2026-10-22, cycle 4 of the 00:44 UTC run: second review of sign to soap
What this cycle did
This was a review cycle: a second reading of entries that so far have been through the reviewer panel only once. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py) chose it and allowed a block of twenty. About 950 entries are still at one round; I took the oldest twenty in the order they were written, continuing after sight: twenty nouns from sign to soap (sign, silence, silk, sink, sister, situation, size, skill, skin, skirt, sky, sleep, slice, smell, smile, smoke, snack, snake, snow, soap). Each went to both outside reviewer models again, and I read every issue they raised.
The container this session runs in was restarted while the panel was working, after five entries. Their results had already been saved, so nothing was lost; I ran the other fifteen in groups of five. The same thing happened in an earlier run, so NEXT.md now says to keep the groups small.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The reviewers raised 35 issues, almost all from reviewer-a; seven entries drew none. I made 35 decisions: 14 applied and 21 rejected.
Applied, among others:
- sister: the first sense said a girl or woman who has the same parents as you, while its own explanation discussed half-sisters. It now says the same parents as you, or one of the same parents, the summary sentence matches, and the explanation adds that people often just say sister. The British hospital sense now says an experienced nurse with a high position, often one who is in charge of a part of a hospital.
- sign: the star-sign sense called a sign one of the twelve parts of the year; it now says one of twelve names given to periods of the year.
- silk: thin was dropped from the cloth sense, and the grammar note on the plural now says that silks can mean kinds of silk or silk clothes.
- smell: have a smell of this milk is mainly British; that sense now carries a British label.
- soap: the note Short for soap opera is a claim about where the word comes from, which a house rule keeps only in the etymology field. It now says The full form is soap opera.
- situation and slice: two notes for translators were made less absolute.
Rejected, among others:
- Four objections that go to sleep, get to sleep, put something to sleep, and lose sleep over something belong under the verbs. The house rule puts an idiom under its first noun, which here is sleep.
- Merging the two senses of sky. Clear skies is plural and about the weather; the splitting rule allows a new sense for different grammar.
- Several objections that ordinary nouns should not have an explanation field. The style guide asks for a grammar exception (a heavy snow, soaps for kinds of soap) to be stated in words.
- The claim that scale is not a synonym of size (the scale entry's first sense is the size or level of something), and that sister school makes sister an adjective (the entry already records that the noun is often used before another noun).
Spend and what is next
US$1.42 for this cycle; the day stands at US$3.17 of the US$15 cap. The next review block continues after soap (society, sock, sofa, software...). The run ends here, after four cycles, the most a run may have. A lint pass (the regular check of the whole knowledge base) is due in about one cycle. Nothing needs the owner from this cycle.