2026-10-19, cycle 1 of the 00:43 UTC run: second review of prayer to proof
What this cycle did
This was a review cycle: a second reading of entries that had been through the two outside reviewers (the review panel, two language models from other companies) only once. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py) chose review because it was the most overdue kind of work, and the block is always the oldest such entries. This time that meant twenty nouns drafted on 2026-10-06 and 2026-10-07, in alphabetical order: prayer, pregnancy, present, president, price, pride, priest, print, prison, prisoner, prize, problem, process, product, profession, profit, program, progress, promise, proof.
Each entry went to both reviewers again. I read every issue against the entry and either changed the entry (applied) or left it as it was (rejected, with a logged reason in reviews/decisions.jsonl). Nothing was escalated to the owner.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
reviewer-a raised 39 issues, 28 of them marked blocking (meaning the entry should not stand without a decision). reviewer-b raised 2, both minor, and gave a verdict on every field. Four entries drew no issues from either reviewer (pregnancy, price, prisoner, prize); most others had one to three. In all I applied 18 and rejected 23.
Applied:
- profession: the job sense listed the medical profession and the legal profession as its collocations (typical word combinations), but those phrases mean the people in the job, which is sense 2. They now stay with sense 2, and sense 1 has a respected profession, a well-paid profession, a demanding profession. The example She chose a profession in medicine was stiff and is now She chose medicine as her profession. The opening summary (the core idea) said the third sense was a statement of belief; it now says what you believe or feel, which covers professions of love.
- problem: the sense an objection (I have no problem with that) had an explanation that said the word is usually in have a problem with, which seemed to clash with sense 1 (We have a problem with the car). The explanation now says this applies to this sense and that a problem with a machine or a plan is sense 1.
- priest: the comparison with monk said a monk does not usually lead services; some monks are priests, and the note now says so. The usage note on addressing a priest is softened to do not usually say.
- prison: the translator's note said that with the the word means the building; it now says with a or the, matching the entry's own explanation.
- present: the present/gift comparison now says gift is a little more formal and common in shops and advertising, not the usual word there.
- progress: the translator's note put the wrong forms a progress and progresses in italics (house style keeps wrong forms out of prose) and seemed to deny the verb form progresses. It now says the noun has no a and no plural, and that progresses is a form of the verb.
- proof: the printed-copy sense was coded usually plural but its own examples used a proof; the code is gone.
- Smaller fixes:
prayer(the time of praying sense no longer requires a meeting); in print (print) now covers any printed text, not just books and newspapers;presidentuses the double mark for words named as words;productkeeps child as a synonym in the result sense (a child of its time) but now says so in a note.
Rejected, with the main reasons:
- pride: both reviewers wanted the animal sense to say a group of lions instead of a family group of the large wild cats plus the explanation Used only of lions. I made the change, then the vocabulary check (which keeps definitions inside a fixed list of plain words) showed that lion is not on the list and has no entry yet. I put the original back and logged the decision again as a rejection.
- Get with the program keeps its American label: a region label in this dictionary means mainly used there.
- Today stays a synonym of the present: the today entry has a sense for the present age (the world of today).
- Prison keeps one sense with an explanation for in prison versus the prison, as school and church do.
Spend
The panel cost US$1.57, under this cycle's ceiling of US$3.00. The day stands at US$1.57 of US$15.
What did not work
Nothing failed. The pride reversal shows why the vocabulary check runs before a reviewer's wording is accepted.
What is next
The next review block starts at protection, protest, public, punishment, purpose. About 963 entries remain at one review round.
For the owner
Nothing new needs you from this cycle.