2026-10-21, cycle 2 of the 12:44 UTC run: second review of twenty nouns, service to sight
What this cycle did
This was a review cycle: a second reading of entries that had been through the review panel (two reviewer models from other companies) only once. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py) chose it as the most overdue kind of work, with a block of up to twenty. There were no unfinished drafts, so the block was the twenty oldest entries with only one review round. They are nouns written on 2026-10-07 and 2026-10-08: service, sex, shade, shadow, shame, shape, sheep, sheet, shell, ship, shirt, shock, shoe, shop, shore, shoulder, show, shower, side, sight.
The panel ran in three foreground batches of six or seven entries. An earlier run lost a background panel when its container restarted, and foreground batches avoid that.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The reviewers raised 45 issues, 42 of them marked blocking. I logged a decision for each: 27 applied, 18 rejected, none escalated (passed to the owner). Sheet, ship, and shore drew no issues.
One thing stands out: every issue came from reviewer-a. Reviewer-b sent a complete reply for all twenty entries, a verdict on every field, and found nothing. That fits the pattern in wiki/notes/reviewer-b-low-yield.md: on older nouns that have already had one review, reviewer-b rarely objects. The lint pass will see it in the precision figures.
The main changes:
- service: sense 3 (work for someone) now says the work or help is often given as a job or a duty. Sense 4 no longer says a religious service must take place in a church. The tennis sense now also covers a player's turn to serve. A service charge (an extra amount on a bill) was removed from sense 1, where it did not belong.
- sex: the usage note and the translators' note now describe gender as a person's identity and social role, not only "the social side of being a man or a woman". I rejected the objection to sense 2's definition: it already says the activity is "done for pleasure or to have children", which rules out the non-sexual cases the reviewer had in mind.
- shower: the party sense (a baby shower) now says "especially" before weddings and babies, and it is labelled Canadian as well as American.
- sight: lose sight of now gives both meanings, stop seeing something and forget an aim, in its definition, with an example for each. The ironic label on not a pretty sight was removed.
- shoe: the learner mistake I wear my shoes and leave the house can be read as correct (a habit), so it became Wait a minute, I'm wearing my shoes corrected to putting on.
- Smaller fixes: definitions on shadow, shell, show (for show), shame (put someone to shame), sheep (count sheep), and shirt (the shirt off your back); one British-sounding example on shop; the shop/store note; an example on shoulder.
I rejected, among others:
- Region objections on shoulder (the road edge, American) and side (a sports team, British; a side dish, American). In this dictionary a region label means "mainly used there", a settled house rule.
- Keeping What form is it? as a learner mistake on shape. It is limited to asking about a thing's outer form, where What shape is it? is the natural question.
- Have a shock, which the reviewer called unnatural. It is common, especially in British English.
Spend
US$1.97 for the two reviewers. The day stands at US$5.50 of the US$15 cap.
What is next
About 943 entries still have one review round. The next block starts with the nouns sign, silence, silk, sink. The run clock allows more cycles in this run; the next one starts with the scheduler's choice.
What needs the owner
Nothing new.