2026-10-08 (20) — review: debate to defense, a small block
Run: 20261008T173111Z-ytfbyc, cycle 4 of the 16:44 UTC run. Mode: review. The selector (tools/next_mode.py) chooses the kind of work each cycle does. Review means a second reading of entries that are already published. Each of these entries had one round of the review panel when it was written; this cycle gives it a second. Cycles 1 to 3 (pull requests #327, #328, #329) merged before this cycle began. This is the fourth cycle, the most a run may have, so the run ends here.
What the cycle did
The day's spending cap is US$15, and only US$0.54 was left when this cycle started. A review of twelve entries costs about US$0.65, so I took a block of six instead: the next oldest entries with only one panel round, all written on 2026-10-02. They were debate, debt, decade, decision, decrease, and defense (all nouns).
All six were already full entries, with core ideas, several senses, idioms, usage notes, and learner errors. Reading them by hand, I found only two gaps: debate and decision had no pronunciation note. Both now have one in plain respelling (dih-BATE, dih-SIZH-un). All six passed the closing checks and stay reviewed (published).
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The two outside reviewers raised only six issues. I applied two and rejected four. None needed the owner.
Applied:
- The adaptation note on debt (a note for translators) said the b is silent, that the word rhymes with get, and then "the same is true of doubt". Reviewer-a read this as saying that doubt also rhymes with get. The note now says only that the b is also silent in doubt.
- Decision, sense 2, gave "the judge of a game" as an example of someone in authority. That is an awkward phrase; it now says "the person in charge of a game". (Referee is not yet in the defining vocabulary, the list of plain words that definitions must use.)
Rejected:
- Reviewer-a said the second sense of decade, a named decade such as the nineties, is not a separate sense. It is used differently from "any ten years" (the start of the decade, which decade were you born in?), so it stays.
- Reviewer-b wanted decision making and decision maker moved out of the collocations. Compounds that contain the headword are ordinary collocations in this dictionary.
- Reviewer-b said decrease can be uncountable. That use exists but is rare, so the grammar stays countable.
- A minor formatting comment on the debt note was wrong: get is named as a word, so the double mark is correct.
Spend
US$0.36 this cycle. The day closes the run at US$14.82 of the US$15 cap. The cap resets at midnight UTC.
What did not work
Nothing failed. The small block was a budget decision, not a problem.
What is next
The next run starts after the budget resets. Review continues with definition, degree, delay, demand and the rest of the 2026-10-02 batch. The build queue continues after support. The next lint pass is due within a cycle or two. It should check reviewer-b, which gave complete but empty reviews on all twelve entries of cycle 3 (journal/2026-10-08-19.md).
For the owner
Nothing new needs you from this cycle.