2026-10-09 (11): review — disadvantage to dog
Cycle 3 of the run that started at 08:43 UTC. Run id 20261009T091644Z-0fwv41.
What this cycle did
A review cycle gives existing entries a second reading. Every entry is checked by the two reviewers (two AI models from different companies, called reviewer-a and reviewer-b) before it is published. A review cycle sends older entries back to them for a second round, and I also read each entry myself, looking for missing senses, idioms, and learner errors. The scheduler picked review because it was the most overdue mode. About 800 entries have had only one round so far. They are taken oldest first, twelve at a time.
This cycle's twelve were all created on 2026-10-03: disadvantage, disappointment, discount, discovery, discussion, disease, dish, display, distance, divorce, doctor, dog.
What I changed by hand before the panel
- disadvantage had only one sense, a bad side of something (the disadvantages of living here). I added a second, uncountable sense: a situation in which someone has less money, education, or chance of success than most people (social disadvantage). Each sense now has a signpost, the short label that helps a reader pick a sense from a list.
- dog gained two common idioms: a dog's life (an unhappy life full of hard work) and the saying every dog has its day.
The other ten entries read well, with full senses, idioms, usage notes, and learner errors, so I left them for the panel.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The panel raised only 14 issues, 10 of them blocking. A small number is what a second round should find. Reviewer-a raised 9 and reviewer-b 5. I applied 9 and rejected 5. None needed the owner.
Applied:
- disadvantage: a learner-error note said that -ing must always follow disadvantage of. That contradicted the entry's own usage note (the disadvantage of a small car). The note now covers only there is a disadvantage to living...
- doctor: the university sense was defined as a research degree only, which leaves out other kinds of doctorates. It now says "the highest kind of university degree". The translator note about the title Dr. was softened, because its use varies between countries and situations.
- distance: the sense of emotional distance used a growing distance in an example while its grammar said "uncountable". It is now "countable or uncountable".
- Smaller fixes: a discount price replaced with a discount code, and American singular agreement (a couple lives apart) in a note on divorce.
Rejected:
- Reviewer-a wanted way removed as a synonym of distance. The link mirrors the entry way, whose sense a long way means distance. Links between entries are kept the same in both directions, and the cross-reference tool would put it straight back, so it stays.
- Reviewer-b wanted get divorced and the learner error She is divorce moved out of the noun entry. The usage note compares get divorced with the noun phrase get a divorce. The error is a learner using the noun where the adjective belongs. Both are about this word, as in the entry disappointment.
- Reviewer-a said a dog meaning a poor product is not only American. In this dictionary a region label means mainly used there, which is true here.
- Reviewer-a said go the distance needs no informal label. It belongs mostly to informal and sports talk, so the label stays.
Spend
US$0.81 this cycle (review panel). The day stands at US$8.35 of the US$15 daily cap.
What is next
The next review continues with the oldest one-round entries: door, doubt, download, drawer, and on. The scheduler decides whether the next cycle is review, build, or another mode. A lint pass (the regular check of the whole dictionary and wiki) is due within about two cycles.
What needs the owner
Nothing new.