2026-10-12, run at 20:44 UTC, cycle 3: review of island to visitor
What this cycle did
This was a review cycle. A review sends existing entries back to the two outside reviewer models (reviewer-a and reviewer-b, from two different companies) for a second reading, to catch what the first reading missed. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py, the script that picks each cycle's job from how long each kind of work has waited) chose it because review had waited longest. No drafts were waiting, so I took the oldest entries that had been through the panel only once.
The scheduler allowed up to twenty entries, but only about US$1.04 of the day's budget was left. The last review cost about six cents an entry, so I took thirteen: island, plus the twelve entries written in the 4 October 20:47 batch. Those were according to, apple, banana, the verbs bicycle, bike, bill, blanket, and block, and the nouns coal, setting, tube, and visitor. I ran the panel in the background, and it finished in about nine minutes.
What the reviewers found, and what I decided
The reviewers raised 20 issues, 16 of them "blocking" (an entry cannot stay marked as reviewed until each one has a decision). I applied 10 and rejected 10, and none needed to go to the owner. Five entries came back with no issues: apple, bicycle, bill, setting, and tube. Every decision is logged, with a short reason, in reviews/decisions.jsonl.
What I changed:
- island. The road sense said "a small raised area". Not every traffic island is raised, so it now says "a small area, often raised". Its first example said only island, which was unclear on its own, and now says traffic island. The kitchen sense called a kitchen island "a work surface or a cupboard". It is really a piece of furniture with both, so it is now "a piece of furniture with cupboards below and a flat top for working on, standing on its own in the middle of a kitchen".
- blanket (verb). The definition said "with a thick layer", but the entry's own examples include fallen leaves and flowers, which are not thick. thick is gone. The collocation box listed be blanketed with fog, which clashed with the usage note: in is the usual word with fog. It now lists be blanketed in fog, and keeps with for flowers.
- block (verb). Sense 1 mixed "be in a road" with "put something there". It now reads as one transitive phrase: "stop people or things from getting through a road, path, door, or pipe by being in it or by putting something in it".
- visitor. The website sense said "someone who looks at a website". It is now "someone who goes to a website and looks at its pages", and the core idea (the one-sentence summary at the top of the entry) was changed to match.
What I rejected, and why:
- A new collocation type, "noun + of + noun", for an island of calm. Collocation types come from a fixed list, and "noun + preposition" already fits.
- A British label on the road sense of island. Traffic island is used in American English too.
- Two issues on bike. Its first sense is defined as riding a bicycle, so the adaptation note that says so is consistent with it. The motorcycle use stays in sense 2.
- On rake someone over the coals: dropping the informal label. The phrase is informal in general use.
- A reviewer-b flag on coal and one on banana that both said a definition broke the base-form rule. Both definitions already follow it; on banana the reviewer's own comment said the wording was correct.
- Two minor notes saying according to's usage note repeats its explanation. The two overlap, but the note adds a point and an example.
- A minor note calling "usually passive" not a real verb pattern. It is on the fixed pattern list.
Spend
The panel cost US$0.83. The day's total is now US$14.79 of the US$15 daily cap. That is under the US$0.50 floor at which the routine stops paid work, so this run ends after this cycle. The budget resets at midnight UTC.
What did not work
Nothing failed. The panel cost about six cents an entry, as expected.
What is next
The next review starts with issue, item, and jacket (the 4 October 21:05 batch). The build queue continues with band-1 adjectives after sick.
For the owner
Nothing new needs a decision.