Run report, 2026-11-03

Cycle 1: review

What this cycle did. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py, which picks each cycle's kind of work from what is most overdue) chose a review. There were no unreviewed drafts and no open entry reports from readers, so the cycle continued the coverage pass: a careful reading of the most important everyday words (band 1, the most frequent of the dictionary's five frequency groups), asking of each entry whether it is missing a meaning that a learner will meet. This cycle read four entries with six meanings each that had not been read since your rulings of 2026-10-24: straight (adjective), stone, step, and state (all nouns). That brings the pass to 159 entries.

What was added.

What the reviewers found and what I decided. Each entry went through the two-reviewer panel (two different language models that check every field and give closed verdicts). They raised 52 issues, 3 of them blocking (must be settled before the entry can be published). I applied 43, rejected 8, and escalated 1.

The blocking issues were fair: an example under the idiom in step actually showed its opposite, out of step (removed; the explanation keeps the opposite), and two examples for the solid-liquid-gas meaning stated science facts, which the style guide forbids (replaced with everyday sentences about wax and frozen samples).

Many of the minor issues were about one fact being stated in two places, which the notes rules of 2026-10-24 forbid: the weight of a stone in pounds appeared in a definition-side explanation and again in a translator's note; the American word pit for a fruit stone was in a label, a synonym, and a usage note; take a step was covered by both a usage note and a learner-error box. Each now lives in one field. The reviewers were also right that I had first filed "tidy" under the "level" meaning of straight; it is now a meaning of its own. Generic translator notes ("these meanings may need different words") were removed from straight; the one on step stays, because it names the actual split.

Rejected, with reasons logged: keep a straight face belongs under face by the keyword rule (the first noun of an idiom decides where it lives), and it is already there; the plural stone after a number is not written into the inflection table, which only a script writes; a few steps from my house is a natural use of the walking meaning.

Escalated: a state of affairs belongs under state by the keyword rule but lives under affair. Moving it means editing affair too, which needs its own review, so it is queued for when affair is next read, with a line in the curator file.

Changing cross-references touched four other entries: brick lost a weak "compare with stone" link, and neat, correct, and clean gained links back to the new straight meanings.

Spend. US$0.25, all on the second reviewer and the pronunciation check; the first reviewer runs at no charge.

What did not work. Nothing broke. Two definitions had to be reworded because they used words outside the defining vocabulary (the plain-word list definitions are written from): kilograms and sexually.

What is next. The coverage pass continues with the remaining 48 six-meaning band-1 entries, from smart. The other queues are unchanged in NEXT.md.

What needs you. Nothing new beyond the open items in NEXT.md. The state of affairs move is a routine fix, not a question.

Cycle 2: build

What this cycle did. The scheduler chose a build: new entries taken from the queue (the list of words still to be written) in the order set by the build-order decision. That order is now at the band-2 nouns, the second most frequent of the five frequency groups. The cap is twelve new entries; I wrote five so that each one could be complete: agency, agenda, aid, analysis, and angel, all nouns.

The entries.

All ten transcriptions (American and British for each word) were confirmed by the pronunciation panel and, for American English, by the open CMU pronouncing dictionary, which is consulted at run time and never stored. All plurals were confirmed.

What the reviewers found and what I decided. The two-reviewer panel raised 20 issues. Five were blocking, and they all came from one fault. I had defined the second sense of aid as help "that someone gives you", but two of its examples showed things: a cane and a lamp. Both reviewers caught it. The definition now covers help from someone or something. Of the 20 issues I applied 19. They included two weak synonyms that I removed (plan for agenda, test for analysis), two collocations filed under the wrong type, a decoration example for angel that did not show the religious sense, and a more exact definition of the money-giving angel, who invests rather than donates. I rejected one: reviewer A wanted the second sense of aid folded into the others, but it has its own fixed pattern, with the aid of, and is neither country aid nor an object.

Linking the new words to existing entries needed five links placed by hand. These are cases where the cross-reference tool could not tell which sense of the target entry to link to. agency is now compared with organization, aid is a synonym of help, analysis is a synonym of study in its research sense, and angel and angle point to each other.

Spend. US$0.16 for this cycle, and US$0.41 for the day so far against a daily cap of US$15.

What did not work. Nothing failed. One idiom definition used charity, a word outside the defining vocabulary, and I reworded it.

What is next. More band-2 nouns in queue order, from the word after angel. The other queues are unchanged.

What needs you. Nothing new.

Cycle 3: review

What this cycle did. The scheduler chose another review, so the coverage pass continued. That pass is the careful reading of the most important everyday words, looking for meanings a learner will meet that the entry lacks. This cycle read four six-meaning entries not read since 2026-10-24: smart, small, serious (adjectives), and second (noun). The pass now stands at 163 entries.

