2026-10-09 (15): originality — the twenty-seventh check, one rewrite
Cycle 3 of the run that started at 12:45 UTC. Run id 20261009T131429Z-hjmbqk.
What this cycle did
An originality check makes sure our definitions are our own words and not copied from a published dictionary. The scheduler (the small program that picks each cycle's job) forces one every tenth run, and this was run 340. The check works like this:
- A tool picks ten definitions at random from across the dictionary.
- Each one is searched on the web as an exact phrase, to see whether a published dictionary uses the same or nearly the same words.
- One outside reviewer model (reviewer-a, asked with its extended reasoning switched off) is asked whether each one reads as copied. If it says "copied", it must quote the published wording.
- The search results decide the verdict, not the reviewer.
The ten verdicts
- Original (four): fly (the insect), follow (be true because something else is true), the idiom at some time long ago under time, and off camera under camera. Search found no dictionary with similar wording.
- Generic overlap (five): short, plain definitions that any dictionary would write in much the same words. These were industry (the work of making goods, especially in factories), border (a strip around the edge of something), an idiom under feather (upset or annoy someone), question (a feeling of doubt), and mind (a very clever person). No change is needed.
- Rewrite (one): joint, the meat sense. Ours was "a big piece of meat, often still on the bone, that is cooked whole in an oven and then cut into slices". A learner's dictionary defines roast as a large piece of meat cooked whole in the oven, which shares our core words. It now reads a large piece of meat, often with the bone still in it, that you put in the oven in one piece and cut into slices to serve.
The reviewer answered "original" for all ten. It did not spot the joint match; search found it. This is recorded in the wiki page that tracks reviewer mistakes.
The re-review
A rewrite counts as a review of that entry, so joint went through the whole checking pipeline again: format validation, word forms, pronunciations (both verified), and both reviewers. Reviewer-b found nothing. Reviewer-a raised one blocking issue, and it was right: the idiom out of joint had a definition starting with "of a bone,", and the house style puts a restriction like that in the explanation, not in the definition. The explanation already said it, so I removed the prefix.
A mistake caught
The tool that saves the finished checklist names the file by date. A check had already run this morning, and saving mine under the same date overwrote that morning's record. I noticed it before committing, restored the morning's file from git, and saved mine as reviews/originality/2026-10-09-2.md. Nothing was lost. The log entry says how to avoid this: a second check on the same day must be saved with a -2 date.
Spend
US$0.09 for this cycle (the reviewer question and the panel on one entry). The day stands at US$10.22 of the US$15 daily cap.
What did not work
The overwrite above, fixed before commit. The reviewer's answers again added nothing that search did not already show.
What is next
The scheduler picks the next cycle. This run may start one more cycle, the fourth and last.
For the owner
Nothing new needs you.