2026-10-12, run at 00:43 UTC, cycle 4: second reading of twelve nouns, ground to guess
What this cycle did
A review cycle sends existing entries back to the two outside reviewer models (reviewer-a and reviewer-b) for a second reading, to catch what the first reading missed. The scheduler chose a review because review was furthest behind its usual share of cycles. No drafts were waiting, so the cycle took the twelve oldest entries that had been through the panel only once. All are nouns written on 4 October: ground, grandmother, habit, hall, handle, half, hair, guard, gun, guest, guide, and guess.
This was the run's fourth cycle, and four is the most a run may have, so the run ends here.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The reviewers raised 43 issues, 34 of them blocking (an entry with an unsettled blocking issue cannot be published). I read each against the entry and logged a decision for each in reviews/decisions.jsonl: 27 applied and 16 rejected. None went to the owner. guide and guess came back with no issues.
The main changes:
- habit: sense 2 had defined a strong need to keep taking a drug, drinking alcohol, or smoking, but its example (gave up her smoking habit) and its collocation a smoking habit are really the ordinary sense, a usual action. Sense 2 is now only the need for a drug, with a new example and collocations (a drug habit, a heroin habit, an expensive habit). The entry's notes had also said that habit is always followed by of and an -ing form; they now say so only of the pattern a habit of doing something. The note contrasting custom (a society's) with habit (a person's) now says usually. The phrase make a habit of something now covers doing something regularly as well as starting to.
- half: the example I'll take the bigger half was dropped (halves are equal by definition), replaced by Fold the paper in half. The British drink sense (I'll just have a half) was redefined; the reviewer was right that it is half a pint. Because the word pint has no entry yet and lies outside the defining vocabulary, the definition says a small glass of beer or another drink, holding half the usual amount, and the explanation names the pint.
- gun: the learner error (He shot to the bird → shot at) and the translator's note had stated a general rule about the grammar of shoot and fire. Both now describe only aiming at a target, and the note says that shoot someone means the shot hits, while shoot at someone means aiming and firing, hit or not.
- hall: the core idea now covers halls where students live and town halls, and hall of fame is defined as a group of people chosen for great success, or the building where they are remembered. A doubtful learner error (hall written as hole) was removed.
- Smaller fixes: guest (people invited to a museum event can be guests), under guard (watched to stop escape or to keep someone safe), stand your ground (hold your ground is not only British), and new collocations for the online name sense of handle.
Rejected, with reasons logged:
- Four region labels: thin on the ground and go halves (British), by a hair and hall meaning a passage (American). A region label in this dictionary means mainly used there, and each is true in that sense.
- A claim that
half-nshould not mention half an hour, half of them, or half asleep. Its usage note only points to the determiner, pronoun, and adverb entries, which is what the style guide asks for. - A request to write the phrase as make a habit of doing something: the slot also takes a pronoun (I don't make a habit of it).
- reviewer-b's point that the gun learner error belongs to shoot: it is the mistake learners make when talking about guns, so it stays.
Spend
US$1.08 for the panel. The day's total is US$1.94 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed. The vocabulary check caught pint in a definition I had just rewritten; fixed as described above.
The run as a whole
- Build: twelve adjectives, long to mental (
journal/2026-10-12.md). - The thirty-second originality check, no rewrites (
-2.md). - The sixty-sixth lint pass, no changes needed (
-3.md). - This review.
What is next
The next run builds from the band-1 adjectives after mental, or reviews the next one-round nouns from growth and group. The next lint pass is due in about five cycles.
For the owner
Nothing new needs you. The two open questions in wiki/open-questions.md still wait for a ruling.