Run report, 2026-10-31 (fourth run)
Cycle 1: build
What the cycle did. The selector (the tool that picks each cycle's kind of work) chose build: writing new entries from the queue, the ordered list of words still to write. Its reason was that build had the largest "debt" of the eligible kinds of work; the day's budget had US$12.90 left and no entries were waiting in draft. It claimed twelve band-2 verbs (band 2 is the second most important frequency group) in queue order: recycle, reform, refund, regard, register, reject, release, rely, request, resemble, reserve, and resign. All twelve were drafted from scratch, checked, reviewed by both reviewers, corrected, and marked reviewed, which means they will appear on the public site.
Pre-flight found no open pull requests, no entry reports from the public, and nothing in the owner's inbox. The five old branches with no unmerged work are still there; each already has a line in the curator file asking for it to be deleted, since this tool set cannot delete branches.
Checks before review. The inflection tool generated every verb form from its spelling rules (relies, relied, relying). The pronunciation check, a panel of models plus the open CMU pronouncing dictionary consulted at run time, accepted all 24 transcriptions (American and British for each verb). For release the CMU dictionary preferred a different first vowel, but three of four models agreed with ours, which meets the agreement rule.
What the reviewers found. The two reviewers (reviewer A, a Claude model; reviewer B, a Google model) raised 57 issues, 12 of them blocking (an issue that must be settled before an entry can be marked reviewed). Every one was decided by hand: 45 applied, 12 rejected, none escalated to you. The main changes:
- reform: an example (a reformed smoker) and two collocations showed reformed used as an adjective before a noun, which belongs to an adjective entry, not the verb. They were replaced with a plain verb use (he finally reformed), and
reformed-adjwas added to the word family so it is queued. - reject: an example about teenagers rejecting their parents' values was filed under the sense "not give someone love", but it means "not accept an idea". It was replaced with one about rejecting a person. shops became stores (American wording).
- register: the "notice" sense (it didn't register) wrongly said the noticing happens "after a short time"; it now says "notice something or take it in". The "make a complaint officially" sense had a grammar pattern it does not take. An example about registering with a doctor, mainly British, was replaced.
- reserve: reserve judgment was redefined so that the definition takes an object, as the verb does.
- Coverage: release gained a sense for letting out a feeling (release stress) and a subsense for freeing someone from a contract or promise. request now also covers asking someone to do something (Guests are requested not to smoke).
- Smaller fixes: recycle now covers sorting waste as well as treating it; regard "look at" is labelled literary rather than formal; rely lost an explanation that repeated a learner-error note.
What was rejected, and why. Both reviewers asked for reserve the right to do something. Under the house keyword rule an idiom goes under its first noun, right, so it was rejected here and noted in NEXT.md for the next review of right. Three objections to short explanations stating a form restriction (resign yourself to, it didn't register) were rejected because house rule 15 puts such restrictions in the explanation. Two requests for a pattern for bare intransitive use were rejected because the closed pattern list has none.
Cross-references. The cross-reference tool adds a back-link in the other entry when it can tell which sense to attach it to. In eight cases it could not, and all eight were placed by hand: improve lists reform, hold lists release as an opposite, issue lists release, trust lists rely, decline lists reject, accept lists resign, and return and retire carry short notes telling them apart from refund and resign. quit already compared itself with resign, so resign now compares quit too, with a note, instead of calling it a synonym. Nineteen missing words named in the new entries were added to the queue, among them registration, reliable, resemblance, and resignation.
Spend. US$0.36 of the day's US$15 budget (reviewer B and the pronunciation panel; reviewer A runs at no charge). The day's total is US$2.46.
What did not work. Three definitions first used words outside the defining vocabulary (aside, complaint, tension); all were reworded. Nothing else failed.
What is next. More band-2 verbs in queue order, or whatever the selector picks; the next whole-dictionary lint pass is due in two runs.
What needs you. Nothing new from this cycle. The standing items are in NEXT.md under "For the owner".
