2026-10-16, cycle 1 of the 00:44 UTC run: originality check, one rewrite
What this cycle did
This was an originality cycle: a spot check that the dictionary's wording is its own and not copied from a published dictionary. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py, the script that picks each cycle's job) forces one every tenth run, and this was run 440. It is the thirty-seventh such check.
The tool tools/originality_check.py picked ten fields at random from the whole dictionary: six sense definitions and three usage notes (the short boxes that explain how a word is used), plus one more definition. For each one I ran an exact-phrase web search to see whether any published dictionary uses the same words. I also asked one of the two reviewer models (reviewer-a, one of the two outside models that check every entry), in a single question, whether each text reads as copied, and to quote the published wording if it said yes. As in earlier checks, the search decides the verdict; the reviewer's answer is only a hint.
The ten fields and the verdicts:
- half (determiner), usage note on singular and plural verbs after half: grammar guides state the same rule, in their own words. Original.
- court (noun) sense 1, a place where legal cases are heard and decided by a judge: no exact match; a learner's dictionary says the place where legal trials take place, a different plain wording of the only possible idea. Generic overlap (short and plain by necessity, not copying).
- kill (verb), usage note on killed in an accident and on murder: no match. Original.
- run (verb) sense 6, flow somewhere in a stream, or make water flow from a tap: no match. Original.
- bottom (noun) sense 2, the ground under the water of a sea, a lake, or a river: no exact match; the closest page words it differently. Original.
- cell (noun) sense 5, the box in a table: no match. Original.
- danger (noun), usage note on in danger and in danger of: no match. Original.
- research (noun) sense 1, careful study of a subject to find out new facts or information about it: a well-known learner's dictionary has a careful study of a subject, especially in order to discover new facts or information about it. Ours is that wording with two words changed. Rewrite.
- long (adjective) sense 4, measuring a particular distance from one end to the other, or lasting a particular time: no match. Original.
- mail (verb) sense 1: no match. Original.
The rewrite
research sense 1 now reads organized work in which someone studies a subject closely, by reading, testing, or asking questions, to learn more than is already known about it. It covers all four examples (research into a disease, a company spending money on research, research on the history of a city).
A rewrite counts as a review, so the entry went through both reviewers again. Each raised one blocking issue, and I rejected both:
- reviewer-a said before you buy or decide something, in the subsense about finding information before a choice, is ungrammatical. It is not: decide takes an object (decide something).
- reviewer-b said the inflections field, which records no plural, contradicts the usage note, which says the plural researches is rare and formal. The inflections field is written by a script (
tools/inflect.py) and records no plural for uncountable nouns by house rule; the note is where a rare form belongs. No conflict to fix.
About the reviewer's answers
In earlier checks reviewer-a said copied far too often, usually quoting our own text back. This time it went the other way: it said copied to none of the ten, including the one real case (research), where it only said the wording "resembles standard definitions". So its silence proves nothing either. Search still decides. I added a line to the note that tracks this (wiki/notes/reviewer-noise.md).
Pre-flight
No open pull requests. Four old claude/* branches remain on GitHub; each is fully merged and already has a line in reviews/needs_curator.txt asking for it to be pruned (this tool set cannot delete branches). The inbox was empty.
Spend
About US$0.07 for this cycle (the reviewer question and the panel on one entry). The day stands at about US$0.07 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed.
What is next
The next originality check is due at run 450. The next review starts at do-aux, motor, move (noun), movement; the next build continues with band 1 adverbs after just.
For the owner
Nothing new needs you from this cycle.