2026-10-17, cycle 3 of the 12:44 UTC run: confirm and eleven verbs, document to educate
What this cycle did
This was a closure cycle. Closure means writing entries for words the dictionary already uses but does not yet define, so that a reader can follow every link. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py) chose it as the most overdue kind of work.
The first source of closure words gave only one row: confirm, used in the definition of indeed. The queue had guessed it was a noun, but confirm has no noun use. I marked that row as a duplicate, queued the verb, and wrote it. The second source, family words (forms related to an existing entry), gave eleven verbs in queue order: document, dog, double, drug, drum, duck, dull, ease, economize, edge, educate. Each has a noun or adjective entry already, such as dog (the animal), edge, and education.
Every entry went through the full pipeline:
- the format check;
- inflections from the rules (all regular, with doubled consonants in dogged, drugged, and drummed);
- the pronunciation check;
- both outside reviewers;
- my decisions on each issue;
- the vocabulary and cross-reference checks.
All twelve are now reviewed. Economize lists the British spelling economise as a variant. Educate warns about a common confusion: in many languages the same word means bringing up a child with good manners, which in English is bring up or raise.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
reviewer-a raised 24 issues and reviewer-b 10. Two entries drew none (dog, economize). I applied 25 and rejected 9.
Applied, among others:
- My duck entry said the verb was not related in meaning to the bird. Both reviewers said this was wrong, and they were right; the sentence is gone. It was also a claim about origins, which belongs only in the etymology field.
- Phrases like well documented and well educated had been listed as adverb + verb collocations. The house rule puts a participle phrase under the phrase type (be well documented), so they moved.
- The church sense of confirm now reads accept someone as an adult member of a Christian church at a special religious service. The draft had said full member, which is not true of every church.
- Drum is no longer limited to a regular sound made with fingers or sticks. Drum up is now glossed as getting support by making an effort, not by working hard.
- An example that used documented as an adjective was replaced. The note on how the verb and the noun document sound different now says usually, not always.
- Double: the definition now covers twice as many for the transitive use. A learner error that was not really an error came out.
Rejected:
- reviewer-b asked four times for a bare intransitive pattern on verbs that can take an object or none. The closed list of patterns has no such value; the transitivity field already says it.
- reviewer-b also called two patterns from the closed list invalid.
- On drum, the remark that the subject is usually rain or feet stays in the explanation, where the house rules put subject restrictions.
- Double as can have a person as subject (the coach doubles as the driver).
- Two objections on edge were rejected: one contradicted itself, and the other was to the house style that a core idea is a full sentence.
My own checks
Three definitions used words outside the defining vocabulary (definite, ceremony, slip), so I reworded them. Twelve back-links were added to existing entries. One landed on the wrong sense: duck went under bend meaning change shape. I moved it by hand to bend meaning move your body. The queue also guessed sideways as a noun from the edge definition; it is an adverb and already queued, so that row is marked as a duplicate.
Pronunciation
Twenty-two of the twenty-four transcriptions were verified. The British forms of document (verb) and educate did not reach agreement. My first drafts used a weak middle vowel. When I changed them to match the existing entries document (noun) and education, one panel model agreed and the other two gave different answers. I kept the forms that match the existing entries. Both are flagged pronunciation-unverified, and the question is in reviews/needs_curator.txt.
Spend
The panel cost US$0.72, and the pronunciation checks about US$0.01. The day's total is US$5.29 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed.
What is next
The scheduler will choose again; this run may start one more cycle. Family verbs continue after educate.
What needs the owner
- Two British transcriptions (document the verb, educate), in
reviews/needs_curator.txt, along with sure and surely from the previous cycle. - The two older open questions are still in
wiki/open-questions.md.