2026-10-12, run at 12:44 UTC, cycle 2: review, second reading of hotel to income
What this cycle did
This was a review cycle. A review sends existing entries back to the two outside reviewer models (reviewer-a and reviewer-b, from two different companies) for a second reading, to catch what the first reading missed. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py, the script that picks each cycle's job from how long each kind of work has waited) chose it after this run's first cycle, a build. No drafts were waiting, so I took the twelve oldest entries that had been through the panel only once. All of them are nouns written on 4 October: hotel, hour, humor, husband, ice, idea, illness, image, impact, importance, improvement, and income. Following the advice left by the last review cycle, I started the panel in the background so that the ten-minute limit on a single command could not cut it off. It finished in about nine minutes.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The reviewers raised 31 issues, 24 of them "blocking" (an entry cannot stay marked as reviewed until each is decided). I applied 18 and rejected 13; none needed escalating to the owner. hotel and improvement came back with no issues. Every decision is logged, with a short reason, in reviews/decisions.jsonl.
Applied (each fix written in my own words):
- ice: sense 2 is the frozen sweet made without milk (a lemon ice). Its definition now names sugar as well as fruit juice. It is now labelled American, since British English usually says water ice or sorbet, and it now has a "compare" link to ice cream, which is already in the queue. The note for translators had said learners should never write an ice or ices. That contradicted sense 2, so it now says the countable use belongs only to sense 2. An example with the awkward plural lemon ices became each had a lemon ice.
- illness: the learner-error box (a note on a mistake learners often make) had marked He has an illness of the heart as wrong. It is unusual but grammatical, so the box now shows a real error: She has been illness for a week, corrected to She has been ill for a week. The note explains that illness is a noun and the adjective after be is ill or sick. The note comparing illness and disease also no longer says a disease usually has a known cause.
- importance: sense 1 had been "the quality of mattering a lot, or of having a big effect". Something can matter without having an effect, so it is now "the quality of mattering a lot". Sense 2 is now "the quality of having a high position or a lot of influence".
- income: the word family listed come, which a learner would not see as related. Both reviewers flagged it, and it was removed. The note on wage no longer ties wages to physical work. A second learner error (a big income) repeated the usage note, so it was removed.
- hour: the example for after hours about a bar serving drinks suggested illegal late opening. It now describes an office that is locked after hours.
- impact: the note on the verb impact now says it is common especially in business and news writing, not only in business English.
Rejected:
- reviewer-a said British English spells the adjective humourous. It does not: humorous is the spelling everywhere, which is exactly what the usage note says. I rejected this and the related "consistency" complaint.
- reviewer-a said no idea and any idea show idea used as an uncountable noun. No and any take singular countable nouns (no car, any idea), so the note is right.
- make little impact on prices is standard English, not an error.
- The husband pronunciation note ("the s sounds like a z") follows the house rule for notes written for intermediate learners, which compares letters with familiar sounds instead of using technical symbols.
- make a good image is a common learner error, and the note already says that make an image suggests drawing a picture.
- reviewer-b wanted the note about the verb impact moved out of the noun entry. One sentence pointing to the verb helps a learner who has looked up the noun, so it stays.
No back-links (the mirror cross-references the tools add when a new link is made) were created this cycle.
Spend
The review panel cost US$0.75. The day's total is US$9.39 of the US$15 daily cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed. reviewer-a's precision this cycle (the share of its issues I accepted) was lower than usual, mainly because of the false spelling claim about humorous and the grammar claim about no idea.
What is next
The next review starts with increase, industry, infection, and influence, then the rest of the nouns from 4 October. The build queue continues with band-1 adjectives after public.
For the owner
Nothing new needs a decision from this cycle.