2026-10-15 — second review of seventeen entries, a lot to menu
Cycle 1 of the run that started at 00:43 UTC on 15 October 2026. Run id 20261015T004350Z-p9d6ya.
What this cycle did
The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py, the script that picks each cycle's job from how much of each kind of work is overdue) chose a review cycle. A review cycle sends entries that have already been published back to the two model reviewers for a second reading, and I then decide on every objection. Every entry is reviewed once when it is first written; about 965 entries had only had that first reading. This cycle took the seventeen oldest of them, all written on 5 October 2026: the adverbs a lot and home; the auxiliary verb be; and the nouns mass, material, match, matter, mayor, meal, meaning, measure, measurement, meat, medicine, member, memory, and menu.
No new entries were written. The dictionary still has 2,375 entries, all of them published.
Before the review, the routine checks for unfinished work from earlier runs. There were no open pull requests. One old working branch (claude/wizardly-keller-lztq6d, from yesterday's 12:44 run) had already been fully merged; this tool set cannot delete branches, so it was listed in reviews/needs_curator.txt for the owner to prune. The inbox was empty.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The two reviewers ("reviewer-a" and "reviewer-b", two different language models) raised 38 issues, 30 of them marked blocking (meaning the entry should not stand until someone decides). I accepted 14 and rejected 24; none needed to go to the owner.
Changes made:
- home (adverb): the sense into place had the definition "into the right place, or as far as possible", which was vague. It now reads "fully into the right place, as far as it will go". The phrase drive something home had been listed under both this sense and the sense make someone understand; it now sits only under the second, where it belongs.
- a lot: the usage note told learners to use a lot of before a noun, but left out the common informal lots of. Both are now named.
- mass: the learner-error note said "use weigh or weight for people", which suggested the noun and the verb could swap. It now gives each its own pattern (I weigh sixty kilos; my weight is sixty kilos). The note comparing mass with weight now gives the science meaning of weight as well.
- meal: a square meal was defined as "a big, healthy meal"; it means a big, filling meal, not necessarily a healthy one. Corrected.
- meaning: the sense about purpose (the meaning of life) had an example and a collocation, lose its meaning, that a reader could take as the other sense (a word losing what it signifies). Both now use lose all meaning about a life. The learner-error note said questions with mean need does; it now says do, does, or did (What did she mean?).
- meat: an example with the plural cold meats now carries a short note ("plural: kinds of meat"), so it no longer seems to contradict the note that meat as food is usually uncountable.
- member and menu: two British expressions in examples were changed to the American forms the dictionary uses: staff members (for members of staff) and pay raise (for pay rise).
Main rejections, with reasons logged in reviews/decisions.jsonl:
- On memory, reviewer-a objected three times that the sense "the space in a computer or a phone where information is kept" confuses memory with storage. In everyday speech (my phone is running out of memory) that is exactly what the word means, and the entry's explanation already separates the technical meaning. Kept.
- Reviewer-a said three learner errors were not errors: We played a match of tennis, The tailor took my measures, and Can I have the card, please? (for the menu). All three are unidiomatic, and the last is a common mistake by speakers of languages that use a word like card for a menu. Kept.
- Reviewer-b wanted meal ticket moved out to its own entry and objected to a definition that was already in the required form. Both rejected under the house rules.
Reviewer-a's objections were accepted about one time in three this cycle, in line with its long-run record; reviewer-b raised only four issues.
Spend
The review panel cost US$1.27, the only paid work in this cycle. The day's cap is US$15. Yesterday, 14 October, closed at US$5.84.
What did not work
Nothing failed. All local checks passed: the validator, the size caps, the link checker, the unit tests, the defining-vocabulary check, and the cross-reference check.
What is next
The next review block starts with message, metal, method, middle, midnight, mind, and minister, the entries written on the afternoon of 5 October. The building of new band-1 words (the most frequent words) continues with the adverbs after down. The next lint pass (the periodic housekeeping check) is due in about five cycles.
What needs the owner
Nothing new. One more fully merged branch is listed for pruning in reviews/needs_curator.txt. The open questions in NEXT.md ("For the owner") are unchanged.