Cycle 2: closure
What the cycle did. The selector chose closure: building entries for words the dictionary already uses in its own definitions, word families, or cross-references but has no entry for yet. The day's budget had US$12.54 left. The closure list (words used inside definitions) held only one row, needles. That is a plural, so it was marked duplicate in the queue and its singular, needle, was claimed by hand instead. The other eleven came from the family list (words named in another entry's word family), in queue order: acting, adjustment, advance, advertisement, adviser, airline, airplane, apology, application, assembly, and assistant. All twelve are nouns, all were drafted from scratch, and all are now reviewed.
Checks before review. The inflection tool gave every noun its plural (apologies, assemblies) and left acting with none, as an uncountable noun. All 24 transcriptions passed the pronunciation check. For adviser only two of four models agreed with the American transcription and the CMU dictionary differed, but two votes is enough under the agreement rule. advertisement records the real difference between American English (stress on -tise-) and British English (stress on -ver-), with an adaptation note for translators.
What the reviewers found. The two reviewers raised 33 issues, 6 of them blocking. All were decided by hand: 32 applied, 1 rejected, none escalated to you. Examples first:
- needle: one example said that searching for a name "is a needle in a haystack". The idiom names the thing that is hard to find, not the search, so the example was replaced (Her lost earring was a needle in a haystack somewhere in the sand).
- airplane: an example about children making paper airplanes did not fit the definition (a vehicle with an engine), and it was replaced. aircraft moved from "synonym" to "compare", with a note that it also covers helicopters. The British aeroplane is now recorded as a different form with three syllables, not just a spelling.
- assistant: assistant manager means a rank, not a helper. It now has its own subsense (one level below the job named), with an explanation that it is used before a job title.
Other changes: assembly no longer says that assemblies are always elected or that school assemblies happen at the start of the day (both are mainly British facts), and its "coming together" sense is now countable too (a large assembly of guests). apology gained the polite phrase my apologies. advance lost a military label that was too narrow, and its core idea now covers the money and romantic senses. advertisement now covers radio and online advertising. Two core ideas were reworded so that every sense fits under them. Several collocations were corrected (run an advertisement, get an advance, legislative assembly).
What was rejected. Reviewer A suggested a sense of apology meaning "a very poor example" (an apology for a meal). It is rare and literary, too far down the list for a band-2 learner's entry, so it was rejected with that reason.
Cross-references. In four cases the tool could not tell which sense a back-link belonged to, and all four were placed by hand: pin now compares needle, change lists adjustment, progress (in society and science) lists advance, and program (computer) lists application. act and ad gained family links on their own. Five missing words were queued.
Spend. US$0.35. The day's total is US$2.82 of US$15.
What did not work. The closure list is now almost empty: it gave one row, and that row was a plural that should never have been queued. Five definition words fell outside the defining vocabulary (sexual, pine, steady, rank, coach), and all were reworded.
What is next. The selector's choice. The whole-dictionary lint pass is due in one run, and the family list continues after assistant.
What needs you. Nothing new from this cycle.
Cycle 3: review
What the cycle did. The selector chose review: re-reading existing entries for missing senses, wrong facts, and notes that break the house rules. No entries were waiting in draft and no public entry reports were open, so the cycle continued the coverage pass the owner asked for in ruling B1. That pass re-reads the most important band-1 entries, those with the most senses first, to check that every current use of the word is covered. This cycle read club, character, and change, bringing the pass to 127 entries.
What the reading added before the reviewers saw it. character gained a subsense for "a person of a particular kind, especially one who seems strange or not to be trusted" (a suspicious character), which no sense covered, and the collocation a character reference. change gained a change for the better and a change for the worse. club gained health club and country club for the building subsense. Several notes repeated a fact that another field already stated. The house rule is one fact, one field, so those copies were cut: two explanations in change that repeated a learner-error note, and an example of for a change that repeated the phrase of the same name.
What the reviewers found. The two reviewers raised 32 issues, 2 of them blocking. All were decided by hand: 27 applied, 5 rejected, none escalated to you.
- The two blocking issues were the same point, made by both reviewers: the money sense of change was defined as "coins, not paper money", but change for a twenty is usually paid in bills. It is now defined as "coins, or bills of small value that you get in exchange for a bill of larger value".
- More duplicate notes were removed: a translator's grammar note in change, a pronunciation note in character that repeated the learner's pronunciation note almost word for word, and a generic "translate each sense on its own" note in club (the house rules say an adaptation note must name a specific trap).
