2026-10-08 (6): originality — the twenty-fourth check, one definition rewritten
Cycle 2 of the 04:44 UTC run. Run id 20261008T045511Z-jmu01g.
What this cycle did
The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py, the script that picks each cycle's job) runs an originality check every tenth run, and this was run 310. An originality check makes sure the dictionary's wording is our own and not copied from a published dictionary. The tool picked ten fields at random: two usage notes (on potato and set) and eight definitions (from box, write, call, buy, place, consider, joint, and day). I searched the web for the exact wording of each and asked one of the outside reviewer models (reviewer-a) whether each reads as copied. Search results decide the verdict; the model's opinion is only a second signal, because past checks showed it is unreliable in both directions.
What the searches found
- Seven fields had no published match at all: the two usage notes, and the definitions of nothing to write home about (under write), call meaning "give a name to", in the first place (under place), consider meaning "think about a fact when judging", the drug sense of joint, and day in, day out (under day). Each is marked original.
- buy, sense 1, reads get something by paying money for it. A learner's dictionary has to obtain something by paying money for it. This is a short, plain definition that almost any dictionary would write the same way, so it is marked generic overlap and kept.
- box, sense 1, read a container with flat, stiff sides and usually a lid, used for keeping or carrying things. Two learner's dictionaries describe a box with the same frame (stiff sides, and a lid that is often or sometimes there). The wording was not identical, but the frame was close enough that, as with bag and package in the previous check, I rewrote it: a container with corners and a flat bottom, often closed at the top, for keeping, carrying, or sending things.
What the reviewer model said
Reviewer-a, asked with its reasoning switched off (which earlier checks found gives cleaner answers), said "copied" for all eight definitions. Each time it named one well-known dictionary and gave as the "quote" our own wording, sometimes with to added. Search found none of those quotes. This is the same pattern seen in earlier checks, and it is recorded in wiki/notes/reviewer-noise.md. It said "cannot tell" for the two usage notes.
The re-review of box
A rewritten definition is a change to the entry, so the whole box entry went back through the reviewer panel. The reviewers did not object to the new definition. They raised six other issues; I agreed with four:
- The post-office sense said the address form is PO Box. American usage commonly writes P.O. Box, so the explanation now gives both, says this is the form used in an address, and the example uses P.O. box in a sentence. The word combinations a post office box and a P.O. box were added.
I rejected two: reviewer-a said a sports ground does not have a "box" in the theater sense, but stadiums do have press boxes and private boxes; and it wanted a collocation for the box (television), which the explanation already covers ("always the box").
Spend
US$0.12 (the reviewer question and the panel on box). The day (2026-10-08) stands at US$4.01 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed.
What is next
The scheduler picks the next cycle's job. The record of this check is reviews/originality/2026-10-08.md.
For the owner
Nothing new needs a ruling.