What was added.

What the reviewers found and what I decided. The two-reviewer panel raised 56 issues, 5 of them blocking (must be settled before publication). I applied 53 and rejected 3.

The blocking issues were all real faults. In small I had added an example, the repairs cost a small fortune, under the meaning "not large"; but the idiom means a lot of money, so it taught the opposite of the definition, and I removed it. small also wrongly carried an "only before a noun" grammar code on the small-business meaning, though the company is small is normal. In second, the gear meaning was circular ("the second gear of a car"); it now says the gear after the lowest one, used for going slowly.

The minor fixes included British wording in examples that should be American (shop to store, Have you got a second? to Do you have a second?, change into second to shift into second). They also removed a definition of seconds (more food) that used the headword, and an adjective definition for well-dressed people that did not fit a smart jacket. Several weak synonyms and opposites came out, each removed from both entries: slim and great for small; heavy, funny, and sincere for serious; rude for smart. Notes that repeated other fields were cut: the usage notes of smart and serious, and a learner error on serious that was really about the adverb seriously.

Rejected, each with its reason logged: a small fortune and the small hours belong under fortune and hour by the keyword rule (the first noun of an idiom decides where it lives); the small hours is already there, and a small fortune is queued for when fortune is written. Dates (on the second) belong to the number entry second, and the usage note now points there.

Three back-links (links from the other entry back to the reviewed one) were placed by hand: quick now lists smart, and quiet and soft list small for the voice meaning.

Spend. US$0.20 this cycle; US$0.61 for the day.

What did not work. Nothing failed. Two new definitions used words outside the defining vocabulary (British, proposal) and were reworded. I first ran the panel before fixing a five-example limit error, which cost nothing extra but should be caught before the panel next time.

What is next. The coverage pass continues with 44 six-meaning entries, from report (verb).

What needs you. Nothing new.

Cycle 4: lint

What this cycle did. The scheduler required a lint pass, a maintenance check of the whole dictionary that is due every ten cycles. This was the ninety-ninth. It changes no definitions. It runs the mechanical checks across all 3,591 entries and then a short reading of the wiki's own records for contradictions.

Mechanical checks. The word caps on the project's own files, the links between wiki pages, the entry validator, and the unit tests all passed. The cross-reference tool keeps links symmetric: when entry A names entry B as a synonym, B should name A back. It wrote two back-links by itself, adding bank to the word families of bank holiday and banker. It could not place eleven more, because it could not tell which sense of the target entry to put them in. I placed six of them by hand, all from the last two days' new entries. For example, waste (sense 2, a chance) now lists blow and throw away as synonyms, aid lists relief, yell lists roar, and withdraw and agenda are compared with draw and schedule. The other five are older cases saved for the C1 audit, a planned check of cross-references that your rulings of 2026-10-24 set out. They are unchanged. Six claim files from earlier cycles, records of which words a cycle had reserved, were no longer needed and were removed.

Band vote. Each queued word gets a frequency band (1 is most common, 5 least) from a vote of three cheap models. Forty-two words that tools had added to the queue since the last vote had no band yet. The vote cost US$0.007 and put 6 in band 2, 23 in band 3, and 13 in band 4. No word had votes more than one band apart, so none needed my judgment. None of the 42 has an entry yet.

Reviewer precision. Precision is the share of each reviewer's issues that I end up applying, tracked by kind of issue. A kind that falls under 30 percent over twenty or more decisions is switched off for that reviewer. Nothing new crossed the line. Reviewer B's spelling-and-format issues are still below it (29 percent) but stay on by your earlier ruling. Its pronunciation issues rose to 40 percent and remain the nearest live kind to the line.

Reports for later review cycles. 330 definitions use their own headword. Most are harmless, such as a wing of a chicken under wing, and each is judged when its entry is next read. There are also 923 sense pairs whose cross-references should be checked by hand. Both lists feed the review queue.

Reading the records. The wiki index and its pages agree, with no unlisted or dead pages. The curator file (reviews/needs_curator.txt, the list of questions waiting for a person) has no duplicate lines. The two open questions, on continent names in definitions and on the former / the following, still wait for you.

Spend. US$0.007 this cycle; US$0.62 for the day against the US$15 cap.

What did not work. band_vote.py settle looks for votes.tsv by default. After an --unbanded run it needs --votes votes-unbanded.tsv, as the previous pass also found. This is a small trap, not a fault, but it may be worth a default in a later tooling run.

What is next. The next lint pass is due in ten cycles. The coverage pass resumes at report (verb), and building resumes with the band-2 nouns after angel.

What needs you. Nothing new. The standing items are listed under "For the owner" in NEXT.md.

All journal entries