2026-10-11: review — second reading of game to glue
Cycle 3 of the run that started at 16:43 UTC. Run id 20261011T172102Z-ta2o7g.
What this cycle did
A review cycle gives existing entries a second reading. Two outside reviewer models check every entry when it is first written, and a second round catches what the first missed. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py) chose a review because, after two builds, it was furthest behind its usual share. No drafts were waiting, so the cycle took the twelve oldest entries that had been through the reviewer panel only once. All are nouns written on 4 October: game, garage, garden, gas, gate, gear, gender, generation, glass, glasses, glove, and glue.
First I read each entry myself, looking for missing senses, idioms, and learner errors. They were in good shape. I added one sense to game: the plural games for a large event with many sports competitions. The reviewers then showed that this use lives almost only in the names of particular events, and that the examples read oddly without a name, so I removed it again.
Then the two reviewer models read every field of all twelve entries again. On garden, reviewer-b's first reply came back with no verdicts, so I ran it again by itself; the second reply was complete and raised no issues.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
They raised 49 issues, 41 of them blocking. Glasses came back clean. I logged 49 decisions in reviews/decisions.jsonl: 34 applied and 15 rejected. None went to the owner.
Applied:
- gender: sense 1 defined gender as a group such as man or woman. It now reads the fact of being a man, a woman, or something else, as part of who a person is and of how society treats them, and the usage and adaptation notes say the same.
- gear: the definitions said gears control how wheels turn; they now say gears change how fast a machine moves and how much force it has. The toothed wheel (subsense 1a) can turn another part or be turned by it.
- glass: a drinking glass need not be made of glass (plastic ones are common); the definition and the adaptation note now say usually.
- garden: sense 3 called a public garden a public park; it is now a large area of land with many flowers, plants, and trees, which is open to the public, and park is no longer listed as its synonym.
- glue: sense 2 (the glue that held our family together) is now uncountable, matching its examples.
- garage: the repair sense lost its British label; American English uses it too.
- gas: sense 4 (gas in the stomach) is now gas that forms in your stomach and can make you feel uncomfortable, and the synonym wind is marked British.
- generation: the process sense (the generation of electricity) lost its formal label; the usage note now says a singular verb is usual and British English only sometimes uses a plural one.
- game: the note on game and match no longer says British English always says match; one learner error (We made a game of cards, which is grammatical with another meaning) was removed. One learner error on glove (I bought a new glove) was removed for the same reason.
Rejected:
- reviewer-a wanted lead someone down the garden path changed to up the garden path. Down is the usual American form; the entry already notes that British English says up.
- gas sense 4 keeps its American label. By the house rule, a region label means mainly used there; British English mostly says wind.
- play and toy stay as cross-references from game: many languages use one word for game and play, and some for game and toy.
- out of gear, the learner error Close the garden door (for a gate), and male gender (for male) stay; all are real.
A slip, and how it was fixed
While moving a cross-reference, I ran a command that reset glass to its state before this cycle, which also dropped the record of its second review. I restored the review record from the saved review file with the review tool's own function and applied the fixes again. Nothing was lost.
Also, the cross-reference tool keeps word-family links symmetric, so taking glasses out of glass's word family alone did not stick. Both entries now point to each other under see also instead.
Spend
US$0.88 for this cycle, all of it the review panel. The day stands at US$12.43 of the US$15 cap.
What is next
The oldest one-round entries now start with goal, girl, goat, and governor. The adjective build continues after important.
For the owner
Nothing new.