2026-10-18, cycle 1 of the 00:43 UTC run: second review of peace to plastic
What this cycle did
This was a review cycle: a second reading of entries that had been through the two outside reviewers (the review panel, two language models from other companies) only once. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py) chose review because it was the most overdue kind of work, and the block is always the oldest such entries. This time that meant twenty nouns drafted on 2026-10-06, in alphabetical order: peace, performance, perfume, period, personality, pet, phone, photograph, picture, piece, pig, pill, pilot, pipe, pity, place, plan, plane, plant, plastic.
Each entry went to both reviewers again. I read every issue against the entry and either changed the entry (applied) or left it as it was (rejected, with a logged reason in reviews/decisions.jsonl). Nothing was escalated to the owner.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
reviewer-a raised 38 issues, 28 of them marked blocking (meaning the entry should not stand without a decision). reviewer-b raised 4 and gave a verdict on every field, so its replies were complete. Six entries drew no issues from either reviewer (personality, phone, photograph, pill, place, plastic). In all I applied 16 and rejected 26.
Applied:
- performance: the opening summary (the core idea, one sentence that says what all the senses share) began the way someone does something, which does not describe a show. It now says the act of doing something in front of other people or as a task.
- pig: the animal was defined as having a fat pink or dark body. Pigs come in many colors, and fat reads as a judgment; the definition now says a large round body. The core idea had tied the police-officer insult to behaving like a pig; it now just says the word is also used to say rude things about a person.
- piece: the art sense read as if music were written or painted; it now says something that someone has made as music, writing, or art, such as a short tune or a newspaper article. Man stays as a synonym of the game piece, because the man entry lists piece back, but it now carries a note: only in some games, such as checkers and chess.
- plan: the service sense said such plans are paid for in regular amounts, which fits a phone plan but not a savings plan. It now reads an arrangement in which you pay regular amounts for a service or to save money. Plan B lost its informal label: it is used in plain business writing too.
- period: the punctuation sense had an explanation field holding only British English says full stop. Explanations are for how a word is used, so the British word moved into the usage note.
- perfume: an explanation that only repeated the countability rule (already in the grammar and the learner-error box) was removed.
- Collocations added: an organ pipe, play a pipe (
pipe, music sense); it's a pity, what a pity, a great pity (pity, the shame sense).peace's make peace became make peace with someone.plant's a house plant (usually one word) became a potted plant (reviewer-b). - pipe: the smoking sense keeps dried leaves in its definition, because tobacco is not in the defining vocabulary, but an example now names tobacco.
Rejected, with the main reasons:
- pet project and pilot project: both reviewers called these nouns used before nouns rather than adjectives. The house treats them as adjectives, as learner's dictionaries commonly do, and
pet-adjandpilot-adjare already in the queue. A pet store is a store for pets, so it belongs with the animal sense. - A sweet perfume for a flower's smell is a normal countable use, like a scent.
- Make a performance is not idiomatic; the learner error stays.
- Plane is the everyday word in American speech too; the usage note stands.
- The old-fashioned labels on picture meaning a movie, British the pictures, and for pity's sake stand; more's the pity stays British; put that in your pipe and smoke it needs only informal.
Spend
The panel cost US$1.57, under this cycle's ceiling of US$3.00. The day stands at US$1.57 of US$15.
What did not work
Nothing failed. One small trap: removing a synonym from one side only (block and man under piece) would leave the other entry pointing back, so I restored both and adjusted the note instead.
What is next
The next review block starts at plate, platform, player, pleasure, plug. About 968 entries remain at one review round.
For the owner
Nothing new needs you from this cycle.