2026-10-07 (15): review — a second reading of ankle to conflict
Cycle 3 of the 12:43 UTC run. Run id 20261007T131247Z-l40e1c.
What this cycle did
The scheduler (tools/next_mode.py, which picks each cycle's job) chose review: a second reading of entries that have been through the reviewer panel only once. I took the twelve oldest such entries, all written on 2026-10-02: ankle, brick, cream, explode, fiber, frame, gray, oar, propeller, shelf, confidence, and conflict.
A review cycle has two parts. First I read each entry as an editor and added what was missing. Then the two outside reviewer models read every field again, and I decided on each of their objections.
What I added by hand
These twelve were already fairly complete; earlier build runs had given most of them idioms, learner errors, and notes. I added:
- frame: a sixth sense, one of the parts of a game of bowling or of games played with balls on a table (he won the first three frames).
- shelf: the phrase on the shelf, meaning not being dealt with for now. Its explanation also notes the old British use about unmarried women, which now sounds offensive.
- cream: a see-also link to ice cream.
- propeller: the definition said the blades turn round, which is British wording; it now says turn.
- oar: the phrase rest on your oars. Reviewer-a said this is not an established idiom with the meaning I gave it, and that I had confused it with rest on your laurels. I was not sure enough of the idiom to keep it, so I removed it again.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The two reviewers raised 31 issues, 30 of them from reviewer-a. I agreed with 22 and fixed the entries in my own words:
- cream: the definition said cream forms on the top of milk. Cream sold in stores is separated in other ways, so it is now the part of milk that contains most of its fat.
- fiber: the body sense and the food sense were redefined to be more accurate. The literary label on with every fiber of your being was removed, since people use it in everyday emphatic speech. Thread was changed from a synonym to a word to compare, on both entries, because thread is made from fibers rather than being the same thing.
- explode: a note said blow up is usually transitive, which contradicted the entry's own comparison of the three words; it now says with or without an object.
- gray: an example meant to show the "dull, without character" sense (gray office buildings) could just as well be about the color, so it was replaced.
- confidence: the opening summary sentence (the "core idea") was rewritten in two plain sentences.
- shelf: one example of the new phrase was about an injured player. That is a different meaning, so it was replaced.
I rejected nine. Reviewer-a wanted a brick wall treated as something other than brick the material, but the wall is made of brick, and the entry's grammar code already says the word often comes before another noun. It flagged a steel frame as listed under the wrong type of word combination, but it is already under the right one. It said put your oar in is British, but the entry already labels it British.
Three definitions used words outside the defining vocabulary (the 2,394 plain words that definitions must use): snooker, spin, and aside. I reworded them.
Spend
US$0.86 for the panel. The day stands at US$10.10 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed this cycle. One note: the three misplaced back-links named in the lint pass earlier this run (on report, respect, and roof) are left for a later session. They are the links this session's permission check refused to let a script move.
What is next
The next review continues with the oldest one-round entries from confusion-n onward. The run may start one more cycle.
For the owner
Nothing new needs a ruling.