2026-10-07, 00:43 UTC run, cycle 3: second reading of chest to client
What this cycle did
The mode selector chose review. A review is a second reading of entries that have been checked by the outside reviewers only once. The oldest such entries come first. Entries written in the later cycles of long runs in late September and early October tend to be thinner, so each review also checks for missing common senses, idioms, and learner errors. This cycle took the eleven oldest one-round entries: the nouns chest, chicken, choice, church, circle, citizen, city, claim, class, clay, client, all written on 2026-10-01.
What I added by hand before the reviewers saw them
- New phrases:
- chicken feed (a very small amount of money)
- like a chicken with its head cut off (American; British English says like a headless chicken)
- by choice
- church and state
- you can't fight city hall (American)
- a class act
- New learner errors (common mistakes, with the correct form):
- a pain on my chest (correct: in my chest)
- chicken mixed up with kitchen
- draw a round (correct: draw a circle)
- do a claim (correct: make a claim)
- third class for a school year (correct: third grade in American English, Year 3 in British English)
- Other changes:
- citizen has a new usage note on the difference between a citizen and a resident.
- church now lists churchgoer and churchyard as related words and points to religion, priest, and minister.
- client was redefined so that it no longer says a client always pays. People who get help from a social worker are clients too.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The two outside reviewer models (reviewer-a and reviewer-b) raised 32 issues: 28 from reviewer-a and 4 from reviewer-b. I applied 24 and rejected 8, each with a logged reason. Three entries (city, clay, client) drew no issues at all.
The main fixes:
- church, sense 3, had been defined as any religious group. It now says a Christian group, or all Christians together. The church and state phrase was reworded to match.
- citizen had resident listed as a synonym, which contradicted its own new usage note. Resident now appears only as a word to compare, with a short note. The town sense now mentions rights and duties, and senior citizen is now defined by age, not by whether the person has stopped working.
- class, sense 5, now covers the travel classes, as in first class and economy class. Its "style" sense lost an informal label that the reviewer rightly said it does not need.
- chest had two separate notes comparing it with breast. They are merged into one.
- circle had ring as a synonym of the geometric shape. It was moved to the "round group" sense. The note on theater seats now says American theaters use balcony or mezzanine.
The rejections:
- The chest translation note. It warns that many languages use separate words for the body part and the box. The reviewer read it as a claim about the history of English.
- The chicken learner error I ate a chicken for lunch. It stays, because the meant reading is the meat.
- The church as uncountable. The reviewer called the institutional use uncountable, but the church is a countable noun used with the.
- A "mainly American" label on graduating class. It stays, under the house rule that a region label means a word is mainly used there, not only there.
- Three issues on claim.
- A formal label for stake a claim: the phrase is neutral.
- A doubt about the soup-complaint learner error: it is a real mistake in that context.
- One reviewer-b comment that withdrew itself halfway through.
Linking and vocabulary
Two new definitions first used words outside the defining vocabulary: hurried and then rushing in the chicken phrase, and excellent in a class act. All three were reworded. No new back-links were needed. The cross-reference tool queued two missing target words.
Spend
US$0.90 for the two reviewers. Today's total is US$1.76 of the US$15 cap.
What is next
The next review continues with climate, clock, closet and the other entries from 2026-10-02. Builds continue from project.
For the owner
Nothing new needs you.