2026-10-22, run at 12:44 UTC, cycle 4: review
What this cycle did
This was a review cycle: a second reading of entries that so far have been through the reviewer panel only once. The scheduler chose it and allowed a block of twenty. About 973 entries were still at one round. I took the oldest twenty in the order they were written, continuing after soap: twenty nouns from society to spoon (society, sock, sofa, software, soil, soldier, solution, son, song, sort, soul, sound, soup, space, speaker, speech, speed, spelling, spirit, spoon). Each went to both outside reviewer models again, and I read every issue they raised. The panel ran in four chunks of five, as the last few review cycles advised, and no chunk was cut off.
What the reviewers found, and what I decided
There were 52 issues. I applied 18 and rejected 34, each with a logged reason. Reviewer-a raised all but four of them. Reviewer-b raised nothing on seventeen of the twenty entries; its three calls on son and sort were rejected.
Applied:
- solution: sense 3 said the mixed-in substance "cannot be seen", which is not what makes a solution (a colored liquid can be one). It now says the substance is mixed so completely that it becomes part of the liquid. Sense 2 said only "the answer to a question in a game or a test"; it now covers problems in mathematics too. The core idea, the one-sentence summary at the top of a long entry, follows both changes.
- sort: the comparison of sort, kind, and type said sort is more informal than kind. It now says only that sort is more common in British English and kind in American English. The "putting in order" sense lost its "informal" label (it is neutral, and used in computing) and the unnatural collocation do a sort. The usage note no longer bans sort of from all serious writing.
- soil: the note on soil, earth, and dirt is more careful about earth (a material you dig or hold) and about American dirt.
- space: the learner error not enough place in my suitcase stays, but its note no longer claims that place can never follow enough.
- speech and speaker: they were listed as words learners confuse. They are related, not confused, so each now points to the other under "see also". I changed both entries; the cross-reference tool would otherwise have put the old link back.
- Smaller fixes: spirit (an article removed from great team spirit, which is uncountable; a sharper definition of the "mood" sense), society (the "rich people" sense now says it is often found in high society), and sofa.
Rejected, among others:
- Eight objections to sense 4 of speech, "a group of lines that an actor says in a play". Reviewer-a held that actors only have "lines" or "monologues". She has a long speech in the second act is ordinary theater English.
- The claim that something that you hear is too broad a definition for sound.
- Several requests to remove the "informal" label from conversational phrases (by the sound of it, that's the spirit, for a song). The house test is whether the phrase would jar in a report, and these would.
- The request to give the phrase sort of its own entry. The house rule keeps idioms under their keyword entry.
Spend
US$1.50 for this cycle. The day stands at US$6.15 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed. One thing to watch: the knowledge base (the wiki/ folder of rules and notes) is now within about 60 words of its 30,000-word cap. A later run must trim an old note before adding a new one. NEXT.md says so.
Next
The run ends here after four cycles. The next review continues with sport, spread, square, staff... The next build continues with the band-1 suffixes -less, -like, -ly....
For the owner
Nothing new needs a decision.