Run report, 2026-10-25

Cycle 1: review

What this cycle did. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py, the script that picks each cycle's kind of work) chose a review: rereading existing entries and fixing them, rather than writing new ones. The top of the review list is still the appendix of errors you attached to your rulings of 2026-10-24 (ruling B3). Two earlier cycles fixed most of it; this one took the definitions-and-codes group, the invented learner errors, and two small number fixes left over from yesterday. Twelve entries went through the full pipeline: the automatic checks, both outside reviewers, my decision on every point they raised, and the checks again.

The changes, entry by entry:

What the reviewers found. They raised 44 issues, 33 of them blocking (meaning the entry should not stand as it is). I accepted 15 and rejected 29. The accepted ones were mostly about notes: three translator's notes that only said "translate each sense separately" were rewritten to name a specific trap, and repeated facts in manner and well were cut so each lives in one field. The rejected ones fell into three groups the house rules already settle: one reviewer wanted the money and age uses of fifty moved to a separate noun entry (number entries hold them by rule); one asked for phrasal verbs (make up, make out) as senses of make (phrasal verbs are separate entries); and several asked for idioms whose keyword is another word (do someone proud goes under do). I also turned down a "business was dull" sense as too specialized for now.

Spend. US$1.15 of the day's US$15, all on the two reviewers.

What did not work. One reviewer left one checklist item on make unanswered; its other answers were complete, so the record stands. Nothing else failed.

What is next. The rest of the appendix: drop (its invented droped error) and the missing senses you listed for drop, service, into, hard, word, low, fly, everything and ours. Those open the coverage pass over the most important everyday words.

What needs you. Nothing new. The question about surnames after titles (Dr. Lee in the entries for doctor, title, teacher, Dr.) is still waiting for your ruling; until then those stay.

Cycle 2: build

What this cycle did. The scheduler chose to build: write new entries from the queue (the ordered list of words still to be written). The queue still gives milestone 1 first: the words of the defining vocabulary, the roughly 2,400 plain words the dictionary's definitions are written in, which you ruled must all have entries before anything else. Twelve verbs came up, all in band 2 (the second most important of five frequency bands): chase, clap, conclude, dissolve, extend, frighten, heal, leak, organize, quote, roast, and rob. Each was drafted from scratch with every field filled, then run through the full pipeline.

Some points a learner will notice: organize records the British spelling organise; quote has the spoken phrase quote, unquote; frighten has a short note on choosing between scare, frighten, and terrify; conclude, dissolve, and rob each carry one learner error that learners really make (concluded to cancel, the ice dissolved, robbed my phone). leak and heal say in a separate explanation what the subject of each sense is (the pipe or the water; the wound), because the house style keeps such restrictions out of the definition itself.

Checks. All 24 pronunciations (American and British for each verb) passed the agreement check, and every past tense and -ing form came from the spelling rules (clapped, robbed).

What the reviewers found. I sent the entries to the two reviewers in three groups of four, which keeps their replies complete. They raised 35 issues, 23 of them blocking, and I accepted 23 and rejected 12. The accepted ones were real improvements. The first definitions of heal and leak were clumsy about what heals and what leaks, and both were rewritten. Roast had said roasting usually uses oil, which is not true; it now says dry heat. The "offer" sense of extend now covers extend a loan and extend credit, so its example about a bank fits. Several pattern codes were wrong: organize does not take a to-infinitive in the workers organized to demand better pay; that is an infinitive of purpose. Most of the rejections were requests to treat phrasal verbs (chase down, heal over, leak out) as senses; the house rule makes those separate entries, and I added chase up to the queue. I kept one learner error in frighten (I'm frightening of the dark) that a reviewer wanted moved to the adjective entries, because those entries do not exist yet.

Links. The linking tool, which writes the matching link back when one entry points to another, no longer guesses which sense of the other entry is meant. It left seven links for me, and I placed them by hand: follow, decide, end, begin, start, disappear, and order now point back to the new verbs.

Spend. US$0.94 for this cycle; about US$2.09 for the day so far.

What did not work. I ran the pronunciation check twice by mistake, a few cents of extra spend; nothing else failed.

