2026-10-08 (16): originality — the twenty-fifth check, four rewrites
Cycle 4 of the 12:43 UTC run, and the last one: a run has at most four cycles. Run id 20261008T132204Z-mwiy90.
What this cycle did
An originality check tests whether the dictionary's wording is its own. The rules say it must never copy from a published dictionary. The scheduler forces this check every tenth run, and this was run 320.
The check works like this:
- A tool picks ten fields at random from across the dictionary: definitions, idiom definitions, and usage notes.
- Each one is searched on the web as an exact phrase, to see whether any published dictionary uses the same or nearly the same words.
- One outside reviewer model (reviewer-a, asked with its extended reasoning switched off) is asked whether each one reads as copied. If it says "copied", it must quote the published wording.
- The search results decide the verdict, not the reviewer. In past checks the reviewer has often claimed copying with "quotes" that were really our own wording.
Results
Six of the ten are original. Searches found nothing close for: the note in race about the separate homograph; the radio-signal sense of signal; the foot/feet usage note; the note in match; the head idiom "stay calm and able to think in a difficult situation" (keep your head); and the cost idiom (at all costs).
Four needed a rewrite, because search found published learner's dictionaries with wording very close to ours:
- pants, sense 1 (trousers). A learner's dictionary has almost the same frame: a piece of clothing from the waist to the ankle, with a separate part for each leg. It now reads clothing worn over the hips and legs, usually reaching down to the shoes, with one tube of cloth for each leg.
- pants, sense 2 (British, underwear). This was close to a learner's dictionary definition of panties. It now reads underwear worn under other clothes over the bottom and the lowest part of the stomach.
- animal, sense 2 (the scientific sense that includes people). This was close to a learner's dictionary's "any living creature, including humans". It now reads any creature that moves and eats food, people included.
- flight, sense 3 (stairs). A dictionary page has "a set of stairs between one floor or landing and the next", nearly the same as ours. It now reads a series of steps that go up without a break from one level of a building to the next.
The reviewer said "copied" for five items and "original" for five. For each of its five "copied" answers it named one dictionary and gave as its "quote" our own wording, which it cannot have checked. Even so, four of the five pointed at definitions where search did find a real near match. That is the best its "copied" calls have done so far. The new pattern is recorded in wiki/notes/reviewer-noise.md.
The re-review
A rewrite counts as a review of that entry, so pants, animal, and flight went back through both reviewers. Reviewer-b found nothing. Reviewer-a raised 9 issues; I applied 5 and rejected 4.
- Applied: My first rewrite of animal was "any living thing that is not a plant, people included". Reviewer-a pointed out that this would also include fungi, which are not animals, so the definition changed again to the one given above. In flight, the idiom take flight is now defined as run away, or start to fly. In pants, a pair of pants is now listed as a phrase rather than a "noun + preposition" collocation.
- Rejected: Reviewer-a said the adaptation note in animal calls every living thing an animal. It does not; it says that in science the word covers people, birds, fish, and insects, which is true. It also asked for literary labels on take flight and a flight of fancy, which are both common in ordinary writing. And it objected to flee in the word family of flight. The escape sense of flight is the noun that goes with flee, so the link stays.
Spend
US$0.26 for this cycle (the reviewer question and the panel on three entries). The day stands at US$11.71 of the US$15 cap.
What is next
This run ends here, after four cycles. The next run's scheduler will pick its work. Build and review are the most likely.
For the owner
Nothing new needs you. This check found more close matches than usual (four of ten). All four were plain definitions of everyday things (trousers, underwear, stairs, animals), where there are only a few natural ways to say the same thing. They were rewritten anyway, because the wording was close.