2026-10-14, run at 00:44 UTC, cycle 2: second reading of lip to bubble
Run id 20261014T010740Z-5i4a71. Mode: review.
What this cycle did
This was a review cycle: a second reading of entries that so far had passed through the reviewers only once. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py, the script that picks each cycle's job) chose it because reviewing was now furthest behind its share of the work. No entry was waiting as a draft, so the cycle took the oldest one-round entries by creation date: eighteen entries written on 2026-10-05. Six are nouns (lip, list, liver, load, loan, lock), and twelve are the "family" words written that morning to fill gaps next to existing entries: the adjective alike and the verbs bomb, bone, book, boot, boss, bottle, box, brainstorm, branch, bridge, and bubble.
Before sending them to the reviewers I read each one myself. Two things needed fixing:
- liver sense 2 was defined as the liver of an animal, eaten as food, which uses the headword in its own definition, against the house style. It now reads this organ from an animal, eaten as food.
- bomb (verb) means fail badly in informal English, but British English also has the noun phrase go down a bomb, meaning be very successful. A learner who meets both would be confused, so I added a short usage note.
The rest held up well: each entry had its signposts, pronunciation notes in plain words, and the right labels (bottle it, British and informal; book a football player, British).
What the reviewers found and what I decided
Two reviewer models from other companies read every field of every entry. They raised 30 issues, 23 of them marked blocking (meaning the entry must not be published until each is settled). I accepted 17 and rejected 13. None needed the owner. list came back with no issues.
Accepted, among others:
- Five definitions were tightened: liver (it does more than "clean the blood"; it now removes harmful things from the blood and helps the body use food), load in the sense of worry (the load is the worry itself, not a feeling), bridge sense 2 (a bridge does not go across a river; it is built over it), bubble with a feeling (anger and energy too, not only happiness), and book by the police (traffic rules as well as laws).
- The phone-lock subsense of lock said a phone opens only with the right set of numbers; it now covers passwords, faces, and fingers.
- My new note on bomb said the fail sense is mainly American. A reviewer pointed out that only the subsense do badly in a test is, and that subsense was already labelled American. The note now says exactly that.
- alike after two nouns (children and adults alike) now means equally, not both.
Rejected, among others:
- A reviewer wanted the whole hair sense of lock labelled literary. Only the plural locks meaning a person's hair is literary; a lock of hair is everyday English, and the explanation already says so.
- The second reviewer twice objected to a usage note that names a phrasal verb in one clause (bone up on, box someone in). The style guide asks for exactly that: one clause pointing to the other entry.
- A reviewer said brain is not a word-family member of brainstorm. The brain entry lists brainstorm in its family, and removing only one side would be re-created by the next consistency pass.
- alike stays gradable: more alike and very alike are common.
Spend
US$1.12 for this cycle; the day's total is US$2.00 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed. The second reviewer's yield on this batch was low: 7 issues, 1 accepted. That fits the low-yield pattern already recorded in wiki/notes/reviewer-b-low-yield.md; the next consistency pass measures it.
What is next
The oldest one-round entries now start with to (the infinitive marker) and the religion words written 2026-10-05 09:13 (Buddhism, Buddhist, Christian, Christianity, Islam...). About 948 entries remain at one panel round. Lint is due in about two cycles.
What needs the owner
Nothing new.