2026-10-09 (19): review — dust to email
Cycle 3 of the run that started at 16:44 UTC. Run id 20261009T170545Z-xcqumb.
What this cycle did
A review cycle gives existing entries a second reading. Every entry is checked once by two reviewer models (AI models from two different companies, called reviewer-a and reviewer-b) before it is published. A review cycle sends older entries back to them for a second round, and I also read each entry myself, looking for missing senses, idioms, and learner errors. The scheduler chose review because it was the most overdue mode. About 800 entries have had only one round; they are taken oldest first, twelve at a time.
This cycle's twelve, all nouns written on 2026-10-03: dust, duty, ear, earth, economy, edge, effect, effort, egg, election, electricity, and email.
What I added before the reviewers saw them
- ear gained three phrases: keep your ear to the ground (pay attention to what people are saying), from ear to ear (smiling very widely), and lend an ear (listen kindly).
- earth gained a fourth sense, the British word for the safety wire that connects a machine to the ground (Americans say ground), and the phrase come back down to earth.
- duty gained the humorous phrase duty calls, and edge gained push someone over the edge.
The other entries already had the common senses, phrases, and learner errors.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The panel raised 30 issues, 24 of them marked blocking. I agreed with 22 and fixed the entries myself, and rejected 8 with a logged reason. None needed the owner.
Fixes I agreed with:
- earth: down-to-earth (practical and sensible) was listed as a phrase of the noun, but it is an adjective, so both reviewers objected. It was removed and added to the queue as an entry of its own. The entry also told learners that travel around the earth is wrong, which it is not; the learner error now shows a real mistake (the best singer on the earth, for in the world), and the translator note agrees.
- earth, again: my new sense is countable (an earth), but the forms field still said "no plural". That field belongs to the inflection tool, so I re-ran the tool, and it now gives earths.
- egg: the sense "a cell in a woman's body" said the cell can develop into a baby. Reviewer-a pointed out that it must first join with a cell from a male. The definition and one example were corrected.
- economy: the example We flew economy uses the word like an adverb, which belongs in a different entry. It now reads We bought two seats in economy.
- edge: my new phrase's definition mentioned mental illness, which the idiom does not need to imply. It now says only "lose control of their feelings".
- email: the notes said that a mail can never mean one message. They now say more exactly that mail is uncountable in American and British English, so one message is an email. Mail moved from the word family to "see also", because email is not formed from it in today's English.
- dust: a synonym, powder, moved to the powder sense, and the usage note no longer explains the verb at length.
What I rejected: reviewer-b again asked for verb definitions that begin with to, against house style, and for collocation items without articles. Reviewer-a called make a big effort unidiomatic; it is common. Reviewer-a also objected that the forms field says dust has no plural while the usage note mentions the rare plural dusts; the style guide asks for exactly this: the ordinary rule plus the exception named as one.
The vocabulary check found no definition word outside the defining vocabulary, and the cross-reference tool added no back-links.
Spend
The review panel cost US$0.95. The day stands at US$12.87 of the US$15 daily cap, so the next paid cycle has about US$2 left.
What did not work
Nothing blocked the cycle.
What is next
The review continues with the oldest one-round entries from emergency and emotion onward. The new queue row down-to-earth-adj waits for a build or closure cycle.
What needs the owner
Nothing new.