Journal, 2026-11-05: run 20261105T004357Z-wu5vp0
Cycle 1: closure
What the cycle did. The mode selector (tools/next_mode.py, which picks each run's kind of work from what has gone longest undone) chose closure: building entries for words the dictionary already uses but has no entry for. The plain closure list held one word, mushroom (used in the definition of cap). The other eleven came from the family list, nouns related to verbs that already have entries: collapse, collection, commander, commitment, communication, concern, confirmation, congratulation, consideration, consultant, and contribution. A thirteenth word, cook (noun), was claimed by mistake when two claim commands ran back to back; it was released to the queue without being drafted, so the cycle stayed at twelve, the selector's limit.
Each entry was drafted from the house style guide, then went through the full pipeline: the schema validator; inflections from rules; a pronunciation check by a panel of models plus the open CMU pronouncing data for American English; a field-by-field reading by the two reviewer models (reviewer A, a Claude model; reviewer B, a Google model); my decision on every issue they raised; the defining-vocabulary check (definitions must use the dictionary's list of about 2,400 basic words, or words that have entries); and the cross-reference tool, which adds the matching link in the other entry when one entry names another as a synonym or a related word.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. They raised 77 issues, 6 of them "blocking" (an issue that must be settled before the entry can be published). I agreed with 70 and rejected 7, with the reason logged for each in reviews/decisions.jsonl. None needed to go to the owner as a disagreement between reviewers.
The useful finds were gaps in what the entries covered:
- collection lacked the very common use for gathering things (data collection, tax collection); its "taking away" sense now covers gathering too, and the senses were reordered so that the commoner ones come first.
- confirmation lacked official approval of a person for a public job (a confirmation hearing); this is now a sense of its own.
- communication gained a subsense for communications as a field of work or study.
- congratulation had a learner-error note saying the word is "always plural", which contradicted its own second sense (a letter of congratulation); the note now says the good wishes are plural, and its error examples are now noun uses in a sentence, not the interjection Congratulations!, which has its own entry.
Most of the minor fixes removed explanation fields from ordinary nouns (the style guide keeps that field for function words and hard uses), swapped British wording out of American examples (on our street, going-away present), and replaced weak collocations.
Rejected issues included reviewer B's claim that consideration should be transcribed with an r-colored vowel before the stressed syllable. The r opens the stressed syllable, and all four American votes, CMU included, agreed with our transcription. I also rejected a request for a "fashion" label (the closed list of subject labels has none; "clothing" is the nearest), and one asking for congratulation to be marked plural-only, which would have hidden its plural form.
Pronunciation. Twenty-three of twenty-four transcriptions were verified. The British form of congratulation got one vote in three. I kept the vowel that matches the existing entry for congratulate, flagged the entry pronunciation-unverified, and added a line to reviews/needs_curator.txt for the owner.
Cross-references. Thirteen of the reviewed synonyms point to entries with several senses, where the tool will not guess which sense should carry the matching link. I placed each one by hand (for example concern in the sense "a business" is now listed at business, "a company").
Spend. US$0.42 of the day's US$15. About one cent was wasted when I ran the pronunciation check a second time to see output the first run had already shown.
What did not work. The double claim (above), and the repeated pronunciation call. Neither changed any entry.
What is next. The family list continues from cook (noun). When cap is next reviewed, it can gain a subsense for the top of a mushroom, now that mushroom has an entry.
For the owner. One new curator line, the British pronunciation of congratulation. Nothing else needs you from this cycle.
Cycle 2: build
What the cycle did. After cycle 1 merged, the selector chose build: new entries taken in order from the main queue, which is now working through band-2 nouns (band 2 is the second most important of five editorial frequency bands). I drafted twelve: collar, combination, comedy, command (noun), companion, complaint, concept, congress, consequence, construction, consumer, and context. Each one went through the same full pipeline as in cycle 1: the schema validator, inflections from rules, the pronunciation panel, both reviewer models reading every field, my decision on every issue, the defining-vocabulary check, and the cross-reference tool.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. They raised 35 issues, 3 of them blocking. Two reviewers found nothing to fix in collar, combination, or consequence. I applied 31 and rejected 4.
