2026-10-23 (2) — review: second reading of sport to station, contest to invention
Cycle 2 of the run that started at 00:44 UTC. Run id 20261023T005916Z-rm5wd1.
What this run did
The mode selector (the script that picks each cycle's job) chose review: a second reading of entries that have so far been through the outside reviewer panel only once. There are no unfinished drafts, so the block was the twenty oldest one-round entries in the order they were written, continuing where the last review stopped:
- eleven nouns: sport, spread, square, staff, stage, stairs, standard, star, state, statement, station
- six verbs: contest, contract, corner, crack, credit, crowd
- famous (adjective), invent (verb), invention (noun)
Each went to both reviewer models again, in four chunks of five run one after another (earlier runs lost work when a long background job was cut off). No chunk failed. Five entries came back with no issues at all: stairs, standard, station, invent, invention.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The reviewers raised 62 points. I accepted 24 and rejected 38; every decision is logged with its reason in reviews/decisions.jsonl.
Accepted changes:
- square and staff: the opening "core idea" sentence (which says what all the senses share) claimed too much. For square it said every sense has the square shape, which is not true of a dull person; for staff it said a military staff is only officers. Both are now accurate, and the military sense of staff now reads "a group of people, mostly officers, who help a military leader to plan and organize". The usage note now says British English also uses stave for the music sense, not that it uses only stave.
- star: the horoscope sense used read your stars, which is mainly British. The example and collocations now use what the stars say and written in the stars.
- crack: the joke sense mentioned crack a smile, which is a different meaning. By the house rule, an idiom goes under its first noun, so it belongs to smile (where it already is). It was removed from crack and a "see also" link to smile added.
- statement: a statement to the police can be spoken as well as written; the definition now says "often written and signed".
- contest, credit, crowd: definitions widened or made clearer (contest now includes competing for a position; credit now covers results that are not always good; crowd "come into or fill someone's mind in large numbers at the same time").
- contract: a transitive example was added (Contract your stomach muscles…), and a grammar pattern with no example was removed.
- corner ("make someone talk to you") lost its informal label; it is ordinary English.
- famous: rich and famous moved to the right collocation type, and the translator's note was made language-neutral.
Rejected, with reasons:
- Reviewer-a said the ceremony sense of state (a state visit, lie in state) is an adjective, not a noun. Lie in state and in state are noun uses, so the sense stays.
- Several objections ran against settled house rules: an explanation that names the kind of subject (Used of a voice) is where the style guide puts such restrictions; a region label means "mainly used there" (the British label on credit "believe", as in I couldn't credit it).
- Reviewer-b objected that crowd discusses crowded; be crowded with is also the passive of the verb, and the note names the adjective entry in one clause, as the style guide asks.
Spend
US$1.63 for this cycle; US$2.19 so far today of the US$15 daily cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed.
What is next
The review queue continues with underneath (adverb and preposition), steam, step, and onward; about 945 entries are still at one review round. The next build would start the high-frequency abbreviations (ad, app, Dr, p.m.…).
For the owner
Nothing new needs you from this cycle.