is not on the closed list, but it is. The other said the note "used only in the continuous form" belongs elsewhere, but the style guide puts that kind of restriction in the explanation field.
Spend. US$0.21 this cycle; the day's total is US$1.96 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work. While checking how the decision tool reports several issues on one field, I accidentally logged two real decisions with a placeholder note. Both decisions were correct, and I replaced the two notes with real reasons in the ledger before committing.
What is next. The pass continues with receive (verb), whose last reading was on 2026-10-24 itself, or else record (noun).
What needs you. Nothing new.
Cycle 4: build
What this cycle did. The selector chose build again, allowing up to twelve new entries. This was the fourth and last cycle a run may have, so I took eight, as earlier late cycles have done, to keep every entry as full as the first cycle's. The first two words in the queue were brand and media. Both moved into band 1 (the commonest words) in the band vote during this run's lint cycle, so they came first. The other six came from the queue in order: camp (noun and verb), locate, sue, junior (noun), and lecturer. All eight were written, checked, and published.
What the entries contain.
- brand: three senses. The product name (which brand of coffee), with a subsense for a company's or person's image (a personal brand). A kind or style of something (his own brand of humor). The mark burned into a farm animal's skin.
- media: the news sense, with social media as a subsense of its own. The materials artists use (mixed media). The objects that computer information is stored on.
- camp: the noun has places where people stay outdoors, with subsenses for refugee and prison camps and for army and training camps; the American summer camp for children; and a group with shared views (split into two camps). The verb has staying outdoors, and waiting outside a place to get something (fans camped outside the stadium).
- locate: finding something, and be located for where a place is. It carries a real learner error, the hotel locates near the beach.
- junior: the American third-year student; someone younger or lower at work (ten years her junior), which mirrors the existing senior entry; a young sports player; and the informal American Junior for a son.
- lecturer: its usage note explains that the word is a regular job title in British universities. In American English, professor is the usual word for a university teacher.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. The two reviewers raised 28 issues, 5 of them blocking. I accepted 27 and rejected 1.
- The blocking issues were mostly about one mistake in locate. I had defined its second sense as put or build something somewhere, but all its examples meant be located, that is, be in a place. The sense is now be in a particular place, used in the passive. The active use (locate the new office in the city center) is a subsense.
- The other blocking issue was the missing Junior, which was added.
- Media was reshaped on the reviewers' advice: social media got its own subsense, and the art sense and the storage sense were separated.
- Brand gained the image subsense.
- A note now says make is a synonym of brand mainly for cars and machines.
- I rejected camp it up, meaning act in an exaggerated way. It belongs with a separate adjective, camp, not with the verb for staying in tents.
Three definitions had used words that have no entry yet (tent, vacation, rank), so I reworded them. The cross-reference tool could not choose a sense in two places, so I placed those links by hand: in side (the sense for groups against each other) and find (the sense for finding after looking).
Spend. US$0.22 this cycle. The run as a whole spent about US$0.80, and the day's total is US$2.18 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work. Nothing failed.
What is next. The build queue continues after lecturer. The coverage pass continues with receive or record.
What needs you. Nothing new. As before: the pronunciation disputes and digest samples in reviews/needs_curator.txt and the digests wait for a session with you, and the old branch claude/friendly-mayer-mdy32d can be deleted.