2026-10-08: review — a second reading of crime to promise
Cycle 1 of the 04:44 UTC run. Run id 20261008T044413Z-jmu01g.
What this cycle did
The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py, which picks each cycle's job) chose review: a second reading of entries that have been through the reviewer panel only once. There were no draft entries waiting, so I took the twelve oldest such entries, all written on 2026-10-02: the nouns crime, criminal, crop, crowd, cry, cup, curtain, custom, and customer, and the verbs plant, print, and promise.
A review cycle has two parts. First I read each entry as an editor, looking for missing senses, idioms, and learner errors. Then the two outside reviewer models (reviewer-a and reviewer-b) read every field again, and I decided on each of their objections, keeping a logged reason for each decision in reviews/decisions.jsonl.
Before starting, I checked for unfinished work left by earlier runs: there were no open pull requests and no stray branches, and the inbox (where the owner leaves instructions) was empty.
What I changed by hand
- crop was missing a common use: a thick growth of hair on someone's head (he had a thick crop of curly hair). It is now a fourth sense.
- cup, sense 1, said a cup has a handle and is used for hot drinks, but one of its own examples was about paper cups at work, which have no handle and often hold cold drinks. The definition now says usually with a handle and especially hot drinks.
- curtain: the theater sense gained the word combination a curtain call (when the performers come back on stage to be applauded).
I also checked the idioms that belong to these words by the keyword rule (an idiom goes under its first noun). The cream of the crop is already under cream, and two's company, three's a crowd under company, so nothing needed to move.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The reviewers raised 25 issues, 24 from reviewer-a and 1 from reviewer-b. I agreed with 13 and fixed the entries in my own words:
- cup: the cooking sense now says a cup is a fixed amount, not just any unit; the prize sense says the cup is usually made of metal; the notes comparing cup, mug, and glass no longer claim that every mug has straight sides and no saucer, or that cold drinks at home always come in a glass.
- crop: my first wording for the new hair sense, a thick amount of hair, was unnatural; it now reads a thick growth of hair.
- cry: the sense a period of crying (have a good cry) had an "informal" label; this use is ordinary English, so the label was removed.
- print: the newspaper sense mixed two things, producing many copies of a book or paper and including a story or letter in a newspaper. The second is now a subsense of its own with its own examples, and the synonym run is marked as applying only to newspapers.
- promise: the usage note said a promise reported in the past must use would; it now says would is usual. A learner-error note that said "a promise is about the future" now applies only when the promise is about the future. A passive example (the job was promised to someone else) is now marked as passive, since the pattern listed beside it is the active one.
I rejected 12. Five were one objection made five ways: reviewer-a said the shop sense of custom (thank you for your custom) should not carry a British label. The house rule is that a region label means mainly used there, and this sense is mainly British, so the label, its example, and its word combinations stay. Reviewer-a also wanted the see-also note on promise to say promise someone the moon, but the phrase is entered under moon as promise the moon, and the note must match it. It said it's a crime to waste food is not informal; this is a deliberate exaggeration used in conversation, so the label stays. Reviewer-b's one issue said a word combination on plant (plant the idea that) needed a verb pattern with a that-clause; the clause belongs to the noun idea, not to the verb.
My new subsense on print first used the word magazine, which is outside the defining vocabulary (the 2,394 plain words that definitions must use), and the vocabulary check caught it; the subsense now says newspaper only.
Spend
US$0.86 for the panel. The day (2026-10-08) stands at US$3.89 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed.
What is next
The next review continues with the oldest one-round entries from report-v onward (2026-10-02 16:48), then cry-v, escape-v, knock-v, laugh-v, and shake-v. When shake-v is opened, shake hands and shake your head should move to hand and head as phrases. About 709 entries remain at one panel round.
For the owner
Nothing new needs a ruling.