2026-10-11: review — second reading of fridge to deliberately
Cycle 4 of the run that started at 08:43 UTC, and the last (a run has at most four cycles). Run id 20261011T091559Z-lxu13d.
What this cycle did
A review cycle gives existing entries a second reading. Every entry is checked by two outside reviewer models when it is first written; a second round catches what the first missed. The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py) chose review because it was furthest behind its usual share. No drafts were waiting, so the cycle took the twelve oldest entries that had been through the reviewer panel only once, all written on 4 October: the nouns fridge and friend, the verbs battle, beach, beautify, bed, befriend, belt, bench, and benefit, the noun cheat, and the adverb deliberately.
First I read each entry myself, looking for missing senses, idioms, and learner errors. They were in good shape. I made two small changes: fridge now points to refrigerator under "see also", and befriend no longer lists friend twice (it was in both its word family and "see also").
Then the two reviewer models read every field of all twelve entries again.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
They raised 26 issues; bed, benefit, and deliberately came back with none. I logged 26 decisions in reviews/decisions.jsonl: 17 applied and 9 rejected, none sent to the owner.
Applied:
- cheat (noun) had a subsense for a person who is unfaithful to a partner. The reviewer was right that this is not a separate meaning of the noun: someone who cheats on a partner is simply a dishonest person, and the main sense already covers that. The subsense was removed. Its learner error (Don't make cheat in the exam) was about the verb, so it was replaced by a noun error: He is cheat should be He is a cheat.
- beach (verb): sense 1 said "bring a boat out of the water", but beaching a boat is simply moving it onto the shore, so it now says that. Sense 2 was marked as both transitive and intransitive, but every example has an object or is passive, so it is now marked transitive.
- bench (verb): the weight-lifting sense described lifting one weight once; it now describes the exercise.
- battle and beautify: their usage notes said the words belong mainly to news or official writing. Both are also ordinary in speech (battle the traffic, beautify a garden), and the notes now say so. beautify no longer claims that the word sounds humorous about a person.
- Small fixes: fridge's note on the British fridge-freezer now says what American English calls the same machine; befriend and belt have better collocations; a duplicate "see also" link on battle was removed.
Rejected:
- The American label on bench (keep a player out of a game) stays: the project's rule is that a region label means mainly used there.
- beach, sense 2: the reviewer wanted it widened to people and boats that end up on the shore. Those uses are figurative or already covered by sense 1; the sense describes stranded sea animals, and whales beached themselves is the ordinary wording in the news.
- Two "see also" links the reviewer thought unhelpful (war from battle, shore from beach) are kept, because both are related entries worth reading.
- friend: the reviewer asked for an attitude label on friends in high places and a "proverb" label on a friend in need is a friend indeed. The first is neutral in most uses, and the project's closed list of labels has no "proverb" value.
Spend
US$0.63 for the review calls. The day's total is US$7.79 of US$15.
What did not work
Nothing failed.
What is next
This run has reached its four-cycle limit. The next run's scheduler will choose again; the next one-round entries in age order begin with fail (noun), hollow (noun), friendship, and front. About 878 entries remain at one review round.
For the owner
Nothing new. The continent-names question and three pronunciation disputes still wait for you (NEXT.md, "For the owner").