2026-10-10 (14): originality — the twenty-ninth check, two rewrites
Cycle 2 of the run that started at 12:44 UTC. Run id 20261010T130458Z-9zjnpp.
What this cycle did
An originality check tests whether the dictionary's wording is its own. Every tenth cycle, the selector tool forces one; this was run 360. The check tool picks ten fields at random from the published entries (definitions of senses and phrases, and one usage note). For each, I searched the web for the exact wording, and I asked one reviewer model whether it reads as copied from a published dictionary. Each field then gets one of three verdicts: original; generic-overlap (a short plain definition that any dictionary would write in much the same way, which is not copying); or rewrite (it follows a published dictionary's distinctive wording or structure, so it must be rewritten).
The ten fields came from end (the phrase in the end), cause, thing, string (the computing meaning), blood (new blood), information (information desk), crop (a group appearing at the same time), home (home sweet home), ball, and the usage note of meet.
Results
Original 6, generic-overlap 2, rewrite 2.
- ball, sense 1, read "a round object that you throw, kick, or hit in a game". A well-known learner's dictionary and an open word list both define ball with the same three verbs in the same frame. The definition is short and plain, but the shared frame is the distinctive part, so I rewrote it: "a round object, often filled with air, that people play with in games and sports".
- blood, sense 3 (new blood), read "new people who bring fresh ideas and energy to a group or organization". A learner's dictionary defines new blood as new people in an organization who will provide new ideas and energy: the same frame. It now reads "people who have just joined a group and can make it more lively and successful".
Both rewritten entries went back through the two-reviewer panel, as any rewrite must. blood drew no issues. ball drew three blocking issues on other parts of the entry, which I decided like any review: I applied two (sense 3, a pass in sport, and sense 5, the vulgar body meaning, were both redefined more accurately) and rejected one (the reviewer wanted to remove the American label from drop the ball; the project's rule is that a region label means "mainly used there", and the idiom is still mainly American).
The reviewer's answers
The reviewer model answered "copied" for nine of the ten, each time naming a learner's dictionary and giving a "quotation". Every quotation was simply our own text repeated. I searched that dictionary's own website for four of them: for cause, string, and information desk its wording is clearly different; only new blood shared a frame, and the general search had already found that. So the reviewer's answers were set aside, and the verdicts rest on the searches and my own reading. This matches what earlier checks found (wiki/notes/reviewer-noise.md).
Spend
US$0.28 (two panel reviews and one reviewer question). The day's total is US$12.99 of the US$15 cap, which resets at midnight UTC.
What did not work
Nothing failed. The reviewer's originality answers are again unreliable; no change is proposed beyond what the reviewer-noise note already records.
What is next
The next cycle's mode is chosen by the selector. Builds continue with band-1 adjectives after cheap.
For the owner
Nothing new. The leftover branch claude/wonderful-bardeen-22po9n can still be deleted.