2026-10-17, cycle 1 of the 00:44 UTC run: second review of January to pan
What this cycle did
This was a review cycle: a second reading of entries that had been through the two outside reviewers (the review panel, two language models from other companies) only once. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py) chose review because it was the kind of work most overdue, and it picks the oldest such entries first. This block was twenty entries drafted on 2026-10-06: the month names January and June, the adjectives rocky and shiny, and sixteen nouns in alphabetical order (official, oil, operation, opinion, opportunity, order, organ, outside, oven, owner, pack, page, pain, paint, pair, pan).
Each entry went to both reviewers again; I read every issue and decided to change the entry (applied) or leave it (rejected, with a logged reason). I also read every entry myself.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
reviewer-a raised 51 issues, 34 of them marked blocking (meaning the entry should not stand without a decision). reviewer-b raised none at all, though it gave a verdict on every field of every entry, so its replies were complete; it was simply silent. Six entries drew no issues from either reviewer (January, June, official, operation, owner, pain). I applied 15 and rejected 36. Nothing needed the owner.
Applied:
- pan: the entry had a third sense, the amount that a pan holds (a pan of water). The reviewer was right that this is just the pan with something in it, which any reader understands from the first sense; the style guide says not to split a sense for that. The sense is gone; its water example moved to sense 1 with a short note, and the core idea sentence (needed only for three senses or more) was removed.
- shiny: a learner-error note said shining has one n, which is confusing, since the word has two. It now says the n before -ing is not doubled.
- opportunity: a note said the word always needs the or an, but the entry's own example (There wasn't much opportunity for rest) has neither. The rule is now limited to one particular chance (have the opportunity to).
- oven: the usage note now says British English also says oven; cooker is the British word for a stove with an oven.
- pair: the note comparing pair and couple now gives a couple of as two or a few.
- organ: organism was listed as a family word. It is not formed from organ in today's English, so it came off.
- order: the usage note gave the start of a sentence as a reason to use in order to, which is no reason; it now says to use it for a very clear purpose, especially in writing.
Rejected, with reasons logged:
- Pack meaning a bag on your back gets no region label; it is ordinary English everywhere (a hiker's pack).
- At the outside (at most) is used in American English too, so it is not labeled British.
- Take a page from someone's book keeps its American label: in this dictionary a region label means mainly used there, and British speakers usually say take a leaf out of someone's book. Open at page 20 is common British classroom English, so the learner-error note stands.
- In order to and in order that stay under order: the house rule files an idiom under its first noun.
- Minor objections to see-also links and to the synonyms attitude and mind on opinion were rejected; Out of order (wrong sequence), like watching paint dry, and a few collocation types were also left as they were. One small collocation fix on oil was applied.
My own additions
- The idiom a tall order (a very difficult task or request) added to order.
- page: the usage note said a page is one side of the paper and the whole piece is a sheet, but sense 1 says page can mean the whole sheet (tear a page out). The note now says so, and the two agree.
No new cross-links were created, and every definition word has an entry.
Spend
The panel cost US$1.36, the day's only spend so far (cap US$15).
What did not work
Nothing failed. reviewer-b said ok even where reviewer-a was right (the pan sense, the shiny note), the pattern in wiki/notes/reviewer-b-low-yield.md.
What is next
The scheduler will choose again. The next review block starts with paper, paragraph, parent, park; about 962 entries remain at one review round. The next lint pass is due in about two cycles.
What needs the owner
Nothing new. The two open questions (continent names in definitions; the former as noun or pronoun) are still in wiki/open-questions.md.