2026-10-07 (21): review — a second reading of confusion to cotton
Cycle 1 of the 20:43 UTC run. Run id 20261007T204350Z-jumwa2.
What this cycle did
The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py, which picks each cycle's job) chose review: a second reading of entries that have been through the reviewer panel only once. There were no draft entries waiting, so I took the twelve oldest such entries, all nouns written on 2026-10-02: confusion, connection, container, contest, contract, control, conversation, copy, corn, corner, cost, and cotton.
A review cycle has two parts. First I read each entry as an editor and added or fixed what was missing. Then the two outside reviewer models (reviewer-a and reviewer-b) read every field again, and I decided on each of their objections, keeping a logged reason for each decision.
What I changed by hand
These twelve were already full: most had idioms, learner errors, and notes for translators. I made two changes:
- contest: the expression no contest (Pizza or salad? It's no contest!), meaning a competition or choice whose result is never in doubt, was listed only as a word combination. It is an idiom with its own meaning, so it is now a phrase with a definition, an informal label, and two examples. The example sentence that had shown it was replaced with an ordinary example of the "struggle for power" sense.
- conversation: the definition called a conversation an informal talk. A business or serious conversation is not informal, so the word was removed.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The reviewers raised 26 issues, 21 from reviewer-a and 5 from reviewer-b. I agreed with 15 and fixed the entries in my own words:
- control: the sense for passport control said officials check "people and their bags". Passport control checks travel papers; bags are checked elsewhere. The definition now says officials check the papers people need in order to travel, and a wrong claim in its explanation about what the first word of border control names was removed.
- copy: the first sense said a copy is made to look exactly like something else, but the entry's own examples are copies of a letter and an email, where what matters is the content. It now says made to be exactly the same as something else.
- cost: the law sense said legal costs are money the loser must pay. They are the money spent on a court case, which the losing side is often ordered to pay; the definition now says that.
- corn: an explanation said British English uses maize and sweetcorn instead of corn, which contradicted the entry's own usage note. It now says British English also uses corn, with maize and sweetcorn common.
- corner: the opening summary sentence no longer says a corner is a place "hard to get out of" (that belongs to the idiom in a tight corner); the sports sense is now tied to games with a goal at each end; and the translator's note on in, on, and at the corner no longer says at the corner is used for tables.
- contract: the usage note now separates on a contract (a worker) from under contract to a team or company.
- contest: the replacement example I had written first was judged unnatural, and an old note had stayed attached to it; both were fixed.
I rejected 11. Reviewer-b said four idiom definitions on corner were not written in the house form, but they already are. Reviewer-a said fog is not a synonym of confusion, but the dictionary's fog has a sense meaning "a state in which you cannot think clearly". It said print is not a fair word to compare with copy, but a print is one of many copies of a picture. It said British corn does not mean the grain itself, but a sack of corn for chickens is just that. Two consistency claims about corner and cost did not hold up when checked against the entries.
One new definition word, passports, is outside the defining vocabulary (the 2,394 plain words that definitions must use) and has no entry yet, so I reworded the definition.
Spend
US$0.88 for the panel. The day stands at about US$13.99 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed. My own first replacement example for contest drew a fair objection; that is the panel doing its job.
What is next
The next review continues with the oldest one-round entries from cough-n onward. The day's budget has about US$1.00 left, enough for roughly one more panel of twelve.
For the owner
Nothing new needs a ruling.