2026-10-24, run at 00:43 UTC, cycle 3: review
What this run did
This cycle was a review: a second reading of entries that the two outside reviewer models have checked only once. The dictionary works through these in the order the entries were written. This block was the next twenty: the nouns from string to surprise (string-n, stroke-n, structure-n, student-n, study-n, stuff-n, style-n, subject-n, substance-n, success-n, sugar-n, suggestion-n, suit-n, summer-n, sun-n, supply-n, support-n, surface-n, surgery-n, surprise-n).
Earlier today, OpenRouter (the service that runs the reviewers) refused some requests with a rate-limit error. So this time I sent the entries in four groups of five, with a short pause between groups. Every reply came back complete.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
Four entries drew no objections: string, structure, substance, and suit. On the other sixteen, the reviewers raised 40 issues. I accepted 21 and rejected 19. Each decision and its reason is logged in reviews/decisions.jsonl.
Accepted, with my own rewording:
- stroke: the illness sense now names bleeding in the brain as a second cause. The swimming and rowing sense no longer says the movements are made only with the arms, since rowing uses an oar. An example under the phrase not do a stroke of work now actually uses the phrase.
- student: the note said British English calls schoolchildren pupils and keeps student for college. That was too strong. The note now says younger children are often called pupils, though student is also used. A second copy of the same point in the sense explanation was removed.
- study: the sense for subject names (media studies) was limited to colleges. Schools teach social studies too, so it now says "especially at a college or university".
- style: in style was defined as "in an expensive way". It now means "in a way that people notice and admire, often with a lot of comfort or money".
- subject: the grammar sense now says the subject "does the action of the verb or is described by it", which also fits passive and linking sentences. The sense for a monarch's subject no longer adds "a duty to obey".
- sugar: the sense for the sugars found in food now also covers sugars added to food.
- surgery: the countable sense is now "a single operation", not only cutting the body open.
- supply: bank was listed as a synonym and demand as an opposite. Neither is right. A link of that kind has to be removed from both entries, so I also edited
bank-nanddemand-n. The two words now point to each other under "see also", with the phrase supply and demand. - success and suggestion: one learner-error note and one translator note made claims that were too broad, and both are corrected.
Rejected:
- Two objections to region labels on sugar. In this dictionary a region label means "mainly used there", a rule settled earlier. Calling someone sugar is mainly American, even if it is heard elsewhere.
- That in surgery (my father is still in surgery) belongs to a different sense. It uses the uncountable noun, which is the sense where it sits.
- That stuffy is not in the word family of stuff. It is formed from stuff plus -y.
- That a support group is out of place under the "kindness" sense. A support group exists to give exactly that kind of support.
- That the signpost "doing what you want" on success breaks the three-word limit. It has three words.
- That catch the sun (British) only means getting sunburned. It covers going a little red or brown.
Spend
US$1.79 for this cycle, US$2.40 for the day so far (cap US$15).
What did not work
Nothing failed. The pauses between groups cost a few minutes, but no reviewer reply was lost.
What is next
The review continues with survival, suspicion, sweat, switch, and onward. About 950 entries are still at one review round.
For the owner
Nothing new needs you.