What is next. About 220 milestone-1 words are left. The appendix work from cycle 1 continues with drop and the missing senses when the scheduler next chooses a review.

What needs you. Nothing new from this cycle.

Cycle 3: review

What this cycle did. The scheduler chose a review again, and this one finished the appendix of errors from your rulings of 2026-10-24 (ruling B3). What was left was the last group: senses and idioms the assessment found missing from nine common words, plus the invented learner error droped in drop. The ruling said these should open the coverage pass, the planned second reading of the most important everyday entries to check that nothing a learner needs is missing. Nine entries went through the full pipeline.

What was added:

What the reviewers found. They raised 45 issues, 25 of them blocking. I accepted 27 and rejected 18. Most of the accepted ones cut repeated facts, under your notes rule that one fact lives in one field: duplicated translator's notes in drop, fly, and ours, and a usage note in word that only repeated its learner errors. Others fixed real faults: hard defined hard drugs as "harmful", which is too absolute; its learner-error note claimed hard is never followed by an -ing form, which overstates the rule; and two translator's notes, in service and hard, gave only general advice and now name a specific trap. The rejected ones asked for phrasal verbs as senses (drop by, bump into), for idioms filed under another keyword (fly the flag, fly the nest), or for uses that are mainly British (a dinner service, three into twelve).

Spend. US$1.14 for this cycle; about US$3.23 for the day.

What did not work. My first edit script stopped partway when a helper was called with a wrong argument name. Two entries had already been saved, so I fenced those parts off and ran the rest once. I checked that no change was applied twice. Each entry also needed one example removed to stay within four examples per sense.

What is next. The B3 list is done. The review queue now goes to open entry reports (there are none today), then the coverage pass over the 500 most important band-1 entries, then the other review items in your rulings.

What needs you. Nothing new.

Cycle 4: originality

What this cycle did. Every twentieth run the scheduler does an originality check, and this was one. The check makes sure our wording has not drifted toward the wording of published dictionaries, which the drafters are never allowed to open. The tool picked ten definitions and notes at random. For each one I ran a web search for the exact phrase, to see whether any published dictionary shows the same words. I also asked one outside reviewer whether each one reads as copied.

What the searches found. None of the ten matched a published dictionary word for word, except where the definition is so short and plain that any dictionary would write it the same way. Those are get something by paying money for it (buy), refuse to allow something (a phrase under hear), and have something in your hand or hands, or in your arms (hold); I marked them as generic overlap. Six were clearly our own: for example the usage note on truck and the definitions of the phrases make conversation and talk shop.

One needed rewriting. Sense 1 of reason read a fact or situation that explains why something happens or why someone does something. That is not a copy, but it follows the frame a well-known learner's dictionary uses for explanation and reason too closely. It now reads something that explains an event or a person's action; the answer to the question why. My first rewrite said something that makes an event happen, but that describes a cause, and the entry's own note explains that a cause and a reason are different, so I replaced it before recording. The rewritten entry went through both reviewers. One of them pointed out that the common phrase within reason was missing, so I added it. I rejected three other points: one misread the grammar code, and the other two asked for a rare idiom and for a verb use that belongs in the verb entry.

The reviewer's answers. As in earlier checks, the reviewer said "copied from Cambridge" for nine of the ten, and each time it "quoted" our own wording back as Cambridge's. The searches did not support any of those claims, so the searches decided the verdicts, as the house practice already says. My first call to it, with its reasoning switched on, came back empty because it used all its allowance on hidden reasoning; the second call, with reasoning off, worked. I added a line to NEXT.md so later checks use the setting that works.

Spend. US$0.13, slightly over this cycle's US$0.10 ceiling because of the wasted first call. For the whole day: about US$3.36 of US$15.

What is next. The coverage pass over the 500 most important band-1 entries, the phrasal-verb codes (ruling B4 i), the link audit (C1), and more milestone-1 building, in whatever order the scheduler picks. The next lint pass is due in about six runs.

What needs you. Nothing new today. The open questions are unchanged: surnames after titles in four entries, continent names in definitions, and whether the former and the following are nouns or pronouns.

All journal entries