2026-10-20, cycle 3 of the 12:44 UTC run: second review of rubber to search
What this cycle did
This was a review cycle: a second reading of entries that had been through the two outside reviewers (the review panel, two language models from other companies) only once. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py) chose it as the most overdue kind of work. The block is always the oldest such entries; this time twenty nouns drafted on 2026-10-07: rubber, rug, ruin, safety, sail, salary, sale, salt, sand, satisfaction, sauce, scale, scene, schedule, school, science, score, screen, sea, search.
Each entry went to both reviewers again. I read every issue against the entry and either changed the entry (applied) or left it as it was (rejected, with a logged reason in reviews/decisions.jsonl). Nothing was escalated to the owner.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
Three entries drew no issues (ruin, sail, sale). There were 39 issues in all; I applied 24 and rejected 15.
Applied:
- school and sea: the opening summary sentence (the core idea) left out senses. School now covers universities and places for learning a skill; sea now says a very large amount of something rather than anything that seems as large.
- Two synonym links were really contrasts. A school inside a university is not the same as a department, and art is the opposite of science in an art, not a science. Both pairs moved from synonyms to compare, on both entries, with short notes.
- sea: the note that Americans say ocean where the British say sea was too absolute and appeared twice; it is now softened (often, usually) and kept once.
- scene: set the scene now means give people the information they need to understand what happens next, or create the conditions for something. The learner-error note no longer treats view as the same as scenery.
- score: a learner error (What is the point? for What's the score?) was doubtful and was removed.
- rubber (the condom sense), rug (cut a rug is now labeled dated, and an example with an unclear it was rewritten), safety and satisfaction (two translator's notes that said no plural or only countable too absolutely), screen (the the screen subsense: movies and television, as a kind of art or as a business), search (tool names such as search engine replaced in the collocations), scale (a small wording fix).
Rejected, with the main reasons:
- sea: reviewer-a said old-fashioned is not a currency label. It is one, in the closed list of labels the dictionary uses.
- sand: reviewer-b said the forms line "no plural" contradicts the notes about the sands. That line is written by a script (
tools/inflect.py) and has a known gap for one plural-only use; the notes are right. - salt: the chemistry sense, formed when an acid joins with a base, is the standard plain account.
- salary: the learner error about an hourly rate stands; its note already says not usually.
- Smaller: built on sand is the usual form of the idiom; according to schedule, a search warrant are typical; scores of and on that score need no register label.
Spend
The panel cost US$1.75, under this cycle's ceiling of US$3.00. The day stands at US$7.63 of US$15.
What did not work
Nothing failed. One of my rewordings (background in set the scene) failed the vocabulary check and was replaced with plainer words.
What is next
About 955 entries remain at one review round. The next block starts with verbs drafted on 2026-10-07 (carpet, chance, characterize, clothe, club, coin...).
For the owner
Nothing new needs you from this cycle.