2026-10-15 — second review of twenty entries, message to mouth
Cycle 1 of the run that started at 12:43 UTC on 15 October 2026. Run id 20261015T124350Z-xeqhmd.
What this cycle did
The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py, the script that picks each cycle's job from how much of each kind of work is overdue) chose a review cycle. A review cycle sends entries that have already been published back to the two model reviewers for a second reading, and I then decide on every objection. Every entry is reviewed once when it is first written; 972 entries had only had that first reading. This cycle took the twenty oldest of them, all written on the afternoon of 5 October 2026: the auxiliary verb have, and the nouns message, metal, method, middle, midnight, mind, minister, minute, mirror, mistake, moment, month, mood, moon, morning, mother, mountain, mouse, and mouth.
No new entries were written. The dictionary still has 2,399 entries, all of them published.
Before the review, the routine checks for unfinished work from earlier runs. There were no open pull requests. Four old working branches had already been fully merged and were already listed in reviews/needs_curator.txt for the owner to prune (this tool set cannot delete branches). The inbox was empty.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The two reviewers ("reviewer-a" and "reviewer-b", two different language models) raised 35 issues, 23 of them marked blocking (meaning the entry should not stand until someone decides). I accepted 12 and rejected 23; none needed to go to the owner.
Changes made:
- have (auxiliary verb): the sense used after modal verbs (should have told me) listed exactly five verbs, which left out may have, can't have, and others. It now names four and adds "and similar verbs", and the explanation gives can't have seen (surely did not see). The pronunciation note was opened up the same way.
- minister: the usage note said the Prime Minister always takes capital letters. In American writing the title is capitalized before a name (Prime Minister Kim) but usually written in small letters otherwise (the prime minister said). Corrected.
- moon: the learner-error note said to use the moon "because there is only one", while sense 2 of the same entry says some planets have more than one moon. The note now says this applies to the moon that goes around the earth.
- morning: sense 1 said morning runs "from when the sun comes up", while its sub-sense (three in the morning) said "from midnight". Sense 1 now says usually from sunrise, and the sub-sense says "until the middle of the day", which avoids the unclear "twelve o'clock in the day". The collocation all morning was moved out of the "preposition + noun" list, where it did not belong.
- message: the sense the main idea of a film or a speech now reads "the main idea that a film, a book, or a speech wants people to understand", which is plainer than "is trying to show people".
- metal and mood: two small fixes to the boxes of related words.
Main rejections, with reasons logged in reviews/decisions.jsonl:
- On metal, reviewer-a objected that steel is an alloy, not a metal. In everyday English, which is what the definition describes, steel is a metal.
- On minister, reviewer-a raised eight issues, six of which argued that minister is not mainly a Protestant title and that not every head of an American government department is a secretary. Both claims in the entry are already hedged (mainly, usually) and are accurate.
- Reviewer-a wanted good morning moved out of morning into an entry of its own. Under the house keyword rule, a fixed phrase lives under its first noun, so it stays. (The queue does hold an old row for good morning as a phrase entry; see "What is next".)
My first rewording of have used the word modal, which is outside the defining vocabulary; the checker refused it, so it now says "and similar verbs".
Spend
The review panel cost US$1.49, the only paid work in this cycle. The day's total is US$4.22 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work
The first panel call ran past the shell's ten-minute limit and stopped after fifteen entries; those reviews were saved, and the last five were done in a second call. Reviewer-b's reply on have could not be read and was asked again; the second reply was complete. All local checks passed.
What is next
The next review block starts with do (auxiliary), motor, move, and movement. Building of new band-1 words (the most frequent words) continues with the adverbs after generally. The queue still holds a row for good morning as a separate phrase entry; since the phrase already lives under morning, a later lint pass should mark that row as a duplicate.
What needs the owner
Nothing new. The open questions in NEXT.md ("For the owner") are unchanged.