The blocking issues:
- The second sense of complaint used the verb complain in its own definition, which the style guide forbids. It now reads "something that makes you not happy or satisfied, which you tell other people about".
- An example in concept said motor show, which is British. The dictionary's main variety is American, so it now says auto show. Both reviewers caught this one.
The useful coverage finds:
- second in command is now a phrase under command.
- companion has a subsense for a partner someone lives with without being married, and its third sense now covers a guide book (a companion to the exhibition).
- construction covers the building of ideas or systems (the construction of a theory).
The minor fixes trimmed signposts to the house limit of three words, removed a medical subject label from the everyday a skin complaint sense, and dropped loose synonyms (user for consumer, situation for context).
Rejected:
- Moving chain of command under command. The house keyword rule puts an idiom under its first noun, here chain, so it is noted in
NEXT.mdfor when that entry is next reviewed. - Marking the law-making sense of congress as singular-only, since other countries' congresses can be counted. The usage note already explains Congress with a capital and no the.
- Doubts about protest as a synonym of complaint and structure as a synonym of construction in grammar. Both are close enough.
Pronunciation. All 24 transcriptions were verified.
Cross-references. I placed ten matching links by hand in entries with several senses (for example concept is now listed at idea in its "picture in your mind" sense).
Spend. US$0.35 for this cycle; US$0.77 so far today, out of the daily US$15.
What did not work. I first gave the metrics tool the wrong count of changed entries (33 rather than 22) and corrected its record by hand.
What is next. Band-2 nouns continue in queue order after context.
For the owner. Nothing new from this cycle.
Cycle 3: review
What the cycle did. The selector chose review. There were no draft entries and no open entry reports (problem reports filed by readers as GitHub issues), so the cycle continued the coverage pass that the owner ordered on 2026-10-24. This is a fresh reading of the most important (band-1) entries, those with the most senses first, to check that each one covers every common use. I read six entries with six senses each: make up (phrasal verb), dead (adjective), cross (verb), count (verb), corner (noun), and come on (phrasal verb). The pass now stands at 198 entries read. Both reviewer models read all six as well, with the house checks for coverage and for whether each example fits its sense.
What the reviewers found and what I decided. They raised 82 issues. Only 2 were blocking, and both named the same fault: the example my feet felt dead with cold is not natural English (people say numb with cold). I replaced it with my leg is dead because I've been sitting on it. Of the 82, I applied 72 and rejected 10.
Most of the issues came from the notes-discipline rule of 2026-10-24: one fact lives in one field. These older entries often said the same thing three times. Corner, for example, explained in the corner versus on the corner in a sense explanation, again in a learner-error note, and again in a note for translators. Each such fact now lives in one place. The same clean-up went through count (count to ten, not until ten), cross (cross versus pass a street), dead (dead versus died), and make up.
Coverage additions:
- make it up to someone (repay someone you have let down), plus the
separableandinseparablegrammar codes that phrasal verbs now carry (the owner's ruling B4). - cross yourself (the religious gesture), and a sports sense, cross the ball.
- count against someone (be a disadvantage).
- in someone's corner (supporting them).
- a sense of come on for walking onto a stage or a sports field (he came on as a substitute).
- a line in dead's usage note on the dead, meaning dead people.
I also reordered dead so that a dead language (no longer used) comes before the less common "very quiet" and "no feeling" senses.
Rejected:
- over my dead body and play dead as phrases under dead. The keyword rule puts the first under body (it is already there) and the second under play, which is noted in
NEXT.mdfor its next review. - Three requests to mark the headword by hand in examples where the site already marks it.
- A region label for in a tight corner, which is also American.
- A request about a verb-pattern label whose wording comes from the closed list.
Cross-references. When a review removes a cross-reference, its matching link in the other entry goes too. late no longer lists dead as a synonym, and makeup no longer compares itself with make up. humor now lists comedy under "compare" rather than as a synonym, to match the change made to comedy in cycle 2.
Spend. US$0.31 for this cycle; US$1.08 so far today.
What did not work. Nothing failed. One decision command matched no issue because I quoted the wrong text, and I logged it again with the right quote.
What is next. The coverage pass continues with the twelve unread six-sense entries, from collect backward through the alphabet, then the five-sense ones.
For the owner. Nothing new from this cycle.