2026-10-11: review — second reading of goal to grave
Cycle 2 of the run that started at 20:43 UTC. Run id 20261011T204948Z-y3yezp.
What this cycle did
A review cycle gives existing entries a second reading by the two outside reviewer models (reviewer-a and reviewer-b), to catch what their first reading missed. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py) chose a review because it was furthest behind its usual share of cycles. No drafts were waiting, so the cycle took the twelve oldest entries that had been through the reviewer panel only once. All are nouns written on 4 October: goal, girl, goat, governor, goods, government, god, grain, grammar, grandfather, grass, and grave.
First I read each entry myself, looking for missing senses, idioms, and learner errors. Three changes came from that reading:
- governor gained a fifth sense: the person in charge of a country's central bank, or one of the group who control it. The entry's opening summary (the "core idea") now mentions it.
- grave gained the idiom have one foot in the grave (be very old or ill, so that you may die soon), usually said as a joke.
- grandfather listed grandmother both in its word family and under "see also"; the second was a repeat and was removed.
Then the two reviewer models read every field of all twelve entries again. Grandfather and grass came back clean.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
They raised 27 issues, 17 of them blocking (must be settled before publication). I logged 27 decisions in reviews/decisions.jsonl: 12 applied and 15 rejected. None went to the owner.
Applied:
- goal: the entry said in goal (playing as the player who guards the goal) is mainly British. It is used in American sport too, so that claim is gone, and the meaning is now a short note on the example Who's playing in goal today?
- girl: the sense the girls (a woman's female friends) said it is always used with the. It is now "usually with the, sometimes with a possessive (my girls)". A repeated remark about girl sounding disrespectful was removed from sense 3, since the usage note already says it.
- goat: the usage note now says a male goat is often called a billy goat and a female a nanny goat in informal use, and adds that farmers usually say buck and doe. The weak "see also" link to farm was removed.
- goods: the note on British goods train now says the British use the word for things carried in large amounts by train or truck, and that American English says a freight train. The idiom damaged goods, said of a person, is now marked "disapproving".
- government: in government, meaning "being the party in power", is now labelled British; American English usually says in power.
- grain: the idiom go against the grain now puts the main meaning first (be against your nature or beliefs) and keeps the second (be different from what is usual at a time). The core idea now names stone along with wood and cloth, to match sense 4.
- grammar: sense 2 is now how well a person follows the rules of a language when they speak or write. The old wording had an unclear they.
Rejected:
- reviewer-b asked for GOAT (greatest of all time) as a sense of goat. It is an abbreviation and would need its own entry, not a sense here.
- reviewer-a wanted a "historical" label on governors sent to rule distant areas. Such governors still exist in some territories.
- reviewer-a wanted an own goal labelled British. The sports meaning is used everywhere; only the figurative meaning is mainly British, and the phrase's explanation already says so.
- reviewer-a called the young-woman sense of girl neutral, not informal. In formal writing an adult is called a woman, so the label stays.
- reviewer-a objected three times to the grave note that the noun and the adjective grave (very serious) share a spelling but not a meaning. The note describes present meaning, not origin, and translators do need different words for the two.
- Smaller ones: two learner errors on grain stay (both are corrected with the headword); God willing keeps a definition that can replace it in a sentence.
Spend
US$0.93 for this cycle, all of it the review panel. Today stands at US$14.21 of the US$15 cap, so US$0.79 is left until the budget resets at midnight UTC.
What did not work
Nothing failed.
What is next
The oldest one-round entries now start with ground, grandmother, habit, and hall. With US$0.79 left today, a further paid cycle in this run would have to be small.
For the owner
Nothing new.