2026-10-23, cycle 3 of the 12:43 UTC run: second reading of underneath to strike
What this cycle did
The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py, which picks each cycle's job) chose review: a second reading by the outside reviewer panel of entries that have been through it only once. There were no unfinished drafts, so the block was the twenty oldest one-round entries in the order they were written, continuing from where the last review stopped: underneath (adverb and preposition) and the nouns steam, step, stick, stomach, stone, stop, store, storm, story, stove, stranger, strategy, straw, stream, street, strength, stress, and strike.
Both reviewer models (reviewer-a and reviewer-b, from two different labs) read every field again. I ran them in four batches of five, one after another; none failed. Three entries came back with no issues: underneath (preposition), stranger, and stream.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
There were 38 points. I accepted 18 and rejected 20. Every decision is logged with its reason in reviews/decisions.jsonl.
Accepted, the main ones:
- stick, the sports sense, said used to hit the ball, which leaves out games played with a puck. It now says used to hit or move something in some games.
- stone: the usage note said Americans use rock "for a stone of any size", while the compare note said "also for a small stone". The two now agree: Americans often say rock for a stone, even a small one.
- step: the usage note said flatly that you never make a step. That was too strong; it now says make a step and do a step are not the usual ways to say it. I also fixed its marks: the words named there are now in bold, as the style guide requires, not in italics.
- strike, the baseball sense, had a definition with a second sentence after a semicolon. The definition is now short (a throw that counts against the player trying to hit it), and the explanation gives the rule. The idiom a strike against someone now notes that it is used of things too.
- strength: two definitions ended in and so on, which says nothing; both now name what they mean.
- put a stop to something no longer says so that it does not happen again; turn your stomach has a smoother definition; a steam iron was removed from the "steam power" sense, since an iron is not powered by steam; ambiguous collocations (a large store, which sounds like a big shop) were replaced in the "supply" sense of store; a two-way street lost an unneeded informal label.
Rejected, with reasons:
- reviewer-a wanted the two senses of strategy merged (a plan, and the skill of planning). They have different grammar (one is countable, one is not), so they stay apart; its claim that a game of strategy uses the countable form misreads the sentence.
- It called humorous a wrong kind of label. It is in the dictionary's closed list of register labels.
- It said a storm of snow and made a step toward the door are acceptable, so they should not be shown as learner errors. Both are unnatural; the learner errors stay.
- It said British English does not call a large shop a store. British chains commonly do, and the note says only "especially for a large one".
- reviewer-b objected to St. in the street usage note as an abbreviation. The note names the short form as a word, which is the point of the note; it does not use it.
Before saving, the vocabulary check caught one word I had added, hockey, that is outside the defining vocabulary and has no entry yet, so I took it out of the definition.
Spend, problems, and what is next
US$1.74 for this cycle, about what twenty-entry reviews usually cost; the day stands at US$5.47 of the US$15 cap. Nothing failed. The review queue continues with string, stroke, structure, student, and onward; about 947 entries are still at one review round. Nothing needs the owner from this cycle.