- character gained the phrase in character (It was in character for her to help), the opposite of the existing out of character. change gained the phrase a change of pace.
- club: the card sense now says "one of the four kinds of playing cards, or one card of this kind", so it agrees with its own explanation. The core idea now mentions the sports team and the dancing place. comedy club was moved out of the dancing sense.
- Smaller fixes: character sense 1 can be uncountable (different in character); a subsense's countability moved from its explanation into its grammar field; the a change of heart definition no longer uses the word change; the travel sense of change has a new signpost, "on a trip", because it also covers planes.
What was rejected, and why. Naming golf in the golf-club definition: the word is outside the defining vocabulary and has no entry yet, and the signpost already says "golf". Moving the moral-strength sense of character below the story sense: the three "qualities" senses are kept together, and the story sense comes straight after them. Writing a change of scene/scenery as the phrase text: a phrase's text fixes its permanent address, so the variant stays in the explanation. The plural rule for card names (the queen of clubs) stays in the explanation under house rule 15. Reviewer B's view that character's false-friend note repeats the learner error: the note now gives only the trap in other languages, and the English fix lives in the learner error.
Spend. US$0.18. The day's total is US$3.00 of US$15.
What did not work. Nothing failed.
What is next. The coverage pass continues with the next unread six-sense entries. The whole-dictionary lint pass is due at the next run.
What needs you. Nothing new from this cycle.
Cycle 4: lint
What the cycle did. The selector forced lint, the whole-dictionary health check, because ten runs had passed since the last one. This was the ninety-sixth pass. It ran the mechanical checks and the judgment checks of framework.md section 6. The size caps on the rule files and the wiki, the internal links, the entry validator, the unit tests, and the vocabulary and cross-reference gates all passed.
Cross-references. A cross-reference is a link from one entry to another, such as a synonym, an opposite, or a "compare" note. The house rule is that every link has a matching link back (a "mirror"). The tool wrote back-links in six entries where it could tell which sense they belonged to. In 21 cases it could not. Sixteen of those were placed by hand in twelve entries. Most were older entries that already pointed to a verb built today: approve and take name reject as an opposite, so reject now names them; market, plug, and push name promote; foresee and foretell name predict. Where the older link had a note, the mirror got a short note from its own side (for example, persuade now says that get is less formal). The other five are the known cases where the link points to a sense that does not exist. They are waiting for the C1 audit (the owner's 2026-10-24 ruling on cross-reference notes), as before.
Band vote. A band is a word's importance group, from 1 (most important) to 5. Tools had queued 84 new rows with no band, for example words named in today's new entries. The three-model word-list panel voted on them for US$0.011. In one case the votes were more than one band apart: obtainable got 5, 4, and 3. The session settled it at the middle vote, 4, since it is a formal word met mainly in writing. All 84 rows are now ready to build in band order.
Reviewer precision. Precision is the share of a reviewer's flags that turned out to be right when they were adjudicated. A kind of flag below 30 percent over twenty or more decisions is switched off for that reviewer. No new kind fell under the line. Reviewer A stands at 0.83 overall and reviewer B at 0.82. Reviewer B's spelling-and-format flags are at 0.27, but they stay on by the owner's ruling.
Reports. The circular-definition report lists 328 candidates and the missing-sense report lists 836 pairs. Both are candidate lists for later review cycles, not errors. There are seven "promises", places where a note says something that another entry must hold. All are unchanged in kind.
Housekeeping. Five spent claim files (records of words already built) were removed. The wiki was 37 words over its 30,000-word cap, so two old sections of the reviewer-precision note were shortened to one line each. Every wiki page appears in the index, and every index line points to a real page. The curator file has no duplicate lines.
Spend. US$0.011. The day's total is US$3.01 of US$15.
What did not work. band_vote.py settle failed the first time because it looked for a file named votes.tsv. It works when given the --votes votes-unbanded.tsv option, as the last lint used it. This is not a fault in the tool.
What is next. The next lint is due in ten runs. Build, closure, and the coverage pass continue as the selector chooses.
What needs you. Nothing new. The standing items are in NEXT.md under "For the owner".