2026-10-09 (7): review — destruction to disability
Cycle 3 of the run that started at 04:43 UTC. Run id 20261009T045606Z-jdpis4.
What this cycle did
A review cycle gives existing entries a second reading. Every entry is checked by two outside reviewer models (the panel) before it is published, but most entries have been through the panel only once. The scheduler picked a review cycle, and the queue says to take the oldest of these one-round entries first. This time that meant twelve nouns created on 2026-10-02 and 2026-10-03: destruction, detail, development, device, dictionary, difference, difficulty, dinner, direction, director, dirt, disability.
Before sending them to the panel, I read each entry as a whole, looking for common senses, idioms, collocations (words that typically go together) or learner errors that were missing. Most of these entries were already full, so the additions were small:
- detail: a new sense 5, the small group of soldiers or police given one job (a security detail, a protection detail). Sense 4 (a part of a painting) had no collocations and now has a detail from something.
- development: two learner errors, many development countries (it should be developing countries) and a new develop in the story (the verb used where the noun is needed).
- dinner: the collocations the dinner table, dinner time, a dinner plate.
- dirt: the informal idiom dish the dirt (tell people private or unkind things about someone).
All twelve then went through the full checking pipeline: format validation, inflections (all verified), pronunciations, and both reviewers. Twenty-three of the twenty-four transcriptions were confirmed. The American detail was disputed by the panel again (one model of four agreeing with stress on the first part, although the open pronouncing dictionary agrees). The entry already carries a flag for this and lists the other stress as a variant, so nothing changed.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The panel raised 24 issues: 22 from reviewer-a and 2 from reviewer-b. I applied 9 and rejected 15, each with a short reason in reviews/decisions.jsonl. None needed the owner.
Applied:
- development, sense 4. It mixed two meanings with different grammar: a group of new buildings (countable: a housing development) and the work of building on land (uncountable: land sold for development). The countable meaning is now the sense, and the uncountable one is a subsense under it. The usage note now lists both. Reviewer-b also pointed out that Americans live in a housing development, not on one; the example was changed.
- direction. The usage note said that this direction, the opposite direction, and the wrong direction always take in. That is true when they describe movement (walk in the wrong direction), but informal American English sometimes leaves in out (go that direction). The note and the matching translator note now say this.
- director. The film-and-play sense now carries a theater label beside the film-and-television one. A learner-error note said the article is left out "only" before a title that one person holds; it now says "often".
- disability. The collocation disability pay was replaced by the more common disability payments.
Rejected:
- Both reviewers said the idiom dirt cheap should go under cheap, because it works as an adjective. The house rule is that an idiom goes under its first noun, whatever part of speech the whole phrase has, so it stays under dirt.
- Reviewer-a said a "dictionary of a subject" gives only words, not information about topics. Many subject dictionaries (a dictionary of music) explain topics too, and the definition covers both.
- It said make a difference need not mean a good effect. The definition already says "especially a good effect", and the explanation covers make no difference.
- It said Can you tell me the direction to the station? is not a real learner error. Asking for the route takes the plural, directions; the singular asks only which way the station lies.
- The other six: two label requests on device (a domain label is used only for specialist fields, and the bomb sense is ordinary news language), one on dinner's translator note (such notes are meant for translators), two on dirt's uncountable notes (the claims hold: in a dirt road the a belongs to road), and one on director's note about managing directors, which already says "often".
Spend
US$0.92 for this cycle, almost all of it the panel. The day stands at US$4.90 of the US$15 daily cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed.
What is next
The next review cycle starts from disadvantage, disappointment, discount, and discovery. About 760 entries remain at one panel round.
For the owner
Nothing new.