2026-10-11: review — second reading of fail to gain
Cycle 2 of the run that started at 12:43 UTC. Run id 20261011T130409Z-7cgg25.
What this cycle did
A review cycle gives existing entries a second reading. Two outside reviewer models check every entry when it is first written, and a second round catches what the first missed. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py) chose a review because it was furthest behind its usual share. No drafts were waiting, so the cycle took the twelve oldest entries that had been through the reviewer panel only once. All were written on 4 October: the nouns fail, hollow, friendship, front, fruit, fuel, fun, funeral, fur, furniture, future, and gain.
First I read each entry myself, looking for missing senses, idioms, and learner errors. They were in good shape. I made one change, prompted by the previous cycle: the usage note on fun (noun) called a fun day informal, but the new fun (adjective) entry, after review, no longer carries that label. The note now just says that before a noun, fun is the adjective, and points there.
Then the two reviewer models read every field of all twelve entries again. On friendship, reviewer-b's first reply was cut off with no verdicts, so I ran it again by itself; the second reply was complete and raised no issues.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
They raised 30 issues, 27 of them blocking. Funeral and furniture came back clean. I logged 30 decisions in reviews/decisions.jsonl: 21 applied and 9 rejected. None went to the owner.
Applied:
- gain: sense 3 was defined as money from selling something at a higher price, but its own example was for personal gain, which usually means any benefit for yourself. Sense 3 now reads money or another benefit that you get for yourself.
- fur: the sense for animal skin used for clothes also covered a fur (a fur coat), which is countable and means something different. The coat is now subsense 2a, with its own examples.
- fuel: the figurative sense (fuel for an argument) was too broad; it now says makes a feeling or an argument stronger, or gives people more reason for it. The adaptation note no longer says fuel is always burned.
- front: a front for crime may hide something secret rather than illegal, and a weather front is where two air masses of different temperatures meet, not always cold meeting warm. Both definitions are fixed.
- future: the finance sense (oil futures) no longer suggests that money itself is the usual thing traded. The repeated link to tomorrow under "see also" was removed.
- Smaller fixes: fail (a silly mistake) no longer says the person must look stupid; hollow lost an awkward example (the hollow of her hand); fruit has a clearer core idea; the note on friendship's learner error no longer implies one tense is the only choice; the fun part was removed from the noun fun, because there it is the adjective.
Rejected:
- Reviewer-a wanted in front, out front, up front, and front and center moved out of the noun front. The house rule files an idiom under its first noun, which here is front.
- Tomorrow stays as a synonym of the future: the tomorrow entry has a sense meaning exactly that. Tail stays as an opposite of front for the back of a line or a vehicle.
- Hollow (a hole, or a place where a surface goes in) stays one sense; the uses share one core meaning.
- In fun is not formal. Fun and games, used straight or as a joke, stays one phrase.
The cross-reference tool added no new return links, and the vocabulary check found no definition words outside the defining vocabulary.
Spend
US$0.83 this cycle (the review panel, including the one re-run). US$9.68 so far today of the US$15 daily cap.
What did not work
Reviewer-b's first reply on friendship had no verdicts. The tool's re-run handled it, as it has since the fix of 5 October.
What is next
The scheduler picks the next cycle. The oldest one-round entries now start with game, garage, garden, gas, and gate (4 October).
For the owner
Nothing new needs you.