2026-10-20, cycle 1 of the 12:44 UTC run: second review of request to routine
What this cycle did
This was a review cycle: a second reading of entries that had been through the two outside reviewers (the review panel, two language models from other companies) only once. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py) chose review because it was the most overdue kind of work, and the block is always the oldest such entries. This time the block was twenty nouns drafted on 2026-10-07: request, respect, rest, restaurant, result, rhythm, rice, ride, right, ring, risk, river, road, rock, roof, room, root, rope, route, routine.
Before starting, the usual checks found nothing stranded: no open pull request from an earlier run, the four leftover branches already fully merged and already listed for the owner to prune, and nothing in the inbox.
Each entry went to both reviewers again. I read every issue against the entry and either changed the entry (applied) or left it as it was (rejected, with a logged reason in reviews/decisions.jsonl). Nothing was escalated to the owner.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
Seven entries drew no issues at all (restaurant, result, rhythm, rice, ride, rock, routine). The reviewers raised 35 issues, 31 of them blocking (meaning the entry should not stand without a decision). I applied 20 and rejected 15.
Applied:
- respect: the idiom pay your respects now means a formal visit or going to a funeral to show respect, especially for someone who has died. The translator's note that said the feeling is uncountable now says so only of the feeling senses and adds that the detail sense is countable (in many respects).
- rest and ring: each had a usage note that described the entry as covering only its first sense (the noun about relaxing, the round object), while the entry also holds the music rest and the secret group. Both notes now cover every sense. The rest learner-error note now says have a rest, take a rest, or get some rest (not get a rest).
- rope: the definition now says twisting or weaving; learn the ropes moved out of the explanation of know the ropes into a phrase of its own with two examples; the translator's note on rope, cord, and string is softened, since the words overlap.
- route: the sense used in road names (Route 9) had a function-word definition (used before a number...); both reviewers flagged it, and it is now a noun phrase: a main road that has a number as its name.
- right: a learner-error correction, Turn right, used the adverb in the noun entry; it is now Turn to the right, with a note that bare turn right is the adverb.
- Smaller: river lost a literary label on a river of people, and its translator's note says English usually uses river for a large one; risk (danger sense) replaced a big risk with a possible risk; roof now says a roof over his children's heads; room got a clearer learner error (Is there a room for one more person in your car?).
Rejected, with the main reasons:
- rest: reviewer-a wanted come to rest, at rest, and lay someone to rest moved to verb or adjective entries. The house keyword rule puts an idiom under its first noun, here rest.
- ring, river: reviewer-b said phrase definitions must start with to. House style is the bare base form.
- Region labels: room and board and down the road (future) keep American, and by rights stays unlabeled; a region label means mainly used there.
- root: the word-part sense (the basic part of a word ... from which other words are formed) is accurate for learners even for roots that cannot stand alone.
- room and rope: Is there place for my bag? and I tied the present with a rope are real, common learner errors and stay.
- ring: a circus ring is a space where animals and people perform; the definition stands.
Spend
The panel cost US$1.68, under this cycle's ceiling of US$3.00. The day stands at US$5.07 of US$15.
What did not work
The first panel call ran in the background with a ten-minute limit and was stopped after thirteen entries (the panel takes close to a minute an entry). The finished reviews were kept, and the other seven were run again; nothing was lost or paid twice. NEXT.md now warns the next review run.
What is next
About 964 entries remain at one review round; the next block continues with the 2026-10-07 entries after routine (rubber, rug, ruin, safety, sail, salary, sale, salt, then sand, satisfaction...).
For the owner
Nothing new needs you from this cycle.