2026-10-13 (9): the thirty-fifth originality check
Run id 20261013T124415Z-3vvjdp, cycle 1 of the 12:44 UTC run. Mode: originality.
Why this mode
The mode selector (tools/next_mode.py, the script that picks each cycle's job) forced an originality check because this is run number 420, and every tenth run is one. An originality check takes a random sample of ten fields from the dictionary and asks one question about each: does this wording copy a published dictionary? The day's budget had US$7.84 left of the US$15 daily cap; this cycle's ceiling for paid calls was US$0.10.
Before the work
No pull requests from earlier runs were open. Three old working branches (claude/wonderful-bardeen-*) hold nothing that is not already in main; I listed them in reviews/needs_curator.txt for deletion, which this session's tools cannot do. The inbox was empty.
What the check found
The check tool picked ten fields: eight definitions and two usage notes (the short boxed notes on how a word is used). For each I ran an exact-phrase web search and looked only at whether a published dictionary or word list uses the same words. The verdicts:
- Original (6): idea sense 3, transport sense 3, the fool usage note, the duty usage note, father sense 3, and according to sense 2. No search found the wording.
- Generic overlap (2): butter (verb), spread butter on something, is the same four words in several dictionaries, but there is no other natural way to say it. exchange sense 2, a short conversation, especially an angry one, has no exact match; dictionaries say "conversation or argument" in their own ways.
- Rewrite (2): public sense 2 said connected with people in general. A well-known learner's dictionary has connected with ordinary people in society in general for the same sense: ours was that wording with a few words taken out. deliberately sense 1 said in a way that is planned or intended, not by accident. Learner's dictionaries define intentional as done in a way that is planned or intended and accidental as in a way that is not planned or intended: ours followed that frame.
I rewrote both from scratch:
- public sense 2 (public opinion, public support, public health): affecting or shared by most of the people in a country or community.
- deliberately sense 1: on purpose, because you have chosen to do it and not by accident.
The reviewer's answer to the originality question
The checklist also puts the question to one reviewer model (reviewer-a, with its hidden reasoning turned off). It answered copied for eight of the ten, each time naming the same learner's dictionary, and for seven of them the "quotation" it gave was our own text, word for word. For according to its quotation was different wording that the search did not find. As in earlier checks (wiki/notes/reviewer-noise.md), the verdicts rest on the searches.
The reviewers on the rewritten entries
A rewrite counts as a review of the entry, so both reviewer models read the whole of both entries again. deliberately came back with no issues. public came back with twelve issues, eleven of them marked blocking (meaning the entry should not be published until each is settled). I accepted one and rejected eleven:
- Accepted: reviewer-a said sense 3, connected with the government, or paid for by it, was vague for public schools and public services. I agreed and redefined it as run by the government or working for it, or paid for with the government's money, which covers public schools, public office, and public money.
- Rejected: that general is not a synonym of sense 2 (our own general sense 1 is "involving or shared by most people"); that state is not a synonym of sense 3 (state school, state sector); that public figure needs its own sense (sense 4, "known about by many people", covers it); that personal is not an opposite (personal life and public life contrast); that the grammar is inconsistent (some senses take more, some do not, which is normal); and a minor objection to one example. Both reviewers objected to the usage note and the learner error about in public and the public, saying noun uses belong in the noun entry. The note is two lines that send learners who look up the adjective to the noun entry; I kept it.
Each decision is logged in reviews/decisions.jsonl. No question was escalated to the owner.
Spend
US$0.15 in all: under one cent for the originality question and US$0.15 for the panel on the two entries. That is over this cycle's planned US$0.10, because the panel reads every field of the long public entry, as on the last check. The day's total is US$7.32 of US$15.
What did not work
Nothing failed.
What is next
The next originality check is due at run 430. The selector will pick the next cycle's mode; the build queue continues with band 1 adjectives after upset.
For the owner
Nothing new needs you. Three fully merged branches are listed in reviews/needs_curator.txt for you to delete